Best Whiskey For An Old Fashioned (2024 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

If you're a whiskey lover, you know that an old fashioned is a classic cocktail that you can't go wrong with. But with so many different types of whiskey on the market, how do you know which one is the best for an old fashioned? Here are five key points to consider when looking for the best whiskey for an old fashioned:

1. Flavor profile: The flavor of the whiskey is one of the most important factors to consider when making an old fashioned. Look for a whiskey with a strong, bold flavor that can stand up to the sweetness of the sugar and bitters.

2. Age: The age of the whiskey can also impact its flavor profile. Older whiskeys tend to have a smoother, more complex flavor, while younger whiskeys can be more intense and bold.

3. Type of whiskey: There are many different types of whiskey to choose from, including bourbon, rye, and Scotch. Each type has its own unique flavor profile, so choose one that appeals to your taste buds.

4. Price: While you don't want to break the bank, it's important to remember that a good quality whiskey will likely cost more than a lower quality one. Look for a whiskey that fits within your budget but still has a good reputation.

5. Personal preference: At the end of the day, the best whiskey for an old fashioned is the one that you enjoy drinking the most. Don't be afraid to try different types and brands until you find one that you love.

In summary, when looking for the best whiskey for an old fashioned, consider the flavor profile, age, type of whiskey, price, and personal preference. With these factors in mind, you'll be sure to find a whiskey that makes the perfect old fashioned cocktail.

10 Best Whiskey For An Old Fashioned

1. Kanars Whiskey Glasses Set Of 4 With Luxury Box – 10 Oz Rocks Barware For Scotch, Bourbon, Liquor And Cocktails.

KANARS Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses with Luxury Box is a high-quality set of four rocks barware glasses that are perfect for scotch, bourbon, liquor, and cocktail drinks. With its elegant packaging, this set is the ideal gift for any whiskey lover, be it for a wedding, birthday, or anniversary celebration. Each whiskey glass tumbler is carefully packaged in a unique, elegant gift box that adds to its exceptional value.

The KANARS whiskey glass is made of the best quality lead-free crystal, which offers excellent clarity, perfect for bourbon, scotch, and whiskey. Its diamond-like detailing adds texture and brilliant refraction, making it sparkle beautifully in the light. The lowball glass is designed to be unique and stylish, with a stunning old-fashioned cocktail glass set that has a timeless design. It is not only a glass but also an artwork that fits effortlessly in your hand, making it perfect for tasting your favorite bourbon or scotch on the rocks.

The KANARS whiskey glassware has a solid and heavy base design, making it highly breakage-resistant thanks to the Platinum Glass production process. The glasses are heavier than others, giving you a real sense of strength and substantiality. They are virtually unbreakable and dishwasher safe, making them durable enough to retain their sparkle for many years to come.

At KANARS, customer satisfaction is our top priority, and we guarantee that our brand values are quality, trust, and integrity. We offer a 30-day money-back guarantee and free replacement, along with professional after-sale service within 24 hours. With KANARS Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses with Luxury Box, you can enjoy your scotch or bourbon in style and with the assurance of a high-quality product.

2. Set Of 4 Italian Made Whiskey Glasses, Perfect For Whiskey Gifts.

The Godinger Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses are a must-have addition to any barware collection. Expertly crafted in Italy, these sleek and contemporary glasses are designed to enhance the décor of any space. These timeless glasses are perfect for serving a range of beverages, from whiskey, bourbon, scotch, and cocktails to wine, juice, and water.

The thick base of these glasses provides stability and ensures that they won't shatter easily, while the cylindrical shape is designed to provide a comfortable grip and easy use. These glasses are lead-free and dishwasher safe, making them a practical choice for everyday use.

The Godinger Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses make for a wonderful gift set for whiskey drinkers, cocktail lovers, or anyone who appreciates elegant and stylish barware. They are ideal for occasions such as birthdays, weddings, housewarmings, Father's Day, or any other special event.

Godinger has been specializing in handcrafted silver, crystal, stainless steel, and alternative metal giftware since 1973. Their range of products includes wedding gifts, barware, dinnerware, bakeware, tea sets, and frames. With Godinger, you are sure to find the perfect item for any occasion. Their products are available at all major retailers across the US and Canada.

In summary, the Godinger Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses are a stylish and practical addition to any barware collection. Designed and crafted in Italy, these glasses are perfect for serving a range of beverages and are sure to impress guests with their timeless elegance.

3. Opayly Set Of 4 12oz Old Fashioned Glasses For Whiskey And Cocktails, Ideal Gift For Men And Women At Home Or Bar.

OPAYLY is a brand that is committed to creating high-quality wine glasses that raise the practical products of life to a certain level of art. Their Whiskey Glasses Old Fashioned Glasses Set of 4 is an excellent example of their commitment to quality and design.

One of the most impressive features of this product is the lifetime warranty and 24/7 customer service that OPAYLY offers. Their supplier is one of the largest glass manufacturers in the world, providing hundreds of millions of high-quality glasses each year. OPAYLY aims to create a variety of perfect high-quality wine glasses for customers, and they only produce good products.

The design of these glasses is unique and carefully crafted. The bottom is designed with classic old-fashioned printing patterns, and the glasses are hand-blown by technicians with more than 10 years of experience. Skilled techniques are used to blow molten glass into the mold, and each piece is refurbished 2-3 times on average to ensure perfection. The result is a set of glasses that maintains its original luster and purity even after multiple washes.

These whiskey glasses are made of the highest quality lead-free crystal, which maximizes the transparency and brightness of every glass body. They are ideal for whiskey, bourbon, scotch, cocktail, vodka, rum, white wine, and red wine, as they vividly express the true color of the beverage. The glasses feel heavy and well-made, with a weight of 1.02 lbs and a capacity of 12 oz. They are formed in one piece, with no traces of joints or seams, producing a flawless natural appearance. The toughness of the material and the transparency of the glass are above market standards.

The Whiskey Glasses Old Fashioned Glasses Set of 4 is an excellent gift for any whiskey lover. The glasses come packaged in an exquisite gift box, making it a great gift for any occasion, especially weddings, birthdays, and anniversaries. It is an excellent gift for men, women, fathers, and friends. The inside of the gift box is filled with pearl cotton to ensure that the glasses will not break during transit. If the glasses are damaged during transit, OPAYLY offers a 100% refund or free replacement.

Overall, the OPAYLY Whiskey Glasses Old Fashioned Glasses Set of 4 is an excellent product that is sure to impress any whiskey lover. With its unique design, high-quality materials, and lifetime warranty, it is an investment that will last a lifetime.

4. Jbho Crystal Double Old Fashioned Glasses – 12oz, Set Of 2, Perfect For Whiskey, Cocktails And Oversized Ice Cubes.

The JBHO Hand Blown Crystal Double Old Fashioned Cocktail Glasses are a stylish addition to any bar or dining table. With a classic yet innovative design, these glasses feature creative shapes at the bottom and a raised pentagonal pattern that deepens the reflection of any wine color in the light. The straight cup wall molding makes it easy to clean, ensuring that these glasses will be a favorite for years to come.

Made from lead-free premium crystal glass, these glasses are brighter and can correctly express the color of the wine in the glass. The quality of nice restaurant glassware is evident in these luxurious and luminous glasses. They are perfect for use as bar tools, liqueur and spirits drinkware, and make a great gift for Father's Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Christmas or any special occasion.

The solid and thick base of these glasses makes them feel textured in your hands, and the lead-free crystal block up to 1 cm thick ensures they are sturdy and durable. The set includes two 12 fluid-oz whiskey glasses, hand-made from premium crystal glass that is incredibly transparent and elegant. The large enough size can accommodate oversized ice cubes/whiskey stones, making them the perfect partner for your whisky.

JBHO offers a 1-year satisfaction guarantee on these glasses, providing peace of mind for whisky enthusiasts. If they are damaged in any way upon arrival, a replacement set will be sent free of charge. Any bubbles or defects can also be addressed within 45 days, with a commitment to serving customers until they are satisfied.

In conclusion, the JBHO Hand Blown Crystal Double Old Fashioned Cocktail Glasses are a premium glassware option for those who appreciate quality and style. The combination of classic and innovative design, lead-free premium crystal glass, solid and thick base, and satisfaction guarantee make them a worthwhile investment for any home bar or special occasion.

5. Dublin Whiskey Bar Set: Decanter, 6 Tumblers, Mirrored Tray

The Dublin Whiskey Bar Set is the perfect addition to any home bar or entertaining space. This set includes a beautifully crafted Whiskey decanter, six old fashioned tumbler glasses, and a mirrored display tray, all designed to enhance your drinking experience.

Crafted from lead-free crystal, the Dublin Collection decanter is a stunning way to serve your favorite Whiskey, Scotch, Bourbon, Vodka, or Wine. The decanter features a classic shape with intricate detailing, creating a timeless design that will never go out of style. The matching old fashioned tumbler glasses are also crafted from lead-free crystal, ensuring that your favorite spirits are served in the finest quality glassware.

The set is completed with a mirrored display tray, which not only adds a touch of elegance to your home bar, but also provides a convenient way to serve your drinks. The tray is made from high-quality materials and is designed to be both functional and stylish.

Since 1973, Godinger has been a leading name in the giftware industry. Specializing in handcrafted silver, pewter, crystal, stainless, and alternative metal giftware, Godinger has a wide range of products perfect for any special occasion. From wedding gifts to candlesticks, barware, bakeware, tea sets, and frames, Godinger has something for everyone.

The Dublin Whiskey Bar Set is just one example of Godinger's commitment to quality and craftsmanship. This set is available at all major retailers across the US and Canada, making it easy to add a touch of sophistication to your home bar or entertaining space. Whether you are a Whiskey connoisseur or just enjoy a good drink, the Dublin Whiskey Bar Set is the perfect way to elevate your drinking experience.

6. Smoketop Cocktail Smoker Kit For Cocktails, Whiskey, & Bourbon By Middleton Mixology.

The SmokeTop Cocktail Smoker Kit by Middleton Mixology is an innovative and unique product for cocktail lovers. This at-home smoker kit is made in the USA from solid American Cherry and offers users a heady, full sensory experience that is sure to leave a lasting impression.

The SmokeTop is the original at-home drink smoker and is perfect for anyone who wants to create an old fashioned style smoking glass. It works perfectly with any cocktails, whiskey, or bourbon, making it a versatile addition to any home bar.

The SmokeTop's simple yet elegant design offers anyone the chance to be a professional bartender and wow their friends with their mixology skills. The cherry chips provide a soothing aroma and a perfect accent to any drink, making it a great addition to parties or gatherings.

Not just a cocktail smoker, the SmokeTop can also be used to cold smoke a variety of foods and drinks, including spirits, meats, cheese, coffee, and even ice-cream. This user-friendly at-home cold smoker is perfect for a variety of culinary adventures.

Overall, the SmokeTop Cocktail Smoker Kit is an excellent choice for anyone who wants to take their cocktail game to the next level. Its unique design, versatility, and ease of use make it a must-have for any home bar or kitchen. Plus, its American-made construction ensures that it is built to last, making it a great investment for years to come.

7. Waterford Lismore Double Old Fashioned, Set Of 6

The Waterford Lismore Double Old Fashioned set is a stunning addition to any home bar or glassware collection. Crafted from the finest crystal, this set of six glasses boasts a versatile design that can be used for a variety of spirits, water, and juices. Each glass is elegantly decorated with the signature diamond and wedge cuts of the iconic Lismore pattern, adding a touch of sophistication to any drink.

The Lismore pattern has been a beloved Waterford design for over 60 years, and these glasses are a beautiful example of the intricate craftsmanship that goes into each piece. The diamond and wedge cuts catch the light beautifully, creating a mesmerizing display that is sure to impress guests. The glasses are also perfectly weighted and balanced, making them a joy to hold and use.

The set comes beautifully presented in classic Waterford packaging, making it an excellent gift for weddings, housewarmings, or any other special occasion. The packaging not only looks elegant, but it also protects the glasses during transit and storage.

To keep the glasses looking their best, it is recommended to hand wash them with a soft cloth. This will help to prevent scratches and other damage that can occur in the dishwasher. With proper care, these glasses will provide years of enjoyment and become a cherished part of any home bar or glassware collection.

Overall, the Waterford Lismore Double Old Fashioned set is a must-have for anyone who appreciates fine craftsmanship and elegant design. Whether using them for a special occasion or enjoying a relaxing drink at home, these glasses are sure to elevate any beverage and make it feel like a true luxury.

8. Vintage Call Me Old Fashioned Whiskey Funny T Shirt T-Shirt

The Vintage Call Me Old Fashioned Whiskey Funny T Shirt T-Shirt is an excellent choice for individuals who enjoy classic cocktails and have a great sense of humor. This t-shirt features a distressed design that showcases the wearer's love for classic cocktails such as the old fashioned, which is a popular drink in Wisconsin, and is made with brandy.

The t-shirt is made of high-quality materials and has a lightweight, classic fit that makes it comfortable to wear. It also features double-needle sleeve and bottom hem, which ensures durability and longevity.

This t-shirt is an excellent gift for whiskey or brandy cocktail lovers who appreciate vintage designs and humorous messages. It is perfect for occasions such as birthdays, holidays, or any other special event where you want to give a unique and memorable gift.

Whether you prefer bourbon, whiskey, or whisky, this t-shirt is an excellent addition to your wardrobe. It is versatile and can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. You can wear it to a casual gathering with friends or dress it up with a blazer for a night out on the town.

In summary, the Vintage Call Me Old Fashioned Whiskey Funny T Shirt T-Shirt is an excellent choice for individuals who enjoy classic cocktails, vintage designs, and humorous messages. It is made of high-quality materials, has a lightweight, classic fit, and features double-needle sleeve and bottom hem. It is a great gift for any whiskey or brandy cocktail lover and can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion.

9. Tritan Whiskey Glasses – 24 Pack, Unbreakable & Dishwasher Safe.

The TOSSWARE RESERVE 12oz Old Fashion SET OF 24 is a premium quality, unbreakable plastic glassware set that offers a high level of convenience and durability without sacrificing on style or sophistication. These glasses are made from Tritan material, which is BPA-free and dishwasher safe, making them an ideal choice for any occasion.

Featuring a classic design with a crystalline pattern and heavy handweight, these glasses are perfect for serving your favorite wine, cocktails, juices, desserts, and more. With a capacity of 12 ounces, they are also suitable for serving whiskey, Scotch, vodka, and other spirits.

One of the key advantages of the TOSSWARE RESERVE glasses is their unbreakable construction. Unlike traditional glassware, these glasses are made from Tritan material, which is highly resistant to impact, heat, and chemicals. This makes them an ideal choice for outdoor events, pool parties, and other situations where traditional glassware might pose a safety hazard.

Despite their durability, the TOSSWARE RESERVE glasses have a crystal-clear appearance and feel just like glass. The perfect hand weight adds to their authenticity and makes them a pleasure to use. Whether you are enjoying a quiet evening at home or hosting a large gathering, these glasses are sure to impress your guests and elevate your drinking experience.

In conclusion, the TOSSWARE RESERVE 12oz Old Fashion SET OF 24 is an excellent choice for anyone looking for a high-quality, durable, and stylish glassware set. With its unbreakable construction and crystal-clear appearance, this set is perfect for both indoor and outdoor use, making it a versatile addition to any home or bar. Whether you are sipping on your favorite whiskey or enjoying a refreshing cocktail, these glasses are sure to enhance your drinking experience and provide you with years of enjoyment.

10. Liiton Grand Canyon Whiskey Glasses Set Of 4 With Raised Canyon For Quick Chill Without Ice – Heavy Rocks Glasses Gift Set.

The LIITON Grand Canyon Whiskey Glasses Set of 4 is a unique and functional addition to any whiskey lover's collection. These one-of-a-kind glasses feature a stunning solid glass Grand Canyon design that is sure to impress.

One of the key benefits of this set of whiskey glasses is that they do not require any additional accessories such as aerators, ice, or whiskey stones. Instead, users can enhance their sipping experience by placing their glass in the freezer to keep their drinks chilled. The custom-cut glass design also aerates the whiskey when it is swirled.

The proprietary Chill Charge System is another innovative feature of these glasses. Made from durable X1 Crystalline, the Canyon chills liquor in just 18 seconds when the whiskey glass is stored in the freezer. This eliminates the need for cumbersome whiskey stones or messy oversized ice cubes.

The LIITON Grand Canyon Whiskey Glasses Set of 4 makes an excellent gift for any whiskey-loving man. Each dishwasher safe rocks glass is individually wrapped in monogrammed paper and protected on all sides, making it an impressive and thoughtful gift. The 4-piece whiskey glass gift box makes a statement and is sure to impress.

At LIITON, customer satisfaction is a top priority. If for any reason a customer is not satisfied with their purchase, free returns are offered with no questions asked.

Overall, the LIITON Grand Canyon Whiskey Glasses Set of 4 is a unique, functional, and impressive addition to any whiskey lover's collection.

Best Whiskey For An Old Fashioned FAQs

Are there any specific brands of whiskey that are known for making the best old fashioned cocktail?

There is no one specific brand of whiskey that is known for making the best old fashioned cocktail. However, there are certain types of whiskey that are commonly used in this classic cocktail. Bourbon whiskey is a popular choice for its sweetness and smoothness, while rye whiskey is preferred for its spiciness and complexity.

Some popular brands of bourbon whiskey for an old fashioned include Maker's Mark, Woodford Reserve, and Bulleit. For rye whiskey, brands like Rittenhouse, Sazerac, and WhistlePig are often used.

Ultimately, the choice of whiskey for an old fashioned comes down to personal preference and the desired flavor profile of the cocktail. It's important to use a high-quality whiskey, as it will greatly affect the taste of the cocktail. Additionally, the other ingredients used in the cocktail, such as bitters, sugar, and citrus, will also impact the overall flavor.

Is a rye whiskey or a bourbon whiskey better for an old fashioned?

Both rye whiskey and bourbon whiskey can be used to make an excellent old fashioned, and the choice ultimately depends on personal preference. Rye whiskey has a spicy, peppery flavor profile that can add complexity and depth to an old fashioned. On the other hand, bourbon whiskey is sweeter and smoother, with notes of vanilla and caramel that can make for a more mellow old fashioned.

Some bartenders may argue that rye whiskey is the traditional choice for an old fashioned, as it was the original spirit used in the cocktail. However, bourbon has become a popular choice in recent years, and many drinkers prefer its smoother taste.

In the end, the best whiskey for an old fashioned is the one you enjoy most. Experiment with both rye and bourbon to find your preferred flavor profile and make your old fashioned your way.

Should I use a single malt or blended whiskey for an old fashioned?

When it comes to making an old fashioned, the choice between single malt and blended whiskey ultimately comes down to personal preference.

However, it's important to note that single malt whiskey tends to have a more distinct and complex flavor profile, with notes of fruit, spice, and oak. This can make it a great choice for those who want a more nuanced and layered cocktail.

On the other hand, blended whiskey is generally smoother and more approachable, with a milder flavor that can be more easily balanced with other ingredients in the cocktail. This can make it a better choice for those who want a classic, straightforward old fashioned.

Ultimately, the choice between single malt and blended whiskey will depend on your individual taste preferences and the specific flavor profile you're looking for in your cocktail. It's always a good idea to experiment with different types of whiskey to find the one that works best for your palate.

What age of whiskey is ideal for an old fashioned cocktail?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question as it largely depends on personal preference. However, most bartenders and whiskey experts recommend using a whiskey that is at least 4 years old for an Old Fashioned cocktail. This is because the aging process imparts flavor and complexity to the whiskey, which can complement the other ingredients in the cocktail. Additionally, older whiskeys are typically smoother and more well-rounded, making them a better choice for sipping cocktails. That being said, some people prefer a younger whiskey for its bold and spicy flavor profile, which can also work well in an Old Fashioned. Ultimately, the best age of whiskey for an Old Fashioned is one that you enjoy the taste of and complements the other ingredients in the cocktail.

What type of whiskey is best for an old fashioned cocktail?

The best type of whiskey for an old fashioned cocktail is a bourbon whiskey. Bourbon is a type of American whiskey that is made primarily from corn and aged in charred oak barrels. Its sweet and smooth flavor profile complements the bitters and sweetener in the cocktail. Some popular bourbon choices for an old fashioned cocktail include Maker's Mark, Bulleit Bourbon, and Woodford Reserve.

Another whiskey that can be used for an old fashioned is rye whiskey. Rye whiskey is made from a mash that contains at least 51% rye and is known for its spicy and peppery flavor profile. Rye whiskey can add a unique kick to the cocktail and is a great alternative for those who prefer a more complex flavor.

Ultimately, the best type of whiskey for an old fashioned cocktail depends on personal preference. Experiment with different types of whiskey to find the perfect one for your taste.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment