Best Paint Finish For Fireplace Mantel (2024 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

If you’re looking for the best paint finish for your fireplace mantel, you’ll need to consider a few factors before making a purchase. The right paint finish can enhance the beauty of your mantel and protect it from damage, ensuring it looks its best for years to come.

First, you’ll need to consider the type of material your mantel is made of. Some paints work better on wood, while others are more suited for brick or stone. Additionally, you’ll want to think about the style of your home and the surrounding decor, making sure the paint finish you choose complements the overall aesthetic.

When selecting a paint finish for your fireplace mantel, it’s important to ask yourself a few key questions. Do you want a glossy or matte finish? Will the paint need to withstand high temperatures or moisture exposure? By taking the time to ask these questions, you can ensure you choose the best paint finish for your unique needs.

Overall, finding the best paint finish for your fireplace mantel will require some careful consideration. By taking the time to research your options and evaluate your specific needs, you can make an informed decision that will leave your mantel looking beautiful for years to come.

10 Best Paint Finish For Fireplace Mantel

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
This product is ideal for painting furniture, home decor, and DIY crafts without sanding or using a primer.
2
The product is ideal for painting furniture with a chalky finish, and comes with a complete starter kit.
3
This product is ideal for supporting shelves, mantels or corbels with an 8"x10" size.
4
Ideal for giving furniture and home decor a smooth, ultra-matte coastal blue finish with minimal prep and easy clean-up.
5
Ideal for interior use, providing a clear matte finish on various surfaces with its chalked acrylic formula.
6
The product is ideal for painting furniture, cabinets, floors, walls, home decor, and accessories with a non-toxic, water-based matte finish.
7
The product is ideal for giving a luxurious, rustic matte finish to wood furniture or DIY projects.
8
Ideal for painting furniture and cabinets without the need to strip, sand or prime, while being eco-friendly.
9
This paint is ideal for achieving a smooth, matte finish on various surfaces, such as wood, metal, ceramic, and more.
10
It's ideal for giving furniture a chalky finish that can be distressed or waxed for a vintage look.
This product is ideal for painting furniture, home decor, and DIY crafts without sanding or using a primer.
The product is ideal for painting furniture with a chalky finish, and comes with a complete starter kit.
This product is ideal for supporting shelves, mantels or corbels with an 8"x10" size.
Ideal for giving furniture and home decor a smooth, ultra-matte coastal blue finish with minimal prep and easy clean-up.
Ideal for interior use, providing a clear matte finish on various surfaces with its chalked acrylic formula.
The product is ideal for painting furniture, cabinets, floors, walls, home decor, and accessories with a non-toxic, water-based matte finish.
The product is ideal for giving a luxurious, rustic matte finish to wood furniture or DIY projects.
Ideal for painting furniture and cabinets without the need to strip, sand or prime, while being eco-friendly.
This paint is ideal for achieving a smooth, matte finish on various surfaces, such as wood, metal, ceramic, and more.
It's ideal for giving furniture a chalky finish that can be distressed or waxed for a vintage look.

1. Midnight Peacock Blue Chalk Paint – Diy Crafts & Home Decor.

This Premium Chalk Style Paint is the perfect solution for those who want to update and transform their furniture, cabinets, upholstery, and home decor. It offers superior coverage on a variety of surfaces, both indoor and outdoor, including wood, laminate, glass, resin, metal, brick, and cement.

Designed for both distressed and modern contemporary styles, this versatile paint requires little to no prep work and is spray gun ready, making it easy to use for any DIY project. Its ultra-low VOC, hypoallergenic, and low odor composition makes it safe for use around children and indoors.

Achieving a smooth chalky matte finish has never been easier with this high-quality chalk finish paint. After just 30 minutes, it dries to a chalky matte finish that's easy to distress and very durable with a silky finish. To ensure long-lasting results, simply seal the finish with a clear furniture wax or a polycrylic.

Made in the USA, you can trust the quality of this chalk style paint to produce professional results. So why wait? Transform your home with this eco-friendly and safe, premium chalk style paint today!

2. Retique It Chalk Furniture Paint By Renaissance Deluxe Starter Kit, 8 Piece Set, 01 Snow

The furniture and home decor industry has a new product that promises great results and superior coverage. The product requires little-to-no prep work and adheres amazingly well to a wide variety of surfaces. The product is ideal for furniture, cabinets, and more, and can even be used for craft and art projects.

Not only is this product great for interior projects, but it also works wonders for exterior projects too. The product's versatility is impressive, and it can be used for both interior and exterior projects alike. For exterior projects, all that's needed is a marine finish topcoat like their Polytique It before applying the clear wax.

The product's finish is silky, chalky, and smooth. It dries quickly within 30 minutes to a contemporary finish with their clear wax or a chalky matte finish that's easy to distress if desired, yet exceptionally durable.

One of the most impressive features of this product is that it's eco-friendly and safe to use. It has a low odor and ultra-low VOC, making it hypoallergenic with virtually no smell. This means that it is safe to use around people, animals, and the environment.

3. One 8"x10" Iron Support Bracket, Mantel Bracket, Shelf Bracket, Corbel

This product is an exceptional support solution for mantels, shelving, and countertop overhangs. The support can be flipped in either direction to fit your desired application. It comes in a durable black powder coat color option that adds a sleek and modern touch to your space. The support system is designed to withstand heavy-duty use, ensuring that your overhangs are safe and secure.

Each support is pre-drilled with 5/16” mounting holes, making installation quick and easy. The heavy-duty design of the support ensures that it can handle the weight of heavy objects, providing you with peace of mind and added safety.

One of the unique features of this product is its design. The support system is designed to be both functional and aesthetically pleasing, adding a touch of elegance to your decor. It is perfect for use in both residential and commercial spaces and is suitable for a wide range of applications.

4. Rust-Oleum Chalked Ultra Matte Coastal Blue Water-Based Chalk Paint 30 Oz.

Introducing a versatile and easy-to-use paint product that guarantees excellent results with just one coat – ideal for those looking to achieve a flawless finish in no time. This paint is specially formulated to provide full coverage on a variety of surfaces, including wood, metal, and even glass, making it a great choice for all your DIY projects.

With its user-friendly application, this paint can be effortlessly applied using a brush, roller, or sprayer, ensuring that even the most inexperienced user can achieve professional-looking results. Its indoor use only specification ensures that it is perfect for use in your home, and it's quick-drying formula means that you can enjoy your newly painted space in no time.

One of the most impressive features of this paint is its smooth, velvety finish, which adds a touch of elegance to any surface. Whether you want to create a modern or vintage look, this paint can be easily distressed to achieve the desired effect. With its extensive range of colors, you can choose the perfect shade to complement any décor style.

In terms of product specifications, this paint comes in a convenient size that is perfect for small or large projects, making it a cost-effective solution for any DIY enthusiast. Additionally, it is made with high-quality, non-toxic materials that are safe for use around the home, making it a great choice for families with children or pets.

5. Rust-Oleum 287722 Ultra Interior Chalked Acrylic Paint 30 Oz, 30 Fl Oz (Pack Of 1), Clear Matte

This versatile paint is perfect for those looking to achieve a vintage aesthetic on a variety of interior surfaces. Its low-odor/VOC formula makes for easy clean up with soap and water, while its quick-drying capabilities allow for projects to be completed in a timely manner. With one-coat coverage and the ability to cover up to 150 sq. ft., this paint is both efficient and effective. The excellent adhesion and easy application also require minimal preparation, making it a convenient option for any DIY project. Additionally, the protective topcoat dries to an ultra-matte velvety, smooth finish, providing a beautiful and durable final result. Give your home a touch of character with this exceptional paint.

6. Jolie Matte Paint: Transform Your Home Beautifully!

The Jolie Paint Company has introduced a remarkable paint product that requires minimal to no prep with no sanding or priming, making it a fantastic option for those who want to renovate their homes without the hassle of prepping their surfaces. The Jolie Paint is easy to apply on a variety of interior surfaces, making it a versatile option for any DIY project.

The paint is water-based, which makes it very easy to clean up using soap and water, unlike oil-based paints that require solvents and other harsh chemicals. Additionally, the Jolie Paint is non-toxic and low VOC, which means it is safe to use indoors, even in children's rooms or nurseries.

One of the notable features of Jolie Paint is its superior coverage. A 32oz quart can cover about 150 sq. ft, while a 4oz sample can cover up to 20 sq. ft. Most colors need only one or two coats, which saves time and money.

Jolie Paint dries quickly in just 30 minutes to a flat (matte) finish, making it a great option for those who want fast results. For those who prefer a higher sheen, the Jolie Finishing Wax can be used to buff the surface to a higher shine.

7. Chic Antique White Furniture Paint

The Shabby Chic interior design style is all about embracing the beauty of imperfection, and that's exactly what this specially-formulated paint achieves. With a distressed and imperfect finish, it's perfect for those looking to restore their furniture with a unique touch.

This chalk-based paint offers great coverage, saving you both time and money. It's also incredibly long-lasting and requires little-to-no prep work for wooden surfaces (just ensure they're clean before painting). The thinner consistency of this paint, combined with superior pigments, makes it ideal for achieving the brush strokes and distressed look that shabby chic is known for.

Not just limited to wooden furniture, this paint is also suitable for use on metal, plastic, brick, stone, and plaster. You can easily refurbish a wooden dresser, vanity, picture frame, or crib without the need for a primer (although one is recommended for other surfaces).

The advanced formula of this paint is non-toxic and water-based, with a low odor and ultra low VOC. It contains no harsh chemicals such as phthalates, formaldehyde, heavy metals, or solvents, making it a safe and eco-friendly choice. This genuine quality paint is made in the U.K. just outside of London, guaranteeing its authenticity and reliability.

8. Chalky Credenza: Eco-Friendly Furniture Makeover

The Premium Furniture Paint is a game changer for anyone who wants to give their furniture a new lease on life. Whether you're a DIY expert or a beginner, this one-step chalk paint makes it easy to transform any piece of furniture from dull to dazzling.

Unlike traditional paints, the Premium Furniture Paint requires no stripping, sanding, or priming. With just one application, you can achieve a clean, crisp finish without having to put in extra elbow grease. The all-in-one formula does the work for you, making the painting process a breeze.

The best part? The paint is safe and easy to use. The fully water-based formula is completely VOC-free, allowing you to work where you want without worrying about harmful fumes. Plus, it's touch-dry in just 20 minutes, so you can finish projects that much faster.

The Premium Furniture Paint is also incredibly versatile. It works on a wide range of surfaces, including wood, glass, fabric, resin, melamine, Formica, concrete, iron, and stone. It's even durable enough for outdoor furniture and décor.

With dozens of timeless hues to choose from, you're sure to find just the right color for your project. From soft neutrals to bold statement colors, the wide range of colors will help you achieve the look you're going for.

9. Rustoleum 285143 30 Oz Aged Gray Chalked Ultra Matte Paint

The RUST-OLEUM Chalked Ultra Matte Paint is a versatile and durable paint that offers one-coat coverage on a variety of surfaces. The easy application process and velvety smooth finish make it a popular choice among DIY enthusiasts and professionals alike.

One of the unique features of this paint is its ability to be easily distressed to create a vintage look. Simply scuff high-gloss surfaces with sandpaper or a sanding sponge and apply 1 to 3 even coats 30 minutes apart. The thick, one-coat coverage allows projects to be completed easily, saving time and effort.

In addition to its ease of use, the RUST-OLEUM Chalked Ultra Matte Paint boasts excellent adhesion and minimal prep work, with no priming necessary. The paint dries in 2 to 4 hours, making recoating a breeze.

For those looking to replicate the timeless style of 18th century decor, distressing the paint can create a unique aged, chippy look. The paint is also easy to clean up with soap and water, and is a low-VOC/water-based formula, making it a safe and environmentally-friendly option.

When working with bare wood surfaces, it is recommended to prime first with ZINSSER bulls-eye white primer for optimal results. Additionally, the paint can be mixed with other RUST-OLEUM chalked paints to create a custom color, and top-coated with chalked matte clear for added protection and durability.

10. Retique It Chalk Furniture Paint By Renaissance Diy, Gallon, 01 Snow

The product being reviewed is a premium paint that delivers great results with superior coverage. It is specifically formulated for furniture, cabinets, and home decor, but can also be used for craft and art projects. The paint is suitable for both interior and exterior projects, and for outdoor use, a marine finish topcoat is recommended before applying the clear wax.

This paint provides a silky, chalky-smooth finish that dries within 30 minutes. It can be finished with a clear wax for a contemporary look or left with a chalky matte finish that is easy to distress if desired. The finish is highly durable, making it ideal for high-traffic areas or items that will be frequently used.

In addition to its exceptional performance, the paint is also eco-friendly and safe to use. It has a low odor and ultra-low VOC content, making it hypoallergenic and virtually odorless. Users can enjoy the benefits of a high-quality paint without any unpleasant or harmful side effects.

Best Paint Finish For Fireplace Mantel FAQs

Can I paint my fireplace mantel with a spray paint?

Yes, you can definitely paint your fireplace mantel with spray paint. However, there are a few things you should keep in mind before doing so. Firstly, make sure the surface of the mantel is clean and dry before you start painting. Use a mild detergent and water to clean it, and let it dry completely before you begin painting.

Secondly, it is important to choose the right type of spray paint for your fireplace mantel. Look for a heat-resistant spray paint that is suitable for use on metal or wood surfaces. This will ensure that the paint will not peel or crack due to the high temperatures generated by the fireplace.

Lastly, spray painting requires a bit of skill and practice, so it may be helpful to practice on a small, inconspicuous area before you start painting the entire mantel. Follow the instructions on the spray paint can carefully, and apply thin, even coats of paint to achieve a smooth and professional-looking finish.

Overall, spray painting your fireplace mantel can be a great way to update its look and give your room a fresh new feel. Just be sure to take the necessary precautions and follow the proper steps to ensure a successful and long-lasting paint job.

Can I use a high-gloss finish on a wooden fireplace mantel?

Yes, you can use a high-gloss finish on a wooden fireplace mantel. However, it is important to prepare the surface properly before applying any finish. First, sand the mantel with a fine-grit sandpaper to remove any rough spots or imperfections. Then, wipe the surface clean with a damp cloth to remove any dust or debris. Next, apply a wood conditioner to the mantel to help the wood absorb the finish evenly. Finally, apply the high-gloss finish in thin, even coats with a paintbrush or sprayer, allowing each coat to dry completely before applying the next. Be sure to follow the manufacturer's instructions for application and drying times. Keep in mind that high-gloss finishes tend to highlight imperfections and scratches, so it is important to take extra care when preparing and applying the finish to achieve a smooth, flawless finish.

How do I prepare my fireplace mantel for painting?

Preparing your fireplace mantel for painting is an important step to ensure that the paint adheres well and looks smooth and even. Here are the steps you can follow:

1. Clean the mantel: Use a soft cloth and a cleaning solution to wipe down the entire surface of the mantel. Make sure to remove any dirt, dust, or grime that may have accumulated on the surface.

2. Sand the surface: Use a fine-grit sandpaper to lightly sand the surface of the mantel. This will help to remove any rough spots or imperfections and create a smooth surface for the paint to adhere to.

3. Fill any gaps or holes: If there are any gaps or holes in the mantel, use wood filler to fill them in. Allow the filler to dry completely before proceeding.

4. Prime the surface: Apply a coat of primer to the surface of the mantel. This will help the paint to adhere well and prevent any stains or discoloration from bleeding through.

5. Paint the surface: Once the primer has dried completely, you can apply your chosen paint to the surface of the mantel. Apply the paint evenly and allow it to dry completely before applying a second coat if necessary.

By following these steps, you can prepare your fireplace mantel for painting and achieve a smooth and even finish that will look great in your home.

Is it necessary to use a heat-resistant paint on a fireplace mantel?

Yes, it is necessary to use a heat-resistant paint on a fireplace mantel. Fireplaces generate a significant amount of heat, and the mantel is often exposed to high temperatures. Using regular paint on a fireplace mantel can be dangerous as it can easily catch fire, leading to a potential disaster.

Heat-resistant paint is specially formulated to withstand high temperatures and is designed to provide a protective coating on surfaces exposed to heat sources. This type of paint is typically made with special resins and pigments that can withstand temperatures up to 1200°F. It helps to prevent the paint from peeling, flaking, or cracking due to the high temperatures.

In summary, using a heat-resistant paint on a fireplace mantel is necessary to ensure safety and prevent any potential fire hazards. It is essential to choose a paint that is specifically designed for high-heat applications to ensure optimal performance and protection.

Should I choose a glossy or matte finish for my fireplace mantel?

When it comes to choosing a finish for your fireplace mantel, both glossy and matte options have their own advantages and disadvantages. A glossy finish can add a sleek and modern look to your mantel, and can be easier to clean and maintain than a matte finish. However, it may also be more prone to showing fingerprints, smudges, and other marks. On the other hand, a matte finish can give your mantel a more natural and rustic feel, and may be less likely to show marks or imperfections. However, it may also be harder to clean and maintain than a glossy finish. Ultimately, the choice between a glossy or matte finish will depend on your personal style preferences and the overall look and feel of your home. Consider factors such as the amount of natural light in the room, the color scheme of the space, and the intended use of the fireplace when making your decision.

What are the most popular paint finishes for fireplace mantels?

There are several popular paint finishes for fireplace mantels that can enhance the overall look and feel of your fireplace. One popular finish is a high gloss or semi-gloss finish, which provides a shiny and reflective surface that can complement a modern or contemporary decor. Another popular option is a matte or flat finish, which can give a sophisticated and understated look that works well with traditional or rustic designs. A satin finish is also a popular choice, as it provides a subtle sheen that can add a touch of elegance to any mantel. Ultimately, the choice of paint finish will depend on the style and color of your fireplace, as well as your personal preferences. It is always a good idea to consult with a professional painter or designer to ensure that you choose the right finish for your specific needs and budget.

What brand of paint is best for a fireplace mantel?

Choosing the right paint for a fireplace mantel is important as it can affect the overall look and durability of the finish. The best brand of paint for a fireplace mantel would be one that is heat-resistant, durable, and can withstand the harsh conditions of a fireplace. One of the most popular brands for fireplace mantel painting is Sherwin-Williams. They offer several types of paint that are specifically designed for painting fireplace mantels, including their Heat Resistant Coating and ProClassic Interior Waterbased Acrylic-Alkyd Enamel. These paints are formulated to resist heat and provide a durable finish that can withstand the heat and smoke produced by the fireplace. Other brands that offer heat-resistant paint options for fireplace mantels include Benjamin Moore and Behr. It's important to choose a paint that is specifically designed for use on fireplace mantels to ensure the best results.

What color paint works best for a fireplace mantel?

When it comes to painting a fireplace mantel, there are several factors to consider, such as the style of the mantel, the color scheme of the room, and the overall aesthetic you're trying to achieve. That being said, there are a few colors that tend to work well for fireplace mantels.

One option is to go with a classic white or off-white paint. This can create a clean, timeless look that complements a variety of decor styles. Another popular choice is to paint the mantel a darker color, such as black or charcoal gray. This can add a touch of drama and sophistication to the space.

If you're looking to create a more rustic or natural feel, consider using a wood stain instead of paint. This will allow the natural grain and texture of the wood to show through, while still providing a protective coating.

Ultimately, the best color for your fireplace mantel will depend on your personal preferences and the design of your space. Experiment with different options to find the perfect fit for your home.

What paint finish will give my fireplace mantel a rustic look?

To achieve a rustic look for your fireplace mantel, you may want to consider using a matte or flat paint finish. These finishes have a low sheen and can help to create a more natural and textured appearance, which is perfect for a rustic aesthetic. Additionally, you may want to consider using a paint with a distressed or weathered effect, which can further enhance the rustic look of your mantel. Another option would be to use a chalk paint, which can give your mantel a vintage, shabby-chic look that is also popular in rustic decor. Ultimately, the best paint finish for your fireplace mantel will depend on your personal preferences and the overall style of your home. It may be helpful to consult with a professional painter or interior designer to determine the best approach to achieving your desired rustic look for your mantel.

Which paint finish is best for a high-traffic fireplace mantel?

When it comes to choosing a paint finish for a high-traffic fireplace mantel, it's important to consider durability and resistance to stains and heat. A semi-gloss or high-gloss finish is typically the best choice for a mantel because it is easy to clean and can withstand frequent touching and cleaning. These finishes are also more resistant to heat, making them less likely to discolor or peel over time.

However, it's important to keep in mind that a high-gloss finish may not be the best choice if you want to hide imperfections or rough texture on the mantel. In this case, a satin or eggshell finish may be a better option. These finishes are still durable and easy to clean, but they won't highlight any flaws or uneven areas on the mantel.

Ultimately, the best paint finish for a high-traffic fireplace mantel will depend on your specific needs and preferences. It's always a good idea to test different finishes on a small area of the mantel before committing to a full paint job.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!