Best Milk For Making Yogurt (2024 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

As a yogurt lover, you probably know that the quality of the milk you use plays a crucial role in the taste, texture, and nutritional value of your homemade yogurt. However, with so many types of milk available in supermarkets and farmers' markets, it can be overwhelming to choose the best one for your yogurt-making needs. That's why we've compiled this short guide to help you navigate the world of milk and find the best one for your yogurt.

Firstly, it's important to choose milk that is fresh, pasteurized, and preferably organic. Fresh milk will give you a better taste and texture, while pasteurized milk ensures that harmful bacteria are eliminated. Organic milk is free of antibiotics and growth hormones, which can affect the quality of your yogurt.

Secondly, consider the fat content of the milk. Yogurt can be made with whole milk, low-fat milk, or skim milk. Whole milk will give you a creamier and richer yogurt, while low-fat or skim milk will result in a lighter and less fatty yogurt.

Thirdly, the type of milk you use can also affect the consistency of your yogurt. For instance, using goat's milk will result in a thinner and tangier yogurt, while using cow's milk will give you a thicker and milder yogurt.

Fourthly, if you're lactose intolerant or vegan, you can still make yogurt using non-dairy milk such as soy milk, almond milk, or coconut milk. However, bear in mind that the taste and texture of non-dairy yogurt may differ from traditional yogurt.

Lastly, always check the expiration date of the milk before using it to make yogurt. Expired milk can affect the quality and safety of your yogurt.

By considering these key points, you'll be able to choose the best milk for making yogurt that suits your taste preferences, dietary needs, and budget. Happy yogurt-making!

10 Best Milk For Making Yogurt

1. Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker With Glass Jar And Recipe Book For Homemade Dairy-Free Yogurts.

Introducing the Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker with 1 Quart Glass Jar and Complete Recipe Book to Make 12+ Easy Homemade Dairy Free and Milk Yogurts. This non-electric yogurt maker is perfect for those who want to make their own yogurt without having to deal with bulky and complicated appliances.

Unlike other yogurt makers, this one is simple to use and compact to store. It does not have any timers or elements that could overheat, so you can feel confident to leave it and wake up to thick homemade yogurt. Plus, it comes with a 42-page yogurt making book that gives you expert knowledge to make over 12 different yogurts, including Greek, coconut yogurt, almond, and more.

One of the best things about making your own yogurt is that you can choose natural flavors and make fresh organic yogurt each week for maximum probiotic bacteria with no added sugar or additives. You can also tailor the nutrition to reach your goals by choosing the milk and serving size to make a2 yogurt, keto, gaps, scd yogurt, or plant-based vegan yogurt.

Not only is making your own yogurt healthier and more customizable, but it also helps you be part of the plastic solution. By removing yogurt pouches and packs from your weekly shop, you can save money and the planet. The average home throws out over 200 yogurt pouches and packs each year, but with this quality plastic-free yogurt maker, you can be above average and contribute to reducing plastic waste.

In summary, the Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker with 1 Quart Glass Jar and Complete Recipe Book is a great investment for those who want to make their own yogurt without having to deal with complicated appliances. With its simple design, comprehensive recipe book, and plastic-free solution, you can enjoy natural and customizable yogurt while contributing to a greener planet.

2. Encheng 7oz Glass Yogurt Jars With Pe Lids, Set Of 30 – Clear Glass Containers For Milk, Jams, Mousse – Dishwasher Safe With Twine And Tag.

The Glass Jars,Encheng 7 oz Glass Yogurt Jars With Lids(PE),Replacement Glass Pudding Jars With Plastic Tops,Clear Glass Yogurt Container With Twine n Tag For Milk,Jams,Jelly,Mousse,Dishwaresafe 30 Pack is a set of 30 high-quality glass jars that are perfect for daily use. These clear glass jars are 7oz in size, with an opening of 2.6 inches, a bottom base of 2.75 inches, and a height of 3 inches, providing durability and stability.

Each jar comes with a PE lid that ensures your food remains fresh for longer. The replacement glass jars can last for years, making them an excellent investment. The set also comes with tags and decorative twine, allowing you to mark your foods and name them with free labeling, adding a personal and stylish touch.

These glass jars are great for storing pudding, DIY projects, milk, yogurt, ramekin, homemade jams, jelly, mousse, and other small desserts and spices. Their perfect container size makes them ideal for small desserts, while their classic beautiful design matches all kitchenware perfectly. You can also fill them with party favors, wedding favors, shower favors, cosmetics, powders, snacks, beans, honey, parfaits, baby food, nuts, cookies, and so much more!

These jars are sealed super tight, leak-proof, and keep your food fresh for longer. They are also mouse-proof, keeping bugs and moisture out, preservative and high-temperature resistance. These jars are durable and useful, made for your convenient use, and last for years. The free labeling makes them great as a gift too, allowing you to organize your home and kitchen now.

The body part of the jars is made with heavy-duty glass, a food-grade material that is non-toxic and extremely safe. The caps are made of PE, which is transparent to see and check, lead-free, BPA-free, food safe grade, natural, and recyclable, perfectly satisfying your daily lifestyle demands. You can use these jars again and again, and their non-reactive nature ensures pure taste.

In terms of safety and cleaning, the lead-free glass and BPA-free lids make these jars dishwasher and microwave safe. The glass body can also be put into the oven and freezer, making them safe and healthy for use in any kitchen.

Overall, the Glass Jars,Encheng 7 oz Glass Yogurt Jars With Lids(PE),Replacement Glass Pudding Jars With Plastic Tops,Clear Glass Yogurt Container With Twine n Tag For Milk,Jams,Jelly,Mousse,Dishwaresafe 30 Pack is an excellent investment that you can use for years to come, providing you with a safe, stylish, and convenient way to store your food.

3. 6 Reusable 100% Cotton Nut Milk Bags For Straining Almond/oat Milk, Cold Brew Coffee, Yogurt And Cheese Making

This set of 6 nut milk bags is made of 100% unbleached cotton cheesecloth that is ultra-fine meshed to filter small particles and provide a smooth and silky result. The bags are reinforced with triple stitching for durability and come in a perfect size of 12"x12" with a clever U bottom design that allows for easy squeezing and prevents pulp from getting stuck in corners. The edges are also triple stitched to prevent tearing and ripping, while the outward seam design makes cleaning easier and less messy than traditional cheesecloth.

These nut milk bags are washable, reusable, and odor-free, making them a sustainable and healthy choice for anyone who loves to live healthily. They are also versatile and can be used for a range of applications, including making homemade nut, almond, or oat milk, yogurt, cheese, vegetable or fruit juices, cold brew coffee, beer home brewing, tea, and even bone broth, soup, or spice straining. They can also be used as sprouting bags for those who enjoy growing their own sprouts.

The corner of the bag is round, facilitating the quick passage of liquid through the bag and making it easy to clean. The drawstring design also makes straining easy and mess-free. This set of nut milk bags makes an excellent gift for anyone who loves to live healthily or enjoy making their own food items, and they come with a quality after-sales service guarantee from the manufacturer. If you experience any issues with the product, the friendly customer service team will do their best to solve the problem within 24 hours.

In summary, these 6 PCS 12"x12" Nut Milk Bags are made of natural cotton, designed for perfect sizing and shape, and are washable and reusable. They are perfect for a range of applications, including making homemade nut, oat, or almond milk, yogurt, cheese, vegetable or fruit juices, cold brew coffee, tea, beer home brewing, bone broth, soup, or spice straining, and even sprouting. They are easy to clean and come with a quality after-sales service guarantee to ensure customer satisfaction.

4. Vegapunk 20oz Nut Milk Maker – Smart Automatic Dairy-Free Soy/oat/coconut Milk Maker With Filter Bag For Vegan Almond Milk.

Introducing the VEGAPUNK Nut Milk Maker Machine 20oz, the ultimate dairy-free solution for plant-based milk lovers. This smart automatic machine offers a range of temperature settings, including Soy Milk, Room Temp, Warm, and Hot Milk, making it suitable for a variety of milk types such as soybean, oat, coconut, and almond.

With a 20oz capacity, this milk maker provides more than enough milk for your entire family. The six-bladed, high-speed, and low-noise blending technology ensures that you get the freshest milk in just 3-24 minutes, without the need for soaking.

The VEGAPUNK Nut Milk Maker Machine also comes with a delay time of up to 18 hours, allowing you to set it up the night before and wake up to freshly-made milk in the morning. Additionally, it features settings such as Boil Water and Keep Warm, making it a versatile kitchen appliance that can be used for a variety of purposes.

The machine is also incredibly easy to clean, thanks to its self-clean function. You no longer have to worry about the hassle of washing and scrubbing, as the VEGAPUNK Nut Milk Maker Machine does the job for you.

This almond milk maker machine is perfect for those who are looking to lead a healthier life and save money on store-bought almond milk. It works in the US, Canada, and other countries on 110v, making it a versatile machine that can be used both at home and during travel.

Measuring only 4.7"D x 6.3"W x 9.4"H, this small-sized machine is perfect for those with limited kitchen space. The VEGAPUNK Nut Milk Maker Machine is the perfect solution for vegan and dairy-free households, providing fresh and healthy milk in just a matter of minutes.

5. Mueller Yogurt Maker With 8 Glass Jars/lids And One Touch Display For Greek Yogurt – Perfect For Baby, Kids, And Parfaits With Organic, Sweetened, Flavored, Plain, Or Sugar Free Options.

The Mueller Yogurt Maker is a specialty kitchen appliance that allows you to make delicious homemade yogurt in the comfort of your own home. This innovative product comes equipped with eight 6 oz reusable glass jars, perfect for trying out different combinations and flavors. The yogurt maker is perfect for the entire family as it provides a budget-friendly option to gourmet yogurt while being nutrient-packed.

One of the key advantages of making your own yogurt is that you can control the ingredients used. This yogurt machine allows you to create yogurt with higher doses of probiotics, minimal additives, preservatives, and artificial flavors compared to commercial yogurts. The Mueller Yogurt Maker is designed to make better-quality regular or Greek yogurt, providing individual portions or larger batches up to 48 oz.

The Mueller Yogurt Maker is fully automatic and operates at the touch of a button, making it extremely easy to use. The electric yogurt maker takes approximately 8-12 hours to make yogurt, depending on the type of milk used. The time can be adjusted based on your personal texture preference. The yogurt maker can be turned off at any time, allowing you to have complete control of the process.

This yogurt machine is made of high-quality, food-grade materials. The stainless steel housing provides a clean, streamlined look, while the transparent cover and glass jars allow you to monitor the yogurt-making process. The heating base and fermenting pot ensure constant and equal heat transmission, ensuring that the activation of your yogurt is optimally maintained.

At Mueller, quality is of utmost importance. The yogurt maker is designed to make your life easier, and the company prides itself on offering unparalleled 24/7 live telephone customer support to assist you with anything you need. If you're looking for a yogurt maker that provides a healthy, cost-effective way to make delicious homemade yogurt, the Mueller Yogurt Maker is the perfect choice.

Best Milk For Making Yogurt FAQs

Can I use plant-based milk alternatives for making yogurt?

Yes, plant-based milk alternatives can be used for making yogurt. The process of making yogurt involves introducing bacteria to milk, which convert the lactose into lactic acid. This process can be applied to any type of milk, including plant-based alternatives like soy, almond, coconut, and cashew.

However, it is important to note that the texture and taste of plant-based yogurts may differ from traditional dairy-based yogurts. Some plant-based milks may not thicken as well as dairy milk, so additional thickeners may need to be added. Also, some plant-based yogurts may have a slightly different taste due to the different flavor profiles of the milk alternatives.

Overall, making yogurt with plant-based milk alternatives is possible, but may require some experimentation and adjustments to achieve the desired texture and taste.

Does the quality of the milk affect the taste of the yogurt?

Yes, the quality of the milk used in making yogurt can affect its taste. Yogurt is made by fermenting milk with live bacteria cultures, and the quality of the milk can affect the growth and activity of these cultures. Milk from cows that have been treated with antibiotics or hormones can affect the bacterial cultures and lead to off-flavors in the yogurt. In addition, the fat content of the milk can affect the texture and richness of the yogurt. Higher fat content can lead to a creamier texture and richer flavor. The freshness of the milk can also affect the taste of the yogurt, as older milk can have a stale or sour taste that can carry over into the finished product. Therefore, using high-quality, fresh milk is important for producing yogurt with a consistent and desirable taste.

Should I use whole milk or skim milk for making yogurt?

The type of milk you use for making yogurt depends on your personal preference and dietary needs. Whole milk contains more fat, which can result in a creamier and richer yogurt with a higher calorie content. On the other hand, skim milk contains less fat and results in a lighter and lower calorie yogurt.

From a professional standpoint, whole milk is often preferred in yogurt making as it provides a richer texture and flavor. The fat content also helps to create a more stable yogurt that is less likely to separate. However, if you are looking for a healthier option or have dietary restrictions, skim milk can also be used.

Ultimately, it's up to you to decide which type of milk you want to use based on your personal preferences and dietary needs. Regardless of which type you choose, using high-quality milk is important for achieving the best results in yogurt making.

What are the benefits of using raw milk for making yogurt?

Raw milk is an excellent choice for making yogurt due to its nutritional value and superior taste. When making yogurt from raw milk, the beneficial bacteria in the milk are preserved, which can aid digestion and boost the immune system. Raw milk also contains enzymes that can help break down lactose, making it more easily digestible for those who are lactose intolerant. Additionally, the creaminess and richness of raw milk can result in a more flavorful and luxurious yogurt product. However, it is important to note that raw milk carries a higher risk of contamination with harmful bacteria, so it is crucial to use proper sanitation and handling techniques when working with raw milk. Overall, using raw milk for making yogurt can result in a healthier and more delicious product, but caution should be taken to ensure safety.

What type of milk is best for making yogurt?

When it comes to making yogurt, the type of milk used is crucial in determining the final product's taste, texture, and nutritional value. Generally, whole milk is the best option for making yogurt as it provides a creamier texture and richer flavor. However, low-fat and skim milk can also be used, but they may result in a thinner and less creamy yogurt.

Another crucial factor to consider when choosing milk for yogurt making is the pasteurization process. Ultra-pasteurized milk can lead to a weaker yogurt culture, which affects the final product's thickness and tang. Therefore, it's best to use pasteurized milk that hasn't been ultra-pasteurized for making yogurt.

Furthermore, non-dairy milk alternatives like soy, almond, or coconut milk can also be used to make yogurt. However, these may require additional thickeners and stabilizers to achieve the desired consistency. In conclusion, whole pasteurized milk is the best option for making yogurt, but other milk alternatives can also be used with the right techniques and additives.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment