20 Best Whiskey For An Old Fashioned (2023 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Whiskey for an old fashioned can be any type of whiskey, but is typically a bourbon or rye. The whiskey is combined with sugar, bitters, and sometimes a twist of citrus peel to create a delicious and strong cocktail.

20 Best Whiskey For An Old Fashioned

Product Image Product Name Features Price

Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey

  • Amber color and oaky aroma
  • One 750 mL bottle of Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey
  • Hints of maple, oak and nutmeg

Buffalo Trace Bourbon – 750 ml

  • Region: Kentucky
  • Alcohol Percentage: 45
  • Package Quantity: 1

Four Roses Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Small Batch – 750 ml

  • Nose: Spicy, rich, mellow, fruity, hints of sweet oak & caramel.
  • Palate: Creamy, mellow, ripened red berries, rich, spicy, well-balanced, moderately sweet.

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 700ml

  • 700 ml

Wild Turkey Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon – 750 ml

  • 750 ml

Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight – 1 lt

  • Color: Woodford Reserve 1L has a light caramel color.
  • Smell: Aromas of vanilla, cereal, toffee and summer fruit.
  • Mouth: I remember almond pastry, caramel and roasted notes cereal; long finish, floral, honey and wood.

Woodford Reserve Miniature Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey – 50 ml bottle

  • Clean, brilliant honey amber.
  • Heavy with rich dried fruit, hints of mint and oranges covered with a dusting of cocoa. Faint vanilla and tobacco spice.

Bulleit Rye Whiskey

  • Released in 2011 it continues to enjoy recognition as one of the highest quality ryes available.
  • Russet in color, with rich oaky aromas.

Bulleit Bourbon 700ml Bottle

  • 700 ml

Woodford Reserve Bourbon 1L Holiday

  • The Finer Details
  • Style
  • Country – United States

Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 750ml

  • Clean, brilliant honey amber.
  • Heavy with rich dried fruit, hints of mint and oranges covered with a dusting of cocoa. Faint vanilla and tobacco spice.

Eagle Rare Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight, Single Barrel – 1.75 lt

  • Tasting Notes.
  • Nose: Complex aromas of toffee, hints of orange peel, herbs, honey, leather and oak.
  • Taste: Bold, dry, oaky flavors with notes of candied almonds and very rich cocoa.

Elijah Craig Bourbon Gift with Glass & Mold – 750 ml

  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
  • Net weight: 750 mL

Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon 750ml

  • Aged between 8 to 12 years in new oak barrels. Produced in Kentucky, America in Small Batches
  • Tasting Notes; Burnished copper in colour this Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey has delightfully complex aromas with notes of vanilla bean

Old Forester Bourbon Whisky, Kentucky Straight – 1.75 l

  • Region: Kentucky
  • Alcohol Percentage: 43.0
  • Package Quantity: 1

Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon 70cl

  • International Wine & Spirits Competition 2019 Gold Medal Best Kentucky Bourbon
  • World Whisky Awards (WWA) 2019 Silver Medal

Old Forester Bourbon Whiskey

  • Rich, full flavour and a smooth character.
  • Aroma: Sharp and sweet with a strong floral character.
  • Taste: Hints of oak and rye grain character and spicy with soft vanilla and light orange notes.

High West Whiskey, Double Rye – 375 ml

  • 375 ml
Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey
  • Amber color and oaky aroma
  • One 750 mL bottle of Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey
  • Hints of maple, oak and nutmeg
Buffalo Trace Bourbon – 750 ml
  • Region: Kentucky
  • Alcohol Percentage: 45
  • Package Quantity: 1
Four Roses Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Small Batch – 750 ml
  • Nose: Spicy, rich, mellow, fruity, hints of sweet oak & caramel.
  • Palate: Creamy, mellow, ripened red berries, rich, spicy, well-balanced, moderately sweet.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 700ml
  • 700 ml
Wild Turkey Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon – 750 ml
  • 750 ml
Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight – 1 lt
  • Color: Woodford Reserve 1L has a light caramel color.
  • Smell: Aromas of vanilla, cereal, toffee and summer fruit.
  • Mouth: I remember almond pastry, caramel and roasted notes cereal; long finish, floral, honey and wood.
Woodford Reserve Miniature Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey – 50 ml bottle
  • Clean, brilliant honey amber.
  • Heavy with rich dried fruit, hints of mint and oranges covered with a dusting of cocoa. Faint vanilla and tobacco spice.
Bulleit Rye Whiskey
  • Released in 2011 it continues to enjoy recognition as one of the highest quality ryes available.
  • Russet in color, with rich oaky aromas.
Bulleit Bourbon 700ml Bottle
  • 700 ml
Woodford Reserve Bourbon 1L Holiday
  • The Finer Details
  • Style
  • Country – United States
Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 750ml
  • Clean, brilliant honey amber.
  • Heavy with rich dried fruit, hints of mint and oranges covered with a dusting of cocoa. Faint vanilla and tobacco spice.
Eagle Rare Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight, Single Barrel – 1.75 lt
  • Tasting Notes.
  • Nose: Complex aromas of toffee, hints of orange peel, herbs, honey, leather and oak.
  • Taste: Bold, dry, oaky flavors with notes of candied almonds and very rich cocoa.
Elijah Craig Bourbon Gift with Glass & Mold – 750 ml
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
  • Net weight: 750 mL
Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon 750ml
  • Aged between 8 to 12 years in new oak barrels. Produced in Kentucky, America in Small Batches
  • Tasting Notes; Burnished copper in colour this Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey has delightfully complex aromas with notes of vanilla bean
Old Forester Bourbon Whisky, Kentucky Straight – 1.75 l
  • Region: Kentucky
  • Alcohol Percentage: 43.0
  • Package Quantity: 1
Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon 70cl
  • International Wine & Spirits Competition 2019 Gold Medal Best Kentucky Bourbon
  • World Whisky Awards (WWA) 2019 Silver Medal
Old Forester Bourbon Whiskey
  • Rich, full flavour and a smooth character.
  • Aroma: Sharp and sweet with a strong floral character.
  • Taste: Hints of oak and rye grain character and spicy with soft vanilla and light orange notes.
High West Whiskey, Double Rye – 375 ml
  • 375 ml

1. Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey

Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey

  • Amber color and oaky aroma
  • One 750 mL bottle of Bulleit Bourbon Whiskey
  • Hints of maple, oak and nutmeg
  • Features a special edition, canvas Bulleit Lewis Bag with a gift tag
  • Distilled and aged in the Bulleit family tradition

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
eBay
BevMo!
Cheers Liquor Mart
Gallo’s Wine Cellar

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Region Kentucky
Distributed by BLW

2. Buffalo Trace Bourbon – 750 ml

Buffalo Trace Bourbon - 750 ml

  • Region: Kentucky
  • Alcohol Percentage: 45
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
  • Proof: 90

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Total Wine & More
Drizly
Mission Wine & Spirits

Product Details

Specifications

Details
ABV 45.00%

Reviews From Real Customers

raman.c
PACowboy
David Nippa

3. Four Roses Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Small Batch – 750 ml

Four Roses Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Small Batch - 750 ml

  • Nose: Spicy, rich, mellow, fruity, hints of sweet oak & caramel.
  • Palate: Creamy, mellow, ripened red berries, rich, spicy, well-balanced, moderately sweet.
  • Finish: Soft, smooth & pleasantly long.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Drizly
Sam’s Club
Total Wine & More

Reviews From Real Customers

WhiskySammi
LenoPaTurbo
Talc

4. Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 700ml

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 700ml

  • 700 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Whisky Kingdom
Loch Fyne Whiskies

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Beverage type Bourbon Whiskey
Alcohol Level 40%
Bottle size 700ml bottle Single
Product Origin Kentucky
Finish Long, smooth

5. Wild Turkey Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon – 750 ml

Wild Turkey Whiskey, Kentucky Straight Bourbon - 750 ml

  • 750 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Total Wine & More
Reserve Bar
Total Beverage

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.
Alcohol by Volume 40.5 %

Reviews From Real Customers

Radguitars
Bourbon Bill 65
ChandlersBourbon

6. Woodford Reserve Distiller’s Select Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight – 1 lt

Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight - 1 lt

  • Color: Woodford Reserve 1L has a light caramel color.
  • Smell: Aromas of vanilla, cereal, toffee and summer fruit.
  • Mouth: I remember almond pastry, caramel and roasted notes cereal; long finish, floral, honey and wood.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Rapid Liquors
Five Towns Wine & Liquor
corkdorkswine.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 1 lt
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.

7. Woodford Reserve Miniature Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey – 50 ml bottle

Woodford Reserve Miniature Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey - 50 ml bottle

  • Clean, brilliant honey amber.
  • Heavy with rich dried fruit, hints of mint and oranges covered with a dusting of cocoa. Faint vanilla and tobacco spice.
  • Rich, chewy, rounded and smooth, with complex citrus, cinnamon and cocoa. Toffee, caramel, chocolate and spice notes abound.
  • Silky smooth, almost creamy at first with a long, warm satisfying tail.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Tulsa Hills Wine Cellar
Bevy’s Liquor World
martinwine.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Unit Size 50 ml
Units in Package 1
Alcohol by Volume 45.2 %

8. Elijah Craig Bourbon – 750 ml

Elijah Craig Bourbon - 750 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Target
Sunset Mart
odarbysliquorbarn.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Alcohol Percentage 47.0
Region United States
Package Quantity 1
Alcohol content Alcoholic
Proof 94.0
Net weight 750 mL
Aged 8 Years
Flavor profile Spice, Smoke, Vanilla
Style Small Batch

9. Bulleit Rye Whiskey

Bulleit Rye Whiskey

  • Released in 2011 it continues to enjoy recognition as one of the highest quality ryes available.
  • Russet in color, with rich oaky aromas.
  • The taste is exceptionally smooth, with hints of vanilla, honey, and spice.
  • Finish is crisp and clean, with long, lingering flavors.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Hard To Find Whisky

Product Details

10. Bulleit Bourbon 700ml Bottle

Bulleit Bourbon 700ml Bottle

  • 700 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Frootbat.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Alcohol Level 40%
Bottle size 700ml bottle Single
Finish Smooth, spicy

11. Woodford Reserve Bourbon 1L Holiday

Woodford Reserve Bourbon 1L Holiday

  • The Finer Details
  • Style
  • Country – United States
  • Region
  • Bottle Size

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Seneca Wine and Liquor
Shamrock Wine & Liquor
Mission Wine & Spirits
Sterling Grapes & Grains

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Alcohol Level 45.2%
Bottle size 1lt bottle Single
Product Origin Kentucky

12. Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 750ml

Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 750ml

  • Clean, brilliant honey amber.
  • Heavy with rich dried fruit, hints of mint and oranges covered with a dusting of cocoa. Faint vanilla and tobacco spice.
  • Rich, chewy, rounded and smooth, with complex citrus, cinnamon and cocoa. Toffee, caramel, chocolate and spice notes abound.
  • Silky smooth, almost creamy at first with a long, warm satisfying tail.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Total Wine & More
Rozis Market
Nestor Liquor
Maple Liquor Market

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Alcohol Level 45.2%
Bottle size 750ml bottle Single
Product Origin Kentucky

13. Eagle Rare Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight, Single Barrel – 1.75 lt

Eagle Rare Bourbon Whiskey, Kentucky Straight, Single Barrel - 1.75 lt

  • Tasting Notes.
  • Nose: Complex aromas of toffee, hints of orange peel, herbs, honey, leather and oak.
  • Taste: Bold, dry, oaky flavors with notes of candied almonds and very rich cocoa.
  • Finish: Dry and lingering.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
roeblingliquors.com
Drizly
All Star Wine & Spirits
bedfordspirits.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 1.75 lt
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.
Alcohol by Volume 45.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

Sasa

14. Elijah Craig Bourbon Gift with Glass & Mold – 750 ml

Elijah Craig Bourbon Gift with Glass & Mold - 750 ml

  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
  • Net weight: 750 mL

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
skywaybeverage.com
Keg n Bottle
Big Time Market & Liquor
Big Time Market and Liquor

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Country United States
State Kentucky

Reviews From Real Customers

Bdiddy13

15. Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon 750ml

Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon 750ml

  • Aged between 8 to 12 years in new oak barrels. Produced in Kentucky, America in Small Batches
  • Tasting Notes; Burnished copper in colour this Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey has delightfully complex aromas with notes of vanilla bean
  • A multi-award Gold & Double Gold medal winning Bourbon
  • Country of Origin: United States

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Nestor Liquor
Prime Oaks

Product Details

16. Old Forester Bourbon Whisky, Kentucky Straight – 1.75 l

Old Forester Bourbon Whisky, Kentucky Straight - 1.75 l

  • Region: Kentucky
  • Alcohol Percentage: 43.0
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
  • Proof: 86.0

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Total Beverage
Mission Wine & Spirits
Total Wine & More

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 1.75 lt
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.
Alcohol by Volume 43.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

bourbonball
Ptraum

17. Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon 70cl

Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon 70cl

  • International Wine & Spirits Competition 2019 Gold Medal Best Kentucky Bourbon
  • World Whisky Awards (WWA) 2019 Silver Medal
  • San Francisco World Spirits Competition (SFWSC) 2013 Rated 90 Points
  • Beverage Testing Institute 2013 Rated 86 Points
  • Jim Murray’s Whisky Bible 2013 Rated 88 Points

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Loch Fyne Whiskies
Hard To Find Whisky
Gopuff

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Distillery/Brand Four Roses
Region USA
Style Bourbon
ABV 45%

Reviews From Real Customers

Joan D
JBG5

18. Old Forester Bourbon Whiskey

Old Forester Bourbon Whiskey

  • Rich, full flavour and a smooth character.
  • Aroma: Sharp and sweet with a strong floral character.
  • Taste: Hints of oak and rye grain character and spicy with soft vanilla and light orange notes.
  • Finish: Long, warm and slightly drying with a nice level of sweetness.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
The Whisky Exchange
Nestor Liquor
Prime Oaks
Whisky Kingdom

Product Details

19. Woodford Reserve Distiller’s Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey – 750ml Bottle

Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey - 750ml Bottle

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Target

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Region Kentucky
Alcohol Percentage 45.2
Package Quantity 1
Alcohol content Alcoholic
Proof 90.4
Net weight 750 mL
Aged Unaged

20. High West Whiskey, Double Rye – 375 ml

High West Whiskey, Double Rye - 375 ml

  • 375 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Seneca Wine and Liquor
Lighthouse Wine & Spirits
Rapid Liquors

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 375 ml
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.

Best Whiskey For An Old Fashioned Buying Guides

whiskey

Whiskey is the main ingredient in an old fashioned. The other ingredients are sugar, bitters, and water.

bitters

The best bitters to use for an old fashioned are whiskey bitters. These bitters have a deep, rich flavor that pairs well with the other flavors in an old fashioned.

sugar

There are a few different ways to make an Old Fashioned, but the most common way is to muddle sugar and bitters together, then add whiskey and stir.

ice

There are a few different ways to make an Old Fashioned, but they all generally follow the same basic recipe. You will need ice, whiskey, bitters, and a sugar cube (or simple syrup). To make the drink, start by adding the sugar cube (or simple syrup) to the bottom of the glass.

Then add a few dashes of bitters. Next, add a small amount of water to help dissolve the sugar. Finally, add the whiskey and stir. Garnish with a twist of orange peel and serve.

orange peel

The orange peel is an important ingredient in an old fashioned cocktail. It provides a citrus flavor and aroma that complement the whiskey. To make an old fashioned, the orange peel is first cut into thin strips.

Then, the strips are placed in a glass and muddled (pressed) with a pestle to release the oils. The muddled orange peel is then removed and the glass is filled with ice. Finally, the whiskey is added to the glass and the old fashioned is stirred.

cherry

Cherries and whiskey have a long, storied history together. In the early days of American whiskey production, cherries were added to the barrels to add flavor and color. Today, cherries are still used in many whiskey-based cocktails, including the Old Fashioned.

There are many different ways to make an Old Fashioned, but the basic ingredients are whiskey, bitters, sugar, and a cherry. Some recipes call for muddling the cherry with the sugar and bitters, while others simply add it as a garnish.

No matter how you make it, an Old Fashioned is a delicious, classic cocktail that is sure to please.

stirrer

A stirrer for whiskey is typically a long, thin object used to mix the drink. This can be anything from a straw to a chopstick.

glass

A glass of whiskey is the perfect drink for an old fashioned. The whiskey will keep you warm and the old fashioned will help you relax.

Conclusion

Whiskey is often the choice for an old fashioned cocktail. There are many different ways to make an old fashioned, but the most common way is to muddle sugar, bitters, and a cherry with a splash of water.

Then, add whiskey and stir.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment