Best Tomatoes For Pizza Sauce (2024 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

As a pizza lover, I know that the sauce is one of the most important components of a delicious pizza. And when it comes to the sauce, the type of tomato you use can make a huge difference. So, if you are looking for the best tomatoes for pizza sauce, there are a few key points you should keep in mind.

Firstly, look for tomatoes that have a high acidity level. This will help to balance out the sweetness of the sauce and give it a tangy flavor. Secondly, choose tomatoes that are meaty and have fewer seeds. This will help to create a thicker and more flavorful sauce. Thirdly, consider the type of tomato you are using. San Marzano tomatoes are often considered the best for pizza sauce due to their sweet flavor and low acidity. However, other varieties such as Roma or heirloom tomatoes can also be great choices.

Fourthly, consider whether you want to use fresh or canned tomatoes. Fresh tomatoes can give a brighter and fresher flavor, but canned tomatoes are often more convenient and can be used year-round. Finally, don't forget to taste test different tomatoes to find the flavor and texture that you prefer.

By keeping these key points in mind, you can find the best tomatoes for pizza sauce and create a delicious and flavorful pizza every time.

10 Best Tomatoes For Pizza Sauce

1. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce, 14.5 Ounce (Pack Of 12)

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is a fully prepared pizza sauce made from fresh vine-ripened tomatoes. This sauce is a family recipe that has been trusted for generations. It includes pure corn oil, salt, spices, and garlic, which give it a unique taste that is rich in both flavor and texture. This cholesterol-free sauce is perfect for anyone who loves pizza but wants to avoid unhealthy ingredients.

The sauce is made from only the freshest, highest quality ingredients. The tomatoes are picked at the peak of ripeness to ensure they are full of flavor and nutrients. The pure corn oil is used to give the sauce a smooth and silky texture while enhancing its flavor. The salt, spices, and garlic are carefully selected and added in just the right amounts to create a perfectly balanced taste.

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is a product that you can trust. The company has been making this sauce for over 50 years and has perfected the recipe to ensure that it is always consistent in taste and quality. The sauce is made in small batches to ensure that it is always fresh and that every jar is of the highest quality.

This sauce is perfect for making homemade pizza, but it can also be used for other dishes such as pasta, lasagna, or as a dipping sauce for breadsticks. The rich flavor of the sauce makes it a versatile ingredient that can be used in many different recipes.

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is not only delicious, but it is also healthy. The sauce is cholesterol-free, making it a great option for anyone who is watching their cholesterol levels. It is also made from natural ingredients and does not contain any artificial colors or preservatives.

In conclusion, Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is a must-have for anyone who loves pizza or Italian cuisine. With its unique flavor, texture, and health benefits, it is a product that you can trust and rely on. Whether you are making homemade pizza or looking for a new ingredient for your favorite recipe, Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is the perfect choice.

2. Dell'amore Premium Tomato Pizza Sauce – Family Recipe – Fresh Ingredients – 16oz / 12 Pack.

Dell'Amore Premium Sauce offers a delicious and authentic taste of Italy with their original family recipe for Italian Tomato Pizza Sauce. Since 1918, Dell'Amore has been using only the finest quality and freshest ingredients to create exceptional sauces. The company remains dedicated to crafting their sauce with meticulous attention to detail to ensure every bottle is delicious.

The homemade and versatile sauce can be used to make any meal delicious. The marinara sauce is perfect for pasta, lasagna, pizza, and any other recipe that requires a delicious tomato sauce. The sauce is all-natural, gluten-free, vegan, non-GMO, kosher, and has no added sugar. The focus on ingredients ensures that the sauce is full of flavor, without any compromises, making it a diet-friendly option.

The jarred marinara sauce is perfect for those who want both convenience and taste. It is the one ingredient that should always be in your pantry, so you can quickly and easily make your favorite Italian marinara sauce recipes. From snacks to casseroles, there are so many ways in which you can turn a jar of sauce into a delicious meal.

The 12 pack of Pizza Recipe sauce gives you the variety needed to enjoy your favorite pizza sauce in the comfort of your own home. The sauce is perfect for any occasion, whether you are hosting a dinner party or simply enjoying a night in with your family. You do not need to make a reservation to enjoy the delicious taste of Dell'Amore Premium Sauce.

In conclusion, Dell'Amore Premium Sauce offers a mouthwatering taste of Italy with their original family recipe for Italian Tomato Pizza Sauce. The sauce is made with only the finest quality and freshest ingredients, ensuring that every bottle is delicious. The all-natural, gluten-free, vegan, non-GMO, kosher, and no added sugar ingredients make it a diet-friendly option. The jarred marinara sauce is perfect for those who want both convenience and taste, making it an essential ingredient for every pantry. The 12 pack of Pizza Recipe sauce offers variety, making it perfect for any occasion. Enjoy the authentic taste of Italy with Dell'Amore Premium Sauce.

3. 6 Pack Of Mutti Pizza Sauce With Basil & Oregano, 14 Oz Cans. Italy's Top Brand Of Tomatoes. Fresh Taste, Vegan Friendly, Gluten-Free, And Free Of Additives Or Preservatives.

Mutti Pizza Sauce with Basil & Oregano is a delicious ready-to-use sauce that boasts rich flavor and thick texture for great tasting pizza every time. Made from 100% Italian tomatoes, this pizza sauce blends sun-ripened tomatoes with aromatic basil and oregano to provide a remarkably fresh taste that is perfect for any pizza or flatbread recipe.

To ensure the freshness of the sauce, Mutti uses the finest non-GMO Project Verified, Italian ingredients and never includes any additives or preservatives. The sauce is then packed into a non-BPA can to preserve its fresh taste and quality.

Not only is Mutti Pizza Sauce perfect for pizza and flatbreads, but it is also a versatile ingredient that can be used as a dipping sauce or even to make an olive tapenade. Its rich flavor and thick texture make it the best kept secret for cooking.

In addition to its great taste, Mutti Pizza Sauce is also vegan friendly and gluten free. Made with natural goodness, you can see and taste a difference in these delicious, canned sauce.

Mutti is Italy’s #1 tomato brand and has been preserving one of nature’s perfect gifts at the peak of ripeness since 1899. The Mutti family has shared its passion for Italian tomatoes for over a century and has partnered with WWF in Italy for over 20 years to reduce water consumption and its carbon footprint.

Overall, Mutti Pizza Sauce with Basil & Oregano is the perfect addition to any pizza or flatbread recipe. Its delicious taste, fresh ingredients, and commitment to sustainability make it a must-have for any kitchen.

4. Pomì Pizza Sauce – Made From 100% Fresh Italian Tomatoes – 14.1oz Can (Pack Of 12)

Pomì Pizza Sauce is a must-have ingredient for anyone who wants to create the perfect pizza with an authentic Italian flavor. Made from fresh tomato juice and a few carefully selected Italian ingredients, this sauce is designed to enhance the taste of your pizza and make it a true delight for your taste buds.

What sets Pomì Pizza Sauce apart is its use of 100% freshly picked and perfectly ripened Italian tomatoes. These tomatoes are grown and ripened under the warm Italian sun, ensuring that they are bursting with flavor and nutrition. Once harvested, they are immediately processed and packaged on location, preserving their freshness and quality.

Unlike many other tomato-based products, Pomì Pizza Sauce is free from GMOs, preservatives, gluten, and BPA. This makes it a healthier and more natural option for those who are concerned about what they put into their bodies. Additionally, it is low in sodium and sugar, making it a great choice for people who want to watch their intake of these substances.

In terms of taste, Pomì Pizza Sauce is hard to beat. The tomato flavor is rich, robust, and satisfying, while the added Italian ingredients give it a distinctive kick that sets it apart from other pizza sauces on the market. Whether you're making a classic Margherita pizza or something more adventurous, this sauce is sure to elevate your dish to the next level.

Overall, Pomì Pizza Sauce is an excellent choice for anyone who wants to create a delicious and authentic Italian pizza at home. Its use of fresh, high-quality ingredients and its commitment to health and sustainability make it a standout product in its category. So why not give it a try and see for yourself why so many people swear by its quality and flavor?

5. Colavita Pizza Sauce 13.76oz Recart Packaging (Pack Of 16)

Colavita Pizza Sauce is a premium product made with 100% Italian tomatoes that are carefully selected and grown to perfection. This pizza sauce is a must-have for anyone who loves to make homemade pizza, calzone, pizza bagels, or pizza rolls. The sauce comes in a convenient 13.76oz recart packaging and is sold in a pack of 16.

The sauce is made with fresh tomatoes that are grown in the sunny fields of Italy. The tomatoes are picked at the peak of ripeness, ensuring maximum flavor and nutrition. The sauce is then prepared using traditional Italian methods, which involve crushing the tomatoes and adding just the right amount of oregano. This results in a rich and flavorful sauce that is perfect for any pizza recipe.

Colavita Pizza Sauce is an authentic Italian product that has been enjoyed by families for generations. The sauce is made by a family-owned company that has been producing high-quality Italian products for over 100 years. The company uses only the finest ingredients and adheres to strict quality standards to ensure that their products are of the highest quality.

The pizza sauce is versatile and can be used in a variety of ways. It is perfect for topping homemade pizza or for use in a calzone or pizza roll. It can also be used as a dipping sauce for mozzarella sticks or other appetizers. The sauce has a classic flavor that is sure to please everyone in the family.

Colavita Pizza Sauce is a product of Italy, which means that it is made using the traditional methods and ingredients that have been passed down for generations. The sauce is made with love and care, and this is reflected in its rich and authentic flavor. The recart packaging ensures that the sauce stays fresh and flavorful for longer, giving you more time to enjoy it.

In conclusion, Colavita Pizza Sauce is a premium product that is made with the finest ingredients and traditional Italian methods. It is perfect for anyone who loves to make homemade pizza or other Italian dishes. The sauce is versatile, delicious, and sure to be a family favorite. Get your pack of 16 today and start enjoying the authentic taste of Italy in your own home.

6. Did You Eat My Pizza Skeleton Bones Slice Tomato Sauce Top T-Shirt

Introducing the "Did You Eat My Pizza Skeleton Bones Slice Tomato Sauce Top T-Shirt," a must-have for pizza lovers everywhere. This foodie-inspired t-shirt features a cheesy Hawaiian overload pizza design, making it the perfect outfit choice for any pizza-themed occasion, especially birthdays.

Made from lightweight, high-quality materials, this t-shirt boasts a classic fit and double-needle sleeve and bottom hem for added durability. It's comfortable to wear and perfect for those who love to cook, bake, and eat Italian cuisine.

The design of this t-shirt is sure to grab the attention of anyone who loves pizza. It features a mouth-watering slice of pizza with tomato sauce, cheese, and salami, all topped off with a fun "skeleton bones" motif. This shirt is a great way to show off your love for pizza and Italian food, and it's sure to be a conversation starter at any gathering.

This t-shirt is perfect for gourmets and foodies who appreciate good pizza. Whether you're out with friends, running errands, or simply lounging at home, this pizza-themed t-shirt is a great way to show off your love for everyone's favorite food. It's also a fantastic gift idea for any pizza lover on your shopping list.

Overall, the "Did You Eat My Pizza Skeleton Bones Slice Tomato Sauce Top T-Shirt" is a stylish and fun way to show your love for pizza. Whether you're wearing it out and about or simply lounging at home, this t-shirt is sure to become a favorite in your wardrobe. So go ahead and order now – your taste buds (and your wardrobe) will thank you!

7. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce, 28 Ounce (Pack Of 12)

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is a premium quality product that comes in a pack of 12 with each can weighing 28 ounces. This ready-to-use sauce is made from vine-ripened New Jersey tomatoes that are hand-picked throughout the season. The sauce is prepared using a family recipe that has been trusted for generations.

The sauce is a rich blend of garlic, salt, spices, and pure corn oil. The high-quality ingredients used in the sauce make it a perfect addition to any pizza. The sauce is fully prepared, so you don't have to worry about spending time and effort preparing it. Just open the can and use it right away.

One of the best things about Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is that it contains no citric acid. Citric acid is a common ingredient used in many pizza sauces, but it can cause heartburn and acid reflux in some people. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is a healthier alternative as it does not contain this ingredient.

Using Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is very easy. All you have to do is lift the tab to the rim of the can and peel it back carefully. The edges may be sharp, so it is important to use care when opening the can. Once the can is open, you can use the sauce right away.

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is perfect for those who love to make pizza at home. The sauce is made using high-quality ingredients and a trusted family recipe. This ensures that you get a delicious pizza every time you use it. The sauce is also versatile and can be used for other dishes as well.

In conclusion, Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is a premium quality product that is perfect for those who love to make pizza at home. It is made using vine-ripened New Jersey tomatoes, garlic, salt, spices, and pure corn oil. It is fully prepared, contains no citric acid, and is very easy to use. It is a family recipe that you can trust to deliver a delicious pizza every time.

8. Dei Fratelli Pizza Sauce – All-Natural, Non-Gmo, Gluten-Free (15 Oz. Cans, 12 Pack)

Dei Fratelli Pizza Sauce is an all-natural, gluten-free sauce made from vine-ripened tomatoes that are picked just hours before packaging and preserving. Unlike other brands that use paste and water, Dei Fratelli Pizza Sauce is made from fresh, real tomatoes that create a delicious, fresh flavor for you to enjoy.

This Pizza Sauce is perfect for those who want convenience without sacrificing taste. With its rich, gourmet flavor, this sauce provides a true fresh-from-the-garden experience that your family will love. Whether you are making pizza at home or just need a quick and easy sauce for dipping, Dei Fratelli Pizza Sauce is the perfect choice.

The recipe for this Pizza Sauce is based on a long family recipe that includes natural sea salt, olive oil, garlic, onion, oregano, and basil flavors. These ingredients combine to create a real pizzeria-style experience that is sure to please even the most discerning palate.

Dei Fratelli takes quality seriously, and they control the entire process from germinating their own seedlings to determining the perfect harvest time. Each BPA-free, recyclable package is sealed for freshness, ensuring that you get the best possible product every time.

This Pizza Sauce is Non-GMO Project Verified and preservative-free, so you can trust that you are getting a high-quality product that is good for you and your family. The American-grown produce is grown on Dei Fratelli's own farms, as well as local family farms in Northwest Ohio and Southeast Michigan. This fifth-generation family company is committed to providing mouth-watering, fresh-packed tomatoes that are perfect for all your culinary needs.

In conclusion, Dei Fratelli Pizza Sauce is a delicious, convenient, and high-quality sauce that is perfect for any occasion. Whether you are making pizza, dipping breadsticks, or creating a delicious pasta dish, this sauce is sure to impress. With its fresh, real tomato flavor and pizzeria-style taste, Dei Fratelli Pizza Sauce is a must-have for any food lover.

Best Tomatoes For Pizza Sauce FAQs

Are there any specific characteristics to look for when selecting tomatoes for pizza sauce?

When selecting tomatoes for pizza sauce, there are several characteristics to look for. Firstly, it is important to choose tomatoes that have a high acid content as this will help to balance out the sweetness of the sauce. San Marzano tomatoes are a popular choice for pizza sauce as they are known for their firm texture, low moisture content, and sweet, tangy flavor.

Additionally, it is important to choose ripe tomatoes that are free from blemishes or bruises, as these can affect the taste and texture of the sauce. Some pizza makers prefer to use canned tomatoes as they are often more consistent in quality and flavor.

Ultimately, the best tomatoes for pizza sauce will depend on personal preference and the specific recipe being used. Experimenting with different types of tomatoes and preparation methods can help to create a delicious and unique pizza sauce.

How can I prepare and cook the tomatoes to achieve the best pizza sauce flavor and consistency?

To prepare the tomatoes for the best pizza sauce, start by choosing ripe and flavorful tomatoes, such as San Marzano tomatoes. Remove the stems and core, and make a small X mark at the bottom of each tomato. Blanch them in boiling water for around 30 seconds, then transfer to an ice bath to halt the cooking process. Remove the skins and use a spoon to scoop out the seeds and excess juice, leaving only the flesh.

For the sauce, sauté garlic and onion in olive oil until fragrant. Add the tomato flesh and cook for around 10-15 minutes until it thickens. Add salt and pepper to taste, and optionally, herbs like oregano or basil.

For a smoother consistency, blend the sauce until it reaches your desired texture.

Overall, using fresh and ripe tomatoes, blanching and removing the skins and seeds, and cooking the sauce with aromatics and herbs will result in the best pizza sauce flavor and consistency.

How do the different types of tomatoes affect the flavor and texture of pizza sauce?

The different types of tomatoes can affect the flavor and texture of pizza sauce. The San Marzano tomato, for example, is a popular choice for pizza sauce because of its low acidity and high sugar content, which produces a sweet and rich flavor. Roma tomatoes are also commonly used because they are meatier and contain fewer seeds, resulting in a thicker and heartier sauce. On the other hand, using beefsteak tomatoes can result in a watery sauce due to their high water content.

Other factors that can affect the flavor and texture of pizza sauce include the ripeness of the tomatoes, the cooking method, and the addition of herbs and spices. Overall, the type of tomato used in pizza sauce can greatly impact the taste and texture of the final product, making it important to choose the right variety for the desired result.

Should I use fresh or canned tomatoes for making pizza sauce?

Both fresh and canned tomatoes can be used for making pizza sauce, but it ultimately depends on personal preference and the desired outcome.

Fresh tomatoes can provide a more vibrant and fresh flavor to the sauce, but they require more work to prepare. They need to be blanched, peeled, seeded, and then cooked down into a sauce. This method can also result in a thinner consistency, which may not be ideal for some pizza styles.

Canned tomatoes, on the other hand, are already peeled and cooked, so they save time and effort. They also tend to have a thicker consistency, making them perfect for deep-dish or stuffed crust pizzas. However, canned tomatoes can sometimes have a metallic aftertaste or lack the fresh flavor that fresh tomatoes provide.

Ultimately, the choice between fresh or canned tomatoes for pizza sauce depends on personal preference, the type of pizza being made, and the time and effort available for preparation.

What are the best tomato varieties for making pizza sauce?

When it comes to making pizza sauce, there are a few varieties of tomatoes that are known for their flavor and texture. San Marzano tomatoes are often considered the best for pizza sauce due to their low acidity and firm flesh. They are also known for their sweet, rich flavor and are often used in Italian cuisine. Another popular variety for pizza sauce is the Roma tomato, which is also known for its low water content and firm flesh. This variety has a slightly more acidic flavor, which can be balanced out with herbs and spices. Other good options include the Amish Paste tomato, which is meaty and flavorful, and the Jersey Fresh tomato, which is sweet and juicy. Ultimately, the best tomato variety for pizza sauce will depend on personal preference and the specific recipe being used.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment