20 Best Vanilla Extract America’S Test Kitchen (2022 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Vanilla extract is a flavor made from the extracts of vanilla beans. It is used to flavor food and beverages, and is a popular ingredient in baking and desserts.

20 Best Vanilla Extract America’S Test Kitchen

1. Kirkland Signature Pure Vanilla, 16-Ounces

Kirkland Signature Pure Vanilla, 16-Ounces

  • Rich, deep color
  • Beautfiul pure vanilla scent
  • Vanilla planifolia orchid vanilla beans extracted to make this product
  • Extract is blended to 2000 particles per million of natural vanillin
  • Outstanding quality product

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 3 x 3 x 8 inches; 1 Pounds

2. Simply Organic Vanilla Extract – 2 fl oz bottle

Simply Organic Vanilla Extract - 2 fl oz bottle

  • 2 Fl Oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com
eBay
Vitacost.com
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan
Derived Nutrition Claim Dairy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

ciaochow

3. Rodelle Pure Vanilla Extract, 32 oz

Rodelle Pure Vanilla Extract, 32 oz

  • 32 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay
Walmart

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Package Dimensions 9.13 x 3.35 x 3.15 inches; 2 Pounds

Reviews From Real Customers

jb
Jeff N
skylark99virginia

4. Watkins Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla Extract – 11 fl oz bottle

Watkins Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla Extract - 11 fl oz bottle

  • Size: 11 Fl Oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com
eBay – bubs1085
Walmart
Vitacost.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Allergens CONTAINS SULFITES.
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan

Reviews From Real Customers

bob27
Sgtbass64
Sweet Mary Lee

5. Nielsen Massey Vanilla Extract, Pure – 4 fl oz

Nielsen Massey Vanilla Extract, Pure - 4 fl oz

  • 4 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – starlightsilents
Walmart
Country Kitchen SweetArt

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 4 fl oz
Directions 1 tbs vanilla extract = 1 vanilla bean.
Ingredients Water, Alcohol (35%), Sugar, Vanilla Bean Extractives.
Warnings Sealed for your protection.

Reviews From Real Customers

KBSofVT
syrup
penny

6. McCormick Pure Vanilla Extract – 2 fl oz box

McCormick Pure Vanilla Extract - 2 fl oz box

  • Made with 100 percent premium ingredients
  • Perfect addition to cakes, cookies, pies and other baked goods
  • All Natural, Gluten Free and no corn syrup
  • Rich, perfectly balanced caramelized, bourbon rummy flavor
  • Easy pour spout eliminates unnecessary mess

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Walmart
Walmart – Choose and Buy Items LLC

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan
Derived Nutrition Claim Dairy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

PG
Linda D
ashley.s

7. Wilton Clear Vanilla Extract – 8 oz

Wilton Clear Vanilla Extract - 8 oz

  • This flavouring is clear so it won’t effect your frosting colouring
  • Shatter proof bottle: 8 fluid ounces
  • Measurements: 16cm x 6.4cm x 3.8cm
  • Made in USA

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Walmart
Wilton Brands

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Occasion Party
Alcohol Content by Volume 0.00
Multipack Quantity 1
Maximum Weight 0.66 Ounces
Recommended Use Party

Reviews From Real Customers

KathyG
egav719
Maria S.

8. Vanilla Extract Alcohol & Gluten Free 2 oz

Vanilla Extract Alcohol & Gluten Free 2 oz

  • 2 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart – OliveNation, LLC.
OliveNation

Product Details

Specifications

Details
GLUTEN FREE Yes
KOSHER Yes
ORGANIC No
ALCOHOL FREE Yes
VEGAN FRIENDLY Yes

Reviews From Real Customers

Barb
Zuhair
olivenation.com

9. Spice Islands Vanilla Extract, Pure – 4 fl oz

Spice Islands Vanilla Extract, Pure - 4 fl oz

  • 4 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan
Derived Nutrition Claim Dairy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

elizabeth.k
joyce_santoro
ThePotatoOne

10. Frontier Vanilla Extract – 2 fl oz

Frontier Vanilla Extract - 2 fl oz

  • 2 Fluid Ounce Bottle
  • Non-GMO Project Verified, pure, aromatic vanilla extract made with premium quality, organic ingredients
  • Kosher, Non-GMO Verified
  • Non-Irradiated
  • Frontier is a member owned co-op, responsible to people and planet

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Walmart – Garner Supply
Frontier Co-op

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan
Derived Nutrition Claim Dairy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

JEANNINE
MeSam
Carolyn

11. Flavorganics Organic Vanilla Extract – 4oz bottle

Flavorganics Organic Vanilla Extract - 4oz bottle

  • 4 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Walmart
Azure Standard

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan
Derived Nutrition Claim Dairy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

Discerning Purchaser
UrbanHuman
Organic Vegetarian

12. Lorann Oils Pure Vanilla Extract – 4 oz.

Lorann Oils Pure Vanilla Extract - 4 oz.

  • 4 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – enjoyitagainbaking
Walmart – Bakedeco.com
WebstaurantStore.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Pack Size 1 Piece
Craft Baking
Dimensions 1.75in x 1.75in x 4.5in
Capacity 4 oz
Flavour Vanilla

Reviews From Real Customers

SophieH
Kari
michaels.com

13. Mccormick Vanilla Flavor, Clear – 2 fl oz

Mccormick Vanilla Flavor, Clear - 2 fl oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart – CPGIO
Trustables
BoxedMarket

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan
Derived Nutrition Claim Dairy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrate Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegetarian
Derived Nutrition Claim Caffeine Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Low Sugar
Derived Nutrition Claim Nut Free
Derived Nutrition Claim High Fructose Corn Syrup Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Artificial Color Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Oil Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Lactose Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Artificial Preservative Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Peanut Free
Derived Nutrition Claim No Added Sugar
Derived Nutrition Claim Gluten Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Tree Nut Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Egg Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Shell Fish Free
Rich Ingredients WATER, ALCOHOL (13%), VANILLIN AND OTHER ARTIFICIAL FLAVORINGS, AND CITRIC ACID.
Ingredients WATER, ALCOHOL (13%), VANILLIN AND OTHER ARTIFICIAL FLAVORINGS, AND CITRIC ACID.
Nutrition Claim Kosher
Nutrition Claim Gluten Free

14. Pure Vanilla Extract for Sale | Best Vanilla Extract, 4 fl. oz.

Pure Vanilla Extract for Sale | Best Vanilla Extract, 4 fl. oz.

  • 4 Fl. Oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart – Slofoodgroup
Slofoodgroup

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

John C.
Daniel K.
Cathryn L.

15. Heilala Pure Vanilla Extract – 1.69 fl oz

Heilala Pure Vanilla Extract - 1.69 fl oz

  • Made in New Zealand.
  • Ingredients include Heilala vanilla bean extractives in water, and alcohol (35%).
  • Store in a cool, dark place.
  • Presented in a Heilala glass jar.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart – The Kiwi Importer LLC
Thrive Market
Heilala Vanilla

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Serving size 1 tsp
Total Fat 0g
Saturated Fat 0g
Sodium 5g
Total Carbohydrate 2g

Reviews From Real Customers

patticake
Atieno
Jamie

16. Kirkland Pure Vanilla Extract, 16 oz (Pack of 2)

Kirkland Pure Vanilla Extract, 16 oz (Pack of 2)

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – wholeandnatural
WholeAndNatural.com

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

April
natalia.s
james.s

17. Organic Vanilla Extract – 16 fl oz (Pint)

Organic Vanilla Extract - 16 fl oz (Pint)

  • 16 Fl Oz. (Pint)

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Beanilla

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Country of Origin United States
Storage Store in a cool, dry place

Reviews From Real Customers

Dona
Jacob G.
Casey R.

18. Vanilla Extract, Single Strength Madagascar

Vanilla Extract, Single Strength Madagascar

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
The Spice House

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

Joan M. L.
Jeanette W.
Viv K.

19. Pure Vanilla Extract Heilala Baking Vanilla Extract

Pure Vanilla Extract Heilala Baking Vanilla Extract

  • 1.69 Fl Oz (Pack Of 1)

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Grocery.com Store

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 1.38 x 1.38 x 5.47 inches; 5.29 Ounces
Country of Origin New Zealand
Volume 1.69 Fluid Ounces

Reviews From Real Customers

HEATHER D.
Sude
J

20. Shank’s Pure Vanilla Extract 12/8oz, 170556, Price/Case

Shank's Pure Vanilla Extract 12/8oz, 170556, Price/Case

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart – ATAFA
The Grain Mill Co-op

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Weight 8 lb

Reviews From Real Customers

Winchell C.
Joshua E.
journie m.

Conclusion

In conclusion, America’s Test Kitchen found that vanilla extract is a versatile ingredient that can be used in many different recipes. They also found that it is a good value for the money and that it can be found in most supermarkets.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment