20 Best Pie To Make For Thanksgiving (2023 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Pie is a dish that is typically made with a crust and a filling. The crust is usually made with flour, butter, and water, and the filling is typically made with fruit, custard, or pudding.

20 Best Pie To Make For Thanksgiving

Product Image Product Name Features Price

Libby's Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy – 30 oz

  • Kosher
  • Good Source of Fiber
  • Low in Fat

Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)

  • Miller’s Old Fashioned Large 2″ Pot Pie Squares makes any recipe delicious.
  • Quality comes naturally when using the traditional homemade process handed down from Mrs. Miller’s Amish heritage.

Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies – 13.1 oz box

  • These tarts are made with finest and purest ingredients.
  • Heat briefly in the microwave to deliver a home bake taste.
  • They are traditionally served warm with fresh cream, creme fraiche, ice cream, custard or brandy butter.

Bobs Red Mill Pie Crust Mix, Gluten Free – 16 oz

  • Bag (1 lbs.)
  • Gluten Free; Vegetarian; Kosher Pareve
  • Manufactured in a dedicated gluten free facility; R5-ELISA tested gluten free

Dash Mini Pie Maker – Red

  • Compact appliance easily prepares delicious, single-serving mini-pies
  • PFOA-free nonstick surface heats quickly and cooks evenly

Comstock Apple Pie Filling or Topping, No Sugar Added – 20 oz

  • Duncan Hines
  • No Sugar Added Apple Pie Filling & Topping
  • 20oz Can

Mrs. Anderson's Baking Easy Pie Crust Maker, 14"

  • 11-12 Inch

Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey – 7 oz

  • Contains: Soy, Milk, Wheat
  • May Contain: Eggs, Fish
  • Package Quantity: 1

Marie Callender's Pie, Pumpkin – 36 oz

  • Extra Flaky Crust Made from Scratch
  • Kosher Dairy
  • Made with Real Pumpkin

Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate – 25.5 oz

  • 25.5 oz

Edwards Pecan Pie, Georgia Style – 32 oz

  • Thaw & serve
  • Kosher

Marie Callender's Pie, Southern Pecan – 32 oz

  • A True Southern Classic
  • Extra Flaky
  • Crust Made from Scratch

Pillsbury Pie Crusts – 2 crusts, 14.1 oz

  • Grams trans fats
  • America’s #1 Pie Crust
  • Just unroll, fill & bake

Marie Callender's Pot Pie, Turkey – 10 oz

  • 10 oz

First Street Graham Cracker Pie Crust, 9"

  • Ready to use straight out of the package
  • Delicious and with a cookie-like shortbread taste
  • Just add pudding, fruit, and dessert fillings
Libby's Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy – 30 oz
  • Kosher
  • Good Source of Fiber
  • Low in Fat
Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)
  • Miller’s Old Fashioned Large 2″ Pot Pie Squares makes any recipe delicious.
  • Quality comes naturally when using the traditional homemade process handed down from Mrs. Miller’s Amish heritage.
Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies – 13.1 oz box
  • These tarts are made with finest and purest ingredients.
  • Heat briefly in the microwave to deliver a home bake taste.
  • They are traditionally served warm with fresh cream, creme fraiche, ice cream, custard or brandy butter.
Bobs Red Mill Pie Crust Mix, Gluten Free – 16 oz
  • Bag (1 lbs.)
  • Gluten Free; Vegetarian; Kosher Pareve
  • Manufactured in a dedicated gluten free facility; R5-ELISA tested gluten free
Dash Mini Pie Maker – Red
  • Compact appliance easily prepares delicious, single-serving mini-pies
  • PFOA-free nonstick surface heats quickly and cooks evenly
Comstock Apple Pie Filling or Topping, No Sugar Added – 20 oz
  • Duncan Hines
  • No Sugar Added Apple Pie Filling & Topping
  • 20oz Can
Mrs. Anderson's Baking Easy Pie Crust Maker, 14"
  • 11-12 Inch
Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey – 7 oz
  • Contains: Soy, Milk, Wheat
  • May Contain: Eggs, Fish
  • Package Quantity: 1
Marie Callender's Pie, Pumpkin – 36 oz
  • Extra Flaky Crust Made from Scratch
  • Kosher Dairy
  • Made with Real Pumpkin
Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate – 25.5 oz
  • 25.5 oz
Edwards Pecan Pie, Georgia Style – 32 oz
  • Thaw & serve
  • Kosher
Marie Callender's Pie, Southern Pecan – 32 oz
  • A True Southern Classic
  • Extra Flaky
  • Crust Made from Scratch
Pillsbury Pie Crusts – 2 crusts, 14.1 oz
  • Grams trans fats
  • America’s #1 Pie Crust
  • Just unroll, fill & bake
Marie Callender's Pot Pie, Turkey – 10 oz
  • 10 oz
First Street Graham Cracker Pie Crust, 9"
  • Ready to use straight out of the package
  • Delicious and with a cookie-like shortbread taste
  • Just add pudding, fruit, and dessert fillings

1. Libby’s Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy – 30 oz

Libby's Libbys Pumpkin Pie Mix, Easy - 30 oz

  • Kosher
  • Good Source of Fiber
  • Low in Fat
  • Gluten Free
  • All Natural; No Preservatives

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Fred Meyer
ShopFoodEx.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Measure 87g
Food Servings Per Container About 10
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Fat Free

Reviews From Real Customers

emepag
Livi
Jayme

2. Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)

Mrs. Millers Homemade Old Fashioned Large 2 Pot Pie Squares 16 oz. Bag (2 Bags)

  • Miller’s Old Fashioned Large 2″ Pot Pie Squares makes any recipe delicious.
  • Quality comes naturally when using the traditional homemade process handed down from Mrs. Miller’s Amish heritage.
  • Since 1973 Mrs. Miller’s Pasta have been producing the finest egg noodles available in a variety of sizes and flavors.
  • Simple and quality ingredients.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – deals4u001
Grocery.com Store
Bonanza – M&M Trading

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 12 x 2 x 9 inches; 2.05 Pounds

Reviews From Real Customers

nancysw
Lynda

3. Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies – 13.1 oz box

Walkers Luxury Mincemeat Pies - 13.1 oz box

  • These tarts are made with finest and purest ingredients.
  • Heat briefly in the microwave to deliver a home bake taste.
  • They are traditionally served warm with fresh cream, creme fraiche, ice cream, custard or brandy butter.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
BritishCornerShop.co.uk
Walkers Shortbread
World Market

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Total Fat 10g
Saturated Fat 5g
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 25.00mg
Sodium 75mg

Reviews From Real Customers

paige.o
elizabeth.c
jourdan.l

4. Bobs Red Mill Pie Crust Mix, Gluten Free – 16 oz

Bobs Red Mill Pie Crust Mix, Gluten Free - 16 oz

  • Bag (1 lbs.)
  • Gluten Free; Vegetarian; Kosher Pareve
  • Manufactured in a dedicated gluten free facility; R5-ELISA tested gluten free
  • Easy to prepare mix
  • Each 16oz package makes two 9-inch crusts

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Swanson Health Products
Bob’s Red Mill Natural Foods
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 3 Tbsp mix
Food Serving Size Measure 30g
Food Servings Per Container About 15
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

RB
HD401

5. The Bakery Pecan Mini Pie

The Bakery Pecan Mini Pie

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1 pie
Food Serving Size Measure 92g
Food Servings Per Container 1
Allergens CONTAINS MILK, EGGS, PECANS AND WHEAT. MAY CONTAIN TRACES OF COCONUT AND SOY.
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

moodykind
Jeanne
ShopShopper

6. Kbosh Pumpkin Zucchini Pie & Dessert Crust: Make Delicious Low-Carb Pies, Dessert Pizzas, More

Kbosh Pumpkin Zucchini Pie & Dessert Crust: Make Delicious Low-Carb Pies, Dessert Pizzas, More

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
KBosh

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

Julia C.
sacha g.
Sophie J.

7. Dash Mini Pie Maker – Red

Dash Mini Pie Maker - Red

  • Compact appliance easily prepares delicious, single-serving mini-pies
  • PFOA-free nonstick surface heats quickly and cooks evenly
  • Circular crust cutter sized to the pie maker takes the guesswork from cutting your pie crust

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Sam’s Club
Kohl’s

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Length 6.7 in
Height 4.3 in
Width 4.7 in

Reviews From Real Customers

HappyGirl
Stacey T.
CNH624

8. Comstock Apple Pie Filling or Topping, No Sugar Added – 20 oz

Comstock Apple Pie Filling or Topping, No Sugar Added - 20 oz

  • Duncan Hines
  • No Sugar Added Apple Pie Filling & Topping
  • 20oz Can

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Netrition.com
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Measure 85g
Food Servings Per Container about 7
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

9. Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Easy Pie Crust Maker, 14″

Mrs. Anderson's Baking Easy Pie Crust Maker, 14

  • 11-12 Inch

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Walmart
Ace Hardware

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Length 14 in.
Product Type Pie Crust Bag
Color White
Brand Name Mrs. Anderson’s

Reviews From Real Customers

sharronrenee
Maggie47
Dennis27

10. Krusteaz Professional 5 lb. Pie Crust Mix

Krusteaz Professional 5 lb. Pie Crust Mix

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
WebstaurantStore.com
Round Eye Supply
Warehouse 115

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Weight 33.5 lb

Reviews From Real Customers

KansasGal
Rita

11. Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey – 7 oz

Banquet Pot Pie, Turkey - 7 oz

  • Contains: Soy, Milk, Wheat
  • May Contain: Eggs, Fish
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Net weight: 7 Ounces

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Fred Meyer
pointy.com/shops/usa/california/angels-camp/altaville-marketcraft-beer-liquorlocal-winesporting-goodsat-and-t-verizon-prepaid-cell-accessory
La Favorita Market Rancho

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1 pie
Food Serving Size Measure 198g
Food Servings Per Container 1
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, SOY, WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

MikeW.
James E
brittany.s

12. Marie Callender’s Pie, Pumpkin – 36 oz

Marie Callender's Pie, Pumpkin - 36 oz

  • Extra Flaky Crust Made from Scratch
  • Kosher Dairy
  • Made with Real Pumpkin
  • Serve with a Dollop of Reddi-Wip

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Fred Meyer
Boxed Market
Albion Mercantile Co

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 pie
Food Serving Size Measure 128g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: EGG, MILK, WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

abb77
DeeD
mariecallendersmeals.com

13. Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate – 25.5 oz

Edwards Creme Pie, Chocolate - 25.5 oz

  • 25.5 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Target
Fred Meyer
La Favorita Market Rancho

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 Pie
Food Serving Size Measure 90g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, SOY.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

teala.w
TM82
momina.i

14. Edwards Pecan Pie, Georgia Style – 32 oz

Edwards Pecan Pie, Georgia Style - 32 oz

  • Thaw & serve
  • Kosher

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 Pie
Food Serving Size Measure 113g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: WHEAT, EGGS, TREE NUTS (PECANS), MILK, SOY.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

Kimbly

15. Marie Callender’s Pie, Southern Pecan – 32 oz

Marie Callender's Pie, Southern Pecan - 32 oz

  • A True Southern Classic
  • Extra Flaky
  • Crust Made from Scratch
  • Kosher Dairy

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 pie
Food Serving Size Measure 113g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: TREE NUT (PECAN), EGG, WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

CityKity
LocalAreaMan
lesli.h

16. Pillsbury Pie Crusts – 2 crusts, 14.1 oz

Pillsbury Pie Crusts - 2 crusts, 14.1 oz

  • Grams trans fats
  • America’s #1 Pie Crust
  • Just unroll, fill & bake

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Target
Fred Meyer
FreshDirect

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 crust
Food Serving Size Measure 25g
Food Servings Per Container 16
Allergens CONTAINS WHEAT INGREDIENTS.
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

Dmblaze
Janfl34
EuroFemme

17. Marie Callender’s Pot Pie, Turkey – 10 oz

Marie Callender's Pot Pie, Turkey - 10 oz

  • 10 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Fred Meyer
Boxed Market

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1 PIE
Food Serving Size Measure 283g
Allergens CONTAINS: MILK, SOY, WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Caffeine Free

Reviews From Real Customers

BJP719
Illiniwek
pentagrid

18. Collin Street Bakery Pecan Pie

Collin Street Bakery Pecan Pie

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Collin Street Bakery

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Servings per Package 8 | 1 lbs 10 oz

Reviews From Real Customers

Vicky H.
MRS B.
collinstreet.com

19. First Street Graham Cracker Pie Crust, 9″

First Street Graham Cracker Pie Crust, 9

  • Ready to use straight out of the package
  • Delicious and with a cookie-like shortbread taste
  • Just add pudding, fruit, and dessert fillings

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
La Favorita Market Rancho
La Favorita Market Twain

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 OF 9″ CRUST
Food Serving Size Measure 21g
Food Servings Per Container 8
Allergens CONTAINS: WHEAT
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free

Reviews From Real Customers

JLRester
courtney.s
SaGinTa

20. Marie Callender’s Pie Shells, Deep Dish Pastry – 2 shells, 16 oz

Marie Callender's Pie Shells, Deep Dish Pastry - 2 shells, 16 oz

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Albertsons
Safeway
Vons
Fred Meyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Food Serving Size Description 1/8 CRUST
Food Serving Size Measure 28g
Food Servings Per Container 16
Allergens CONTAINS: WHEAT.
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free

Reviews From Real Customers

StewTex
tracey.m
quiche cook

Best Pie To Make For Thanksgiving Buying Guides

This is a difficult question to answer without knowing more about the specifics of the situation. Generally speaking, you would need to know how many people will be attending Thanksgiving dinner, what their appetite levels are likely to be, and what other dishes will be served. With that said, a good rule of thumb is to make one pie for every eight people. This will ensure that there is plenty of pie to go around and that everyone can have a generous slice.

Conclusion

If you’re looking for a traditional Thanksgiving pie, you can’t go wrong with pumpkin or apple. But there are plenty of other delicious options to choose from, like pecan, sweet potato, and even chocolate. No matter what type of pie you make, be sure to use fresh ingredients and follow the recipe to the letter for best results.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment