20 Best Toys For New Puppies (2023 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Some general tips for choosing toys for a new puppy include:

– Avoid anything too small or fragile that could be easily swallowed or broken.

– Look for toys that are specifically designed for puppies, as these will often be the perfect size and durability for them.

– Think about what kinds of things your puppy likes to do – if they love to chew, for example, then choose a toy that will be durable enough to stand up to their chewing.

– Consider buying a few different kinds of toys so that your puppy has a variety of options to choose from. This way, they’re sure to find something they love!

20 Best Toys For New Puppies

Product Image Product Name Features Price

Snuggle Puppy, Brown Mutt

  • A healthy tool to help puppies
  • Requires 2 AAA-Batteries (included), which will last for 2 weeks when used 24/7
  • Contains 1 heat pack, which lasts about 24 hours

Kong Medium Puppy Teething Toy – Colors May Vary

  • M

JW Pet Playplace Butterfly Teether

  • Provides optimum dental health for dogs of any age
  • Safe 100% recyclable non-toxic durable nylon toy
  • Entertains & holds up even for tough chewers & teethers

Kong Puppy Ball with Hole Dog Toy, Assorted, Small, Pink

  • This Kong ball will occupy your teething puppy
  • Ball bounces to keep puppy entertained and active
  • Fill the ball with their favorite treats or treat paste

Petmate JW 43032 I-Squeak Ball, Assorted Color, Large

  • Large

KONG Classic Dog Toy, Red, Large

  • Gold standard
  • Super bouncy
  • Red natural rubber

Snuggle Puppy – New Puppy Starter Kit (Neutral)

  • Contains a Snuggle Puppy, Snuggle Blanket, 3 Heat Packs, Puppy’s 1st Toy, and Puppy Teething Aid
  • Snuggle Puppy eases crying, loneliness and separation anxiety in pets by appealing to natural instincts

Kong – Puppy Tires – Soft Rubber Chew Toy and Treat Dispenser (Assorted Colors) – for Medium/Large Puppies

  • Medium/Large

Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Keys – Large

  • Discourages destructive chewing
  • Helps clean teeth and remove tartar
  • Provides entertainment

Pets First New York Yankees Field Toy

  • New York Yankees

Pets First New York Giants Field Pull Dog Toy

  • Poly fill and squeaker.
  • Nylon web binding.
  • Team woven logo over screened football field graphics.

Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Cow Dog Toy, Large

  • Large

Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Dog Toy Pig-Large

  • Soft, Cuddly Plush Used For Quieter Play
  • Interior bottle creates enticing crunch sounds
  • Rattles For Added Fun

Spot Small Dog & Puppy Toy, Lil Spots

  • Squeaker inside plush head
  • 3 character assortment
  • Small Dog/Puppy Toy

Nylabone Puppy Bone Souper

  • Souper

Nylabone – Puppy Teething Pacifier

  • Every puppy needs a pacifier to soothe teething discomfort and prepare their chompers for a life filled with treats and chews!

Planet Dog Orbee Tuff Basketball Dog Toy

  • One-Size

Kong Cozi Ali Alligator Dog Toy, Small, Green

  • Cute design will make it appealing to both your pet and you.
  • Durable build allows it to handle a rough play.
  • The internal squeaker lets you locate it during use sessions.

Hartz Dura Play Ball Medium

  • Medium

Pets First Cincinnati Bengals Field Pull Dog Toy

  • Poly fill and squeaker.
  • Nylon web binding.
  • Team woven logo over screened football field graphics.
Snuggle Puppy, Brown Mutt
  • A healthy tool to help puppies
  • Requires 2 AAA-Batteries (included), which will last for 2 weeks when used 24/7
  • Contains 1 heat pack, which lasts about 24 hours
Kong Medium Puppy Teething Toy – Colors May Vary
  • M
JW Pet Playplace Butterfly Teether
  • Provides optimum dental health for dogs of any age
  • Safe 100% recyclable non-toxic durable nylon toy
  • Entertains & holds up even for tough chewers & teethers
Kong Puppy Ball with Hole Dog Toy, Assorted, Small, Pink
  • This Kong ball will occupy your teething puppy
  • Ball bounces to keep puppy entertained and active
  • Fill the ball with their favorite treats or treat paste
Petmate JW 43032 I-Squeak Ball, Assorted Color, Large
  • Large
KONG Classic Dog Toy, Red, Large
  • Gold standard
  • Super bouncy
  • Red natural rubber
Snuggle Puppy – New Puppy Starter Kit (Neutral)
  • Contains a Snuggle Puppy, Snuggle Blanket, 3 Heat Packs, Puppy’s 1st Toy, and Puppy Teething Aid
  • Snuggle Puppy eases crying, loneliness and separation anxiety in pets by appealing to natural instincts
Kong – Puppy Tires – Soft Rubber Chew Toy and Treat Dispenser (Assorted Colors) – for Medium/Large Puppies
  • Medium/Large
Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Keys – Large
  • Discourages destructive chewing
  • Helps clean teeth and remove tartar
  • Provides entertainment
Pets First New York Yankees Field Toy
  • New York Yankees
Pets First New York Giants Field Pull Dog Toy
  • Poly fill and squeaker.
  • Nylon web binding.
  • Team woven logo over screened football field graphics.
Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Cow Dog Toy, Large
  • Large
Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Dog Toy Pig-Large
  • Soft, Cuddly Plush Used For Quieter Play
  • Interior bottle creates enticing crunch sounds
  • Rattles For Added Fun
Spot Small Dog & Puppy Toy, Lil Spots
  • Squeaker inside plush head
  • 3 character assortment
  • Small Dog/Puppy Toy
Nylabone Puppy Bone Souper
  • Souper
Nylabone – Puppy Teething Pacifier
  • Every puppy needs a pacifier to soothe teething discomfort and prepare their chompers for a life filled with treats and chews!
Planet Dog Orbee Tuff Basketball Dog Toy
  • One-Size
Kong Cozi Ali Alligator Dog Toy, Small, Green
  • Cute design will make it appealing to both your pet and you.
  • Durable build allows it to handle a rough play.
  • The internal squeaker lets you locate it during use sessions.
Hartz Dura Play Ball Medium
  • Medium
Pets First Cincinnati Bengals Field Pull Dog Toy
  • Poly fill and squeaker.
  • Nylon web binding.
  • Team woven logo over screened football field graphics.

1. Snuggle Puppy, Brown Mutt

Snuggle Puppy, Brown Mutt

  • A healthy tool to help puppies
  • Requires 2 AAA-Batteries (included), which will last for 2 weeks when used 24/7
  • Contains 1 heat pack, which lasts about 24 hours
  • Has an on/off button, so that you can use the Snuggle Puppy whenever you need it
  • Washable (when you take out the heart and the heat pack)

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay
PetSmart
Jefferspet.com

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

MelO

2. Kong Medium Puppy Teething Toy – Colors May Vary

Kong Medium Puppy Teething Toy - Colors May Vary

  • M

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
PetSmart
Ray Allen Manufacturing
J&J Dog Supplies

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Size Medium
Breed size Medium breeds
Toy feature Teething
Material All-natural rubber
Dimensions 3.4 x 2.2 x 2.2 inches

Reviews From Real Customers

gyzelle.r
TXGma

3. JW Pet Playplace Butterfly Teether

JW Pet Playplace Butterfly Teether

  • Provides optimum dental health for dogs of any age
  • Safe 100% recyclable non-toxic durable nylon toy
  • Entertains & holds up even for tough chewers & teethers
  • Great way to engage a dog’s natural instinct to chew
  • Ideal for intense chewers and teething puppies

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com
eBay
Walmart – Kwik Retail LLC
Chewy.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Item Package Dimensions L x W x H 3.66 x 3.66 x 0.19 inches
Item Dimensions LxWxH 0.88 x 4.4 x 6.5 inches
Suggested Users Unisex-adult
Included Components Pet Supplies Dog Toys

4. Kong Puppy Ball with Hole Dog Toy, Assorted, Small, Pink

Kong Puppy Ball with Hole Dog Toy, Assorted, Small, Pink

  • This Kong ball will occupy your teething puppy
  • Ball bounces to keep puppy entertained and active
  • Fill the ball with their favorite treats or treat paste
  • Build is durable and can withstand growing teeth
  • Great way to learn how to fetch

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
Chewy.com
Redpost Equestrian
Petco.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Product Puppy Teething Ball
Breed Small Dogs
Material Rubber
Dimensions 2.5 x 2.5 x 2.5
Weight 4.3 oz

Reviews From Real Customers

QueenElf
MaggyMom
Dallasdoggos

5. Petmate JW 43032 I-Squeak Ball, Assorted Color, Large

Petmate JW 43032 I-Squeak Ball, Assorted Color, Large

  • Large

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com
Walmart
Chewy.com
Jefferspet.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Weight 0.41 lb

Reviews From Real Customers

Rainie
B.i.A.
Cheburashka

6. KONG Classic Dog Toy, Red, Large

KONG Classic Dog Toy, Red, Large

  • Gold standard
  • Super bouncy
  • Red natural rubber
  • Perfect for typical chewer
  • Made in usa

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
Walmart
PetSmart
Chewy.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Warnings Important: Supervised used only. Remove all packaging. Discontinue use if damaged. Power chewers: Increase one or two sizes or try KONG Extreme.

7. Snuggle Puppy – New Puppy Starter Kit (Neutral)

Snuggle Puppy - New Puppy Starter Kit (Neutral)

  • Contains a Snuggle Puppy, Snuggle Blanket, 3 Heat Packs, Puppy’s 1st Toy, and Puppy Teething Aid
  • Snuggle Puppy eases crying, loneliness and separation anxiety in pets by appealing to natural instincts
  • Snuggle Blanket provides extra warmth and comfort while catching and holding shed hair
  • Perfect for new pet owners, helps ease your puppy into its new home

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Chewy.com
PetSmart
Target

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Dimensions (Overall) 12.5 Inches (L), 12.5 Inches (H) x 9.8 Inches (W)
Intended Pet Type Dog
Pet Lifestage All Ages
Pet toy type Interactive, Plush
Pet activity Chew, Cuddle

8. Kong – Puppy Tires – Soft Rubber Chew Toy and Treat Dispenser (Assorted Colors) – for Medium/Large Puppies

Kong - Puppy Tires - Soft Rubber Chew Toy and Treat Dispenser (Assorted Colors) - for Medium/Large Puppies

  • Medium/Large

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Petco.com
PBS Animal Health

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

BethW

9. Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Keys – Large

Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Keys - Large

  • Discourages destructive chewing
  • Helps clean teeth and remove tartar
  • Provides entertainment

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Chewy.com
Jefferspet.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Weight 1 lb

10. Pets First New York Yankees Field Toy

Pets First New York Yankees Field Toy

  • New York Yankees

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – starpetscom

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Primary Brand Pets First
Sport Baseball
Team New York Yankees
Length 17.5 IN

Reviews From Real Customers

Creolelj
RayRay

11. Pets First New York Giants Field Pull Dog Toy

Pets First New York Giants Field Pull Dog Toy

  • Poly fill and squeaker.
  • Nylon web binding.
  • Team woven logo over screened football field graphics.
  • Built for tug and fetch.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
PetSmart
Lowe’s

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Batteries Included No
Squeaker Yes
BPA-Free Yes
Package Quantity 1
Flavored No

12. Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Cow Dog Toy, Large

Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Cow Dog Toy, Large

  • Large

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Chewy.com
PetMountain.com
PBS Animal Health

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer ‏ ‎ No
Product Dimensions ‏ ‎ 4.73 x 7.98 x 5.23 inches; 1.92 Ounces
Item Package Dimensions L x W x H ‎12 x 4.72 x 4 inches
Item Dimensions LxWxH ‎4.73 x 7.98 x 5.23 inches
Target Audience Keyword ‎Dogs

Reviews From Real Customers

StevenSteph
Lucy

13. Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Dog Toy Pig-Large

Kong Barnyard Cruncheez Dog Toy Pig-Large

  • Soft, Cuddly Plush Used For Quieter Play
  • Interior bottle creates enticing crunch sounds
  • Rattles For Added Fun
  • Designed For Light/Moderate Chewing
  • Color

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Chewy.com
PetFlow
The Hound’s Meow

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 4.73 x 7.73 x 5.23 inches; 1.92 Ounces
Item Package Dimensions L x W x H 11.9 x 5.5 x 5.3 inches
Item Dimensions LxWxH 4.73 x 7.73 x 5.23 inches
Target Audience Keyword Dogs

14. Spot Small Dog & Puppy Toy, Lil Spots

Spot Small Dog & Puppy Toy, Lil Spots

  • Squeaker inside plush head
  • 3 character assortment
  • Small Dog/Puppy Toy
  • Country Of Origin: China
  • You will receive 1 of the Assorted Animals

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Walmart
Chewy.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Ingredients Content: Polyester Fibers.
Warnings Caution: To ensure the safety of your pet, supervise your pet at all times during play. Do not allow your pet to play with the toy if any part of the toy comes loose or separated. This toy is intended to be used only with supervision.

15. Nylabone Puppy Bone Souper

Nylabone Puppy Bone Souper

  • Souper

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart
Chewy.com
PetSmart

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Weight 1 lb

16. Nylabone – Puppy Teething Pacifier

Nylabone - Puppy Teething Pacifier

  • Every puppy needs a pacifier to soothe teething discomfort and prepare their chompers for a life filled with treats and chews!
  • This toy features dental nubs, this puppy pacifier helps promote dental health, clean teeth, and prevent tartar buildup.
  • This toy is not intended for puppies with adult teeth or for powerful chewers.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart
Chewy.com
Petco.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Size X-Small

17. Planet Dog Orbee Tuff Basketball Dog Toy

Planet Dog Orbee Tuff Basketball Dog Toy

  • One-Size

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Chewy.com
DogTuff.com
Mooshiepets.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 5 x 5 x 5 inches; 12.32 Ounces
Country of Origin USA
Item Package Dimensions L x W x H 5.04 x 4.8 x 4.8 inches
Item Dimensions LxWxH 5 x 5 x 5 inches

Reviews From Real Customers

Kathryn1219
Wiggles
AprilG

18. Kong Cozi Ali Alligator Dog Toy, Small, Green

Kong Cozi Ali Alligator Dog Toy, Small, Green

  • Cute design will make it appealing to both your pet and you.
  • Durable build allows it to handle a rough play.
  • The internal squeaker lets you locate it during use sessions.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Chewy.com
PetFlow
The Hound’s Meow

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Squeaker Yes
Durable Yes
Indoor Use Yes
Color Green
Outdoor Use No

Reviews From Real Customers

lmg997
Pacamama

19. Hartz Dura Play Ball Medium

Hartz Dura Play Ball Medium

  • Medium

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Chewy.com
CVS Pharmacy

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Manufacturer Part Number 032700148003
Product Line Dura Play
Product Name Dura Play Ball Medium
Product Type Dog Ball Toy
Animal Type Dog

20. Pets First Cincinnati Bengals Field Pull Dog Toy

Pets First Cincinnati Bengals Field Pull Dog Toy

  • Poly fill and squeaker.
  • Nylon web binding.
  • Team woven logo over screened football field graphics.
  • Built for tug and fetch.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Rally House

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Primary Brand Pets First
Sport Football
Team Cincinnati Bengals

Conclusion

There are a variety of different toys that are available for new puppies. Some of the most popular options include chew toys, fetch toys, and plush toys. It is important to choose the right type of toy for your puppy based on their individual personality and needs.

Chew toys are a great option for puppies who are teething or who have a lot of energy. Fetch toys are perfect for active puppies who enjoy playing fetch. Plush toys are ideal for puppies who are calm and cuddly.

Ultimately, the best toy for your new puppy is the one that they enjoy the most and that meets their individual needs.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment