20 Best Pies To Make For Thanksgiving (2023 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Pumpkin pie is the most popular pie to make for Thanksgiving. Other popular pies include apple pie, pecan pie, and sweet potato pie.

20 Best Pies To Make For Thanksgiving

Product Image Product Name Features Price

Abbey Gift Pie for 2 Pie Plates with Recipe – Pecan

  • Measures 1. 5″ deep x 6″ diameter
  • Features a traditional holiday recipe, scaled down for this size
  • Includes separate recipe card

Orion Snack Pies (Choco Pie)

  • Chocolate coated marshmallows
  • Vanilla cream sandwich pie

Farmer's Market Pumpkin Pie Mix, Organic – 15 oz

  • Certified organic
  • Farmer’s market recipe, certified organic sugar and spices already added
  • Make an organic pumpkin pie this year

Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies – 13.1 oz box

  • These tarts are made with finest and purest ingredients.
  • Heat briefly in the microwave to deliver a home bake taste.
  • They are traditionally served warm with fresh cream, creme fraiche, ice cream, custard or brandy butter.

Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)

  • Miller’s Old Fashioned Large 2″ Pot Pie Squares makes any recipe delicious.
  • Quality comes naturally when using the traditional homemade process handed down from Mrs. Miller’s Amish heritage.

Libby's Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy – 30 oz

  • Kosher
  • Good Source of Fiber
  • Low in Fat

Duchess Deluxe Pecan Pie 12 3 oz

  • 12 pies – 3 ounces each Contains 40% additional nuts Best ever personal sized pecan pies Individual wrapped for resale.
  • Product Details.

Walkers Spiced Orange & Cranberry Mince Pies

  • Made in Scotland.
  • It is the perfect treat to serve for the holidays.
  • Great for grocery & gourmet food, food & beverage gifts, holidays, parties.

Katz Mini Pies, Real Fruit, Apple – 5.5 oz

  • Apple

Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey – 7 oz

  • Contains: Soy, Milk, Wheat
  • May Contain: Eggs, Fish
  • Package Quantity: 1

Marie Callender's Pie, Pumpkin – 36 oz

  • Extra Flaky Crust Made from Scratch
  • Kosher Dairy
  • Made with Real Pumpkin

Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate – 25.5 oz

  • 25.5 oz

Edwards Creme Pie, Strawberry – 25 oz

  • With a cookie crust
  • Kosher
  • Thaw & serve

Edwards Key Lime Pie with Cookie Crust – 36 oz box

  • 36 oz

Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pie, Pumpkin – 34 oz

  • Pumpkin

Marie Callender's Pot Pie, Turkey – 10 oz

  • 10 oz

Axe & Sledge Home Made – Lemon Cream Pie

  • Lemon Cream Pie
Abbey Gift Pie for 2 Pie Plates with Recipe – Pecan
  • Measures 1. 5″ deep x 6″ diameter
  • Features a traditional holiday recipe, scaled down for this size
  • Includes separate recipe card
Orion Snack Pies (Choco Pie)
  • Chocolate coated marshmallows
  • Vanilla cream sandwich pie
Farmer's Market Pumpkin Pie Mix, Organic – 15 oz
  • Certified organic
  • Farmer’s market recipe, certified organic sugar and spices already added
  • Make an organic pumpkin pie this year
Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies – 13.1 oz box
  • These tarts are made with finest and purest ingredients.
  • Heat briefly in the microwave to deliver a home bake taste.
  • They are traditionally served warm with fresh cream, creme fraiche, ice cream, custard or brandy butter.
Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)
  • Miller’s Old Fashioned Large 2″ Pot Pie Squares makes any recipe delicious.
  • Quality comes naturally when using the traditional homemade process handed down from Mrs. Miller’s Amish heritage.
Libby's Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy – 30 oz
  • Kosher
  • Good Source of Fiber
  • Low in Fat
Duchess Deluxe Pecan Pie 12 3 oz
  • 12 pies – 3 ounces each Contains 40% additional nuts Best ever personal sized pecan pies Individual wrapped for resale.
  • Product Details.
Walkers Spiced Orange & Cranberry Mince Pies
  • Made in Scotland.
  • It is the perfect treat to serve for the holidays.
  • Great for grocery & gourmet food, food & beverage gifts, holidays, parties.
Katz Mini Pies, Real Fruit, Apple – 5.5 oz
  • Apple
Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey – 7 oz
  • Contains: Soy, Milk, Wheat
  • May Contain: Eggs, Fish
  • Package Quantity: 1
Marie Callender's Pie, Pumpkin – 36 oz
  • Extra Flaky Crust Made from Scratch
  • Kosher Dairy
  • Made with Real Pumpkin
Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate – 25.5 oz
  • 25.5 oz
Edwards Creme Pie, Strawberry – 25 oz
  • With a cookie crust
  • Kosher
  • Thaw & serve
Edwards Key Lime Pie with Cookie Crust – 36 oz box
  • 36 oz
Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pie, Pumpkin – 34 oz
  • Pumpkin
Marie Callender's Pot Pie, Turkey – 10 oz
  • 10 oz
Axe & Sledge Home Made – Lemon Cream Pie
  • Lemon Cream Pie

1. Abbey Gift Pie for 2 Pie Plates with Recipe – Pecan

Abbey Gift Pie for 2 Pie Plates with Recipe - Pecan

  • Measures 1. 5″ deep x 6″ diameter
  • Features a traditional holiday recipe, scaled down for this size
  • Includes separate recipe card
  • Can be displayed on easel stand (available separately)
  • High quality and durable

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
Christianbook.com
Megabella Treasures

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Occasion Anniversary
Shape Round
Number of Pieces 1
Product Care Instructions Hand Wash Only
Is Microwaveable Yes

Reviews From Real Customers

GIUGNO
Mmercer
Scarlett99

2. Orion Snack Pies (Choco Pie)

Orion Snack Pies (Choco Pie)

  • Chocolate coated marshmallows
  • Vanilla cream sandwich pie

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 7.09 x 1.97 x 7.87 inches; 12.7 Ounces

Reviews From Real Customers

nguyen.d
ksenia .i
houda.m

3. Farmer’s Market Pumpkin Pie Mix, Organic – 15 oz

Farmer's Market Pumpkin Pie Mix, Organic - 15 oz

  • Certified organic
  • Farmer’s market recipe, certified organic sugar and spices already added
  • Make an organic pumpkin pie this year
  • Grown in the USA

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay
Walmart – Pekks International
Vitacost.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Measure 85g
Food Servings Per Container 15
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

JacquelineL
LadyLiberTEA
Tim from Missouri

4. Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies – 13.1 oz box

Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies - 13.1 oz box

  • These tarts are made with finest and purest ingredients.
  • Heat briefly in the microwave to deliver a home bake taste.
  • They are traditionally served warm with fresh cream, creme fraiche, ice cream, custard or brandy butter.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
BritishCornerShop.co.uk
Walkers Shortbread
World Market

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Total Fat 10g
Saturated Fat 5g
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 25.00mg
Sodium 75mg

Reviews From Real Customers

Bammie

5. Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)

Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)

  • Miller’s Old Fashioned Large 2″ Pot Pie Squares makes any recipe delicious.
  • Quality comes naturally when using the traditional homemade process handed down from Mrs. Miller’s Amish heritage.
  • Since 1973 Mrs. Miller’s Pasta have been producing the finest egg noodles available in a variety of sizes and flavors.
  • Simple and quality ingredients.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – deals4u001
Grocery.com Store
Bonanza – M&M Trading

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 12 x 2 x 9 inches; 2.05 Pounds

6. Libby’s Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy – 30 oz

Libby's Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy - 30 oz

  • Kosher
  • Good Source of Fiber
  • Low in Fat
  • Gluten Free
  • All Natural; No Preservatives

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Fred Meyer
ShopFoodEx.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Measure 87g
Food Servings Per Container About 10
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Fat Free

Reviews From Real Customers

Grandma Mary

7. Duchess Deluxe Pecan Pie 12 3 oz

Duchess Deluxe Pecan Pie 12 3 oz

  • 12 pies – 3 ounces each Contains 40% additional nuts Best ever personal sized pecan pies Individual wrapped for resale.
  • Product Details.
  • Duchess Deluxe Pecan Pies taste deliciously homemade. Each 3-ounce pie is perfectly sized for an after-dinner dessert or middle-of-the-day break.
  • Specifications.
  • Net weight: 2.25 pounds (36 ounces).

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Sam’s Club

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Calories per Serving 340
Number of Servings 12
Regional Cuisine American
Food Aisle Pantry

Reviews From Real Customers

DK
MelD
Aida

8. Walkers Spiced Orange & Cranberry Mince Pies

Walkers Spiced Orange & Cranberry Mince Pies

  • Made in Scotland.
  • It is the perfect treat to serve for the holidays.
  • Great for grocery & gourmet food, food & beverage gifts, holidays, parties.
  • Suitable for vegetarians.
  • Store in a cool, dry place.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walkers Shortbread
World Market
British Food Shop

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

SheDevl
Sue
Allybaba51

9. Katz Mini Pies, Real Fruit, Apple – 5.5 oz

Katz Mini Pies, Real Fruit, Apple - 5.5 oz

  • Apple

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Grocery.com Store

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1 PIE
Food Serving Size Measure 39g
Food Servings Per Container 4
Allergens CONTAINS: EGGS, CORN.
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

T.R.
C.P.

10. Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey – 7 oz

Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey - 7 oz

  • Contains: Soy, Milk, Wheat
  • May Contain: Eggs, Fish
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Net weight: 7 Ounces

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Fred Meyer
pointy.com/shops/usa/california/angels-camp/altaville-marketcraft-beer-liquorlocal-winesporting-goodsat-and-t-verizon-prepaid-cell-accessory
La Favorita Market Rancho

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1 pie
Food Serving Size Measure 198g
Food Servings Per Container 1
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, SOY, WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

heather.s

11. Marie Callender’s Pie, Pumpkin – 36 oz

Marie Callender's Pie, Pumpkin - 36 oz

  • Extra Flaky Crust Made from Scratch
  • Kosher Dairy
  • Made with Real Pumpkin
  • Serve with a Dollop of Reddi-Wip

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Fred Meyer
Boxed Market
Albion Mercantile Co

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 pie
Food Serving Size Measure 128g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: EGG, MILK, WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

Nancy11

12. Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate – 25.5 oz

Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate - 25.5 oz

  • 25.5 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Target
Fred Meyer
La Favorita Market Rancho

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 Pie
Food Serving Size Measure 90g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, SOY.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

leilani.s

13. Edwards Creme Pie, Strawberry – 25 oz

Edwards Creme Pie, Strawberry - 25 oz

  • With a cookie crust
  • Kosher
  • Thaw & serve

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Instacart

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 PIE
Food Serving Size Measure 89g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, SOY.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

brandie.c
Beunah
roshele

14. Edwards Key Lime Pie with Cookie Crust – 36 oz box

Edwards Key Lime Pie with Cookie Crust - 36 oz box

  • 36 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Target
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 PIE
Food Serving Size Measure 128g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, EGGS, SOY.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

karen.c
KeylimePieLover
Dela

15. Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pie, Pumpkin – 34 oz

Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pie, Pumpkin - 34 oz

  • Pumpkin

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Boxed Market

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 PIE
Food Serving Size Measure 121g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: WHEAT, EGGS, MILK
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

16. Marie Callender’s Pot Pie, Turkey – 10 oz

Marie Callender's Pot Pie, Turkey - 10 oz

  • 10 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Fred Meyer
Boxed Market

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1 PIE
Food Serving Size Measure 283g
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, SOY, WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Caffeine Free

Reviews From Real Customers

DisappointedInFL

17. Collin Street Bakery Pecan Pie

Collin Street Bakery Pecan Pie

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Collin Street Bakery

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Servings per Package 8 | 1 lbs 10 oz

Reviews From Real Customers

JOSEPH C.
John W.

18. Sara Lee Pie, Dutch Apple – 34 oz

Sara Lee Pie, Dutch Apple - 34 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
La Favorita Market Rancho

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 0.125 PIE
Food Serving Size Measure 121g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

19. Southern Shine Apple Pie – 750 ml

Southern Shine Apple Pie - 750 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Total Wine & More

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

Desert Moonshine
ELDRIDGE
Bretmiester

20. Axe & Sledge Home Made – Lemon Cream Pie

Axe & Sledge Home Made - Lemon Cream Pie

  • Lemon Cream Pie

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
GNC
N101 Nutrition
Nutrition Faktory
Supplement Xpress

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 2 Scoops
Food Serving Size Measure 113g
Food Servings Per Container 25
Allergens Contains: Milk Allergen Warning: Manufactured in a facility which processes Milk, Eggs, Fish, Shellfish, Tree Nuts, Peanuts, Wheat and Soybeans
Rich Ingredients Whole Grain Oat Flour, Whey Protein Isolate, Whey Protein Concentrate, Sweet Potato Powder, Soluble Corn Fiber (Fibersol-2), Brown Rice Protein, Egg White Powder, Natural & Artificial Flavors, Beef Protein, Pea Protein, Medium Chain Triglycerides (75%), Sucralose, Gum Blend (Gum Acacia, Guar Gum, Xanthan Gum), Sodium Chloride, DigeSEB, a Proprietary Enzyme Blend:(Amylases, Lactase, Proteases, Lipase, Cellulase), Organic Chicken Broth Powder, Sunflower Lecithin

Reviews From Real Customers

JULIE P.
Mack G.
Benjamin R.

Best Pies To Make For Thanksgiving Buying Guides

Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie is a fall favorite and perfect for Thanksgiving. While there are many ways to make a pumpkin pie, we’ve compiled a list of our favorite recipes for the perfect holiday dessert.

1. Classic Pumpkin Pie: This recipe is from America’s Test Kitchen and is the perfect balance of sweet and spice. The secret to the perfect pumpkin pie is using a combination of canned and fresh pumpkin puree.

2. Eggnog Pumpkin Pie: This festive twist on pumpkin pie from Martha Stewart is sure to be a hit at your Thanksgiving feast. The key to this recipe is using good quality eggnog and freshly grated nutmeg.

3. Maple Pumpkin Pie: This recipe from Bon Appetit is perfect for those who love the flavors of fall. The maple syrup and pumpkin combine to create a delicious and unique pie.

4. Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie: This rich and creamy pie from Food Network is the perfect dessert for cheesecake lovers. The pumpkin and cheesecake flavors complement each other perfectly.

5. Chocolate Pumpkin Pie: This indulgent pie from Epicurious is perfect for chocolate lovers. The chocolate and pumpkin combine to create a rich and decadent pie.

Apple Pie

There are many different types of apple pies that can be made for Thanksgiving, but one of the most classic and simple recipes is for a traditional apple pie. This type of pie is typically made with a combination of tart and sweet apples, such as Granny Smith and Honeycrisp, and is spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger.

The filling is enclosed in a flaky pastry crust, and the pie is often served with a scoop of ice cream or a dollop of whipped cream.

Pecan Pie

Pecan pie is a classic Thanksgiving dessert that is relatively easy to make. There are many recipes for pecan pie, but most include a mixture of corn syrup, sugar, eggs, butter, and pecans. Pecan pie is typically served with whipped cream or ice cream.

Sweet Potato Pie

There are many pies that can be made for Thanksgiving, but sweet potato pie is definitely one of the most popular. Sweet potato pie is typically made with a cooked and mashed sweet potato filling, and is often spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger.

The filling is then placed in a pre-baked pie crust and baked until set. Once cooled, sweet potato pie is typically served with whipped cream or ice cream.

Cherry Pie

There are many pies that can be made for Thanksgiving, but one of the most classic and well-loved pies is cherry pie. Cherry pie is typically made with a double crust, filled with sweet cherries, and then baked until the crust is golden brown and the filling is bubbly.

This pie is the perfect addition to any Thanksgiving feast and is sure to please everyone at the table.

Blueberry Pie

There are many pies that can be made for Thanksgiving, but one of the most popular is blueberry pie. This pie is usually made with a blueberry filling and a flaky pie crust. Some people also like to add a streusel topping to their blueberry pie.

Rhubarb Pie

There isn’t a definitive answer to this question as everyone has different preferences when it comes to pie. Some people might say that pumpkin pie is the best type of pie to make for Thanksgiving, while others might say that apple pie is the way to go.

Ultimately, it really depends on what you and your guests prefer. If you’re looking for a specific recipe, you could try making a classic rhubarb pie or a rhubarb custard pie.

Peach Pie

There are many pies that can be made for Thanksgiving, but peach pie is definitely one of the best. There are many recipes for peach pie, but one of the simplest and most delicious is to use fresh peaches, sugar, flour, butter, and a dash of cinnamon.

The key to making a great peach pie is to use ripe, juicy peaches that are not too soft. The best way to do this is to buy peaches that are already ripe and then let them sit out for a day or two so that they soften slightly.

Once the peaches are soft, they can be easily mashed and the sugar, flour, butter, and cinnamon can be mixed in. The pie dough can be made from scratch or bought pre-made. Once the dough is rolled out, the peach mixture can be placed in the middle and the dough can be crimped around the edges.

The pie can then be baked at a high temperature until the dough is golden brown and the filling is bubbly.

Conclusion

Some of the most popular pies to make for the holiday include pumpkin, apple, pecan, and sweet potato.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment