Best Lure For Cutthroat Trout (2025 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

If you’re looking for the best lure for cutthroat trout, then you’ve come to the right place. These beautiful and elusive fish can be found in rivers and streams throughout North America and are prized for their tasty flesh and sporting challenge. However, choosing the right lure can make all the difference in your success rate!

Before buying any product, readers need to consider a few key factors. Firstly, the size and color of the lure. Cutthroat trout are known to favor smaller, more natural-looking lures that match the color of their prey. Secondly, the type of water you’ll be fishing in. Are you targeting cutthroats in a fast-moving river or a slow-moving stream? This will determine the weight and shape of your lure. Lastly, personal preference also plays a role. Some anglers swear by spinners while others prefer spoons or jigs.

So, what is the best lure for cutthroat trout? That’s a tough question to answer, as it depends on many factors. But, we’ve got some questions for you to consider which may help narrow down your options. Have you tried fishing with a textured lure that mimics the movement of natural prey? How about a brightly colored spoon that is sure to get the fish's attention? Which lure has provided you the most success in the past? The best lure is ultimately the one that works for you – so keep trying until you find your perfect match!

10 Best Lure For Cutthroat Trout

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
This product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts who are looking for high-quality, handcrafted spoon lures for catching trophy trout.
2
Ideal for catching various types of freshwater fish such as trout, pike, bass, crappie, and walleye using effective spoons lures.
3
The product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts who want to catch pike, trout, salmon, bass and other fish in saltwater or freshwater.
4
The product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts who want a variety of spinnerbaits and tackle boxes to catch bass, trout, and salmon.
5
This product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts of all levels, with a diverse selection of hooks, bodies, and floats.
6
The product is ideal for catching bass, trout, salmon, and pike in both freshwater and saltwater environments.
7
This product is ideal for fishing in small streams and lakes, catching all species with its 20 crawdad bodies and 8 long shank hooks.
8
The product is ideal for fishing various species including bass, trout, walleyes, pike and more with bright painted kastmaster lures.
9
Ideal for catching various types of fish with split tail grub bodies and longer shad dart hook.
10
Ideal for fishing bass, trout, and walleye with a slow-sinking crankbait.
This product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts who are looking for high-quality, handcrafted spoon lures for catching trophy trout.
Ideal for catching various types of freshwater fish such as trout, pike, bass, crappie, and walleye using effective spoons lures.
The product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts who want to catch pike, trout, salmon, bass and other fish in saltwater or freshwater.
The product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts who want a variety of spinnerbaits and tackle boxes to catch bass, trout, and salmon.
This product is ideal for fishing enthusiasts of all levels, with a diverse selection of hooks, bodies, and floats.
The product is ideal for catching bass, trout, salmon, and pike in both freshwater and saltwater environments.
This product is ideal for fishing in small streams and lakes, catching all species with its 20 crawdad bodies and 8 long shank hooks.
The product is ideal for fishing various species including bass, trout, walleyes, pike and more with bright painted kastmaster lures.
Ideal for catching various types of fish with split tail grub bodies and longer shad dart hook.
Ideal for fishing bass, trout, and walleye with a slow-sinking crankbait.

1. Handcrafted Trophy Trout Spoony Pack

The Hookum spoon lure is a must-have for any serious angler. Its offset swivel rig on the underside creates an outstanding swimming action that is unmatched by any other lure. The Hookum produces a variety of erratic darting actions that predatory fish can't resist. By adjusting the leader length and trolling speed, anglers can achieve a range of wounded fish actions.

This iconic lure has a proven track record in the Pacific Northwest and has been fished by anglers worldwide for every predatory fish species. Developed by Boris Peetz in the early 1930s, the Hookum is still handcrafted to the highest standards by PEETZ and has been in production for over eight decades. The Hookum comes in a wide range of ultraviolet, iridescent, and/or glow mylars, making it a versatile addition to any angler's arsenal.

The Hookum is built to last, with a body made of high-gauge, hand-polished brass that is nickel plated for the brightest finish possible. The swivel rig features a nickel plated barrel swivel and a stainless steel 60lb split ring. This lure can withstand years of heavy use and endure battles with countless fish.

In terms of specifications, the Hookum measures 3 inches (76mm) in length, 0.75 inches (19mm) in width, and weighs 0.59 oz (17 grams). It is a versatile and durable lure that is a must-have for any angler looking to up their game.

For Spanish-speaking customers, the product's characteristics can be found in the description below. Invest in the Hookum spoon lure today and experience the outstanding swimming action and proven fish-attracting power that has made it an angling staple for over 80 years.

2. Trout/pike/bass Spoon Lures – 5pc Set

The fishing spoons in this product are designed to impress with their aerodynamic design and streamlined shape, which allows for impressive casting distances and a quicker retrieve. Made with precision-machined materials, these spoons are built to last and retain their luster, without bending, breaking, or corroding. They can be used for trolling, cast spinning, and jigging, making them extremely versatile and easy to use.

These fishing spoons also produce a life-like swimming action that entices fish to strike. With a special balance that produces wild action without line twist, the spoons can be twitched and jerked during retrieval, which greatly improves the action and attracts fish. The slow retrieve with a wide wobble mesmerizes trout, walleye, and pike, while the fast retrieve produces erratic movements, flash, and vibration.

The surfaces of these fishing spoons are buffed to an almost mirror-like shine, making them highly visible and UV enhanced, with optical brighteners that create brilliant flash to attract a variety of fish, including trout, bluegill, pike, panfish, sunfish, rock bass, large mouth bass, yellow bass, striper, musky, striped bass, and even crappie.

These spoons come in three different colors, each with four sizes to choose from. A single box includes five pieces in five different colors, making them perfect for any fishing trip. The shape of the hook ensures better penetration and increases the hook-ups, making them even more effective at catching fish.

3. Metallic Kit: 30 Colorful Fishing Spoons

The Metal Spoon Lures Assortment is a great choice for any fishing enthusiast. Each spoon lure in this kit features a different pattern, carefully selected from thousands of spinners and spoons. With a wide range of color options and great actions, these lures are sure to bring a surprise to any fishing trip.

These little fishing spoons boast a lifelike movement that fish can't resist. The vivid reflective effect and vibrant colors create a realistic swimming posture, attracting fish to attack. The spoon lures sway back and forth, toss up and down, mimicking the movement of real prey.

Made of high-quality material, these metal fishing lures are rust-resistant and durable. Equipped with a sharp and strong treble hook, they have great penetration power and make it difficult for the fish to escape. These metal spoon lures are suitable for both freshwater and saltwater fishing, making them ideal for catching a variety of species like Largemouth Bass, Trout, Pike, Catfish, Walleye, Bluegill, Steal Head, and more.

The kit includes 30 assorted metal spoons fishing lures, each stored in a plastic tackle box for easy organization. The lures range in length from 2.56 to 3.35 inches and weigh between 4.5 and 9.5 grams. These classic spoons are a great addition to any tackle box and make for a nice gift for family and friends.

4. 10pcs Fishing Lure Spinnerbait, Bass Trout Salmon Hard Metal Spinner Baits Kit With Tackle Boxes

The Fishing Lures Set with Tackle Box is a must-have for any fishing enthusiast. This set includes 10 pieces of lures, out of which 5 of them are equipped with rooster tails. The heavy weighted body of these lures, ranging from 3g to 7g, makes them ideal for catching a wide variety of fishes.

Each lure comes with sharp treble hooks and brightly colored strike-attractor sleeves to ensure that the fish gets firmly hooked once they bite these baits. The hooks are designed to be effective and safe, and will prevent the fish from getting away.

The Fishing Lures Set is designed to be easy to store and carry. With its compact and durable tackle box, it is easy to organize and transport your fishing gear. The set is lightweight and can be easily carried in a backpack or tackle bag, making it perfect for fishing trips.

The high-quality blades of the lures provide continuous flash and vibration, which makes them irresistible to fish. The blades are designed to lure fish to prey and improve the aggressiveness of fish catching. These lures are deadly for bass, trout, leukoplakia, northern pike fish, and salmon. They are specifically designed for fishermen, making it a perfect gift for occasions like Christmas, Thanksgiving, or Father's Day.

5. Mighty Trout Kit: 142 Pieces To Catch!

The fishing enthusiasts can now enjoy a successful fishing experience with the Trout Magnet Fishing Kit, which is a complete fishing system designed to catch various species of fish. This fishing accessory is ideal for trout fishing and can also be used to catch panfish, creek chub, largemouth and smallmouth bass, crappie, and many more.

The Trout Magnet Fishing Kit includes 20 fishing hooks, 120 colorful bodies, and 2 floats, which are all essential components needed to complete a non-fail fishing system for your fishing rod. With this kit, fishing enthusiasts will have everything they need to catch their desired fish.

Unlike other jigs, the Trout Magnet hook and body fall horizontally in the water instead of head weight. This unique feature makes it more attractive to fish and increases the chances of catching them. This fishing accessory is the perfect addition to your fishing tackle box.

The double-sided Trout Magnet box is the perfect size for your pocket or vest. It comes with an excellent selection of jig body-colors, jig head selections, and E-Z trout floats, making it a versatile and convenient tool to carry around. With the Trout Magnet Fishing Kit, your fishing equipment will be the envy of your friends.

Made in the USA, the Trout Magnet Fishing Kit is crafted with high-grade plastic and bright colors that will not tear like other plastics on the market. As such, it is a durable and reliable fishing accessory that guarantees success.

6. Rooster Tail Spinnerbaits: Catch More Fish.

Introducing the VMSIXVM Deadly Spinner-Fly Combo Kit, a must-have for any fishing enthusiast. This comprehensive kit includes twelve spinner baits with six different colors, each measuring 3.5" and weighing 3/8 oz. These bass and trout lures are guaranteed to be the most effective fishing lures you will ever use!

The VMSIXVM fishing spinner combines the hottest flies on the market with the irresistible movement of a spinner. Each spinnerbait is hand-crafted and features a quality fly pattern hand-tied to the sharpest steel hook. These rooster tails also have a double hook as a trail hook to reduce snag, provoking predator fish to strike. The solid brass componentry, brass spinner blade, polished brass bead, and brass spinner blade clevis are all on a stainless steel shaft, ensuring durability and longevity.

The hand-tied fly represents a favorite food source and causes an instinctive strike from fish. The polished spinner blade creates a flash that grabs the trout's attention. The sharpest double hook works in tandem with the main hook to yield a firmly hooked fish.

The VMSIXVM fly fishing flies kit features proven fly hook patterns to match natural food sources, making them versatile and effective for a wide range of fishing situations. These rooster tails are especially effective for all species of trout, including rainbow trout and lake trout, and also fatally attractive to bass, pike, crappie, catfish, bluegill, and sunfish. They can be used to catch more fish over a wider variety of seasonal, water, and atmospheric conditions than any other lures on the market!

In short, if you want to take your fishing game to a new level, you need the VMSIXVM Deadly Spinner-Fly Combo. These baits are easy to use, versatile, and very effective at enticing, hooking, and landing a variety of fish. Try them today and see the results for yourself!

The Deadly Spinner-Fly Combo Kit is only manufactured and sold by VMSIXVM. The company takes responsibility for its product quality and customer service, offering a 100% money-back guarantee. If you are not satisfied with the fishing lures, feel free to contact the friendly and reliable customer service team anytime. The company provides three months of after-sales service, and the team will respond to any inquiries within 12 hours.

7. Trout Magnet Kit: Catch Any Species With Ease.

Introducing the small fishing artificial bait crawdad that has been designed to mimic the size of a small crawfish. Unlike other larger versions of crawdads, this bait is highly effective in catching fish that are usually not attracted to larger baits. Its unique shad dart head allows for a slow fall and a distinctive action that makes it more appealing to a variety of fish, making it an ideal choice for many other fish species besides trout.

This versatile bait is perfect for use in small streams and lakes, and can catch everything from Bluegill to Largemouth Bass, making it an essential fishing accessory for your tackle box. The Trout Slayer colors included in this kit are top-notch and come in a small box that can easily fit in your pocket or vest, making it convenient to carry around.

Manufactured in the USA using high-grade plastic and bright colors that do not tear like other plastics on the market, this Trout Fishing Kit is a great gift idea for fishing enthusiasts. You can impress your friends with your outstanding fishing equipment that is designed to make fishing a more enjoyable experience.

8. Painted Kastmaster Kit: Catch More Fish!

The ACME KASTMASTER 6 PACK PAINTED PATTERNS FISHING LURES KIT is a must-have for any angler looking to reel in some serious catches. This kit includes six top-performing Kastmaster fishing lures in three different painted color patterns, perfect for catching Bass, Trout, Walleyes, Pike and other fish species.

The kit includes three 1/8 oz Kastmaster fishing lures, each in a different bite-triggering pattern. The Brook Trout color Kastmaster 1/8 oz, Cutthroat color Kastmaster 1/8 oz and Metallic Perch color Kastmaster 1/8 oz offer a variety of options for the angler. These 1/8 oz size Kastmaster spoon fishing lures are lightweight and easy to handle, making them perfect for beginners and experienced anglers alike.

The kit also includes three 1/4 oz Kastmaster fishing lures, each in a different painted pattern. The Brook Trout color Kastmaster 1/4 oz, Cutthroat color Kastmaster 1/4 oz and Metallic Perch color Kastmaster 1/4 oz offer a variety of options for the angler who wants to catch bigger fish. These 1/4 oz size Kastmaster spoon fishing lures are heavier and more suitable for experienced anglers who want to cast further.

All of the Kastmaster fishing lures in this kit are made with high-quality materials to ensure durability and longevity. The bright painted color patterns are eye-catching and designed to attract fish from a distance. The Kastmaster design ensures that the lures imitate the movements of a real fish, making them more likely to entice a bite.

9. Panfish Magnet Kit: Catch More Fish!

The Panfish Magnet Fishing Lures are a versatile and reliable option for anglers looking to catch a variety of fish species. These lures have been proven to out-fish other freshwater stream lures when it comes to panfish, trout, creek chub, largemouth and smallmouth bass, and crappie.

One of the standout features of the Panfish Magnet is its unique hook design. The lure body is the same as the popular Trout Magnet, but with a longer shad dart hook, specifically designed for panfish. This design allows the lure to fall horizontally in the water, rather than head weight as with most other jigs on the market.

The single-sided Panfish Magnet box is the perfect size for pocket or vest storage. It comes equipped with a variety of panfish color grub bodies and hooks, making it a convenient addition to any angler's tackle box.

The Panfish Magnet Fishing Lures are proudly made in the USA with high-grade plastic and vibrant colors that won't tear like some other plastics on the market. These lures are a great gift idea for fellow fishing enthusiasts or family members who enjoy spending time on the water.

10. Rebel Lures Tracdown Minnow Fish Catcher, Cutthroat Trout, 2 1/2 In, 1/8 Oz

The fishing enthusiasts out there would be delighted with the slow-sinking action technique used in this fishing lure. It allows for a smooth and natural movement in the water, making it irresistible to trout, bass, and other gamefish.

The detailed color patterns on this lure are sure to catch the attention of any fish in the water. The variety of colors available cater to different fishing conditions, providing options for any kind of water or light situation.

This fishing lure is particularly effective in clear-running streams and rivers. Its design allows for it to blend in seamlessly with the natural environment while attracting fish at the same time.

The lure is 2 1/2 inches long and weighs 1/8 ounces, with a #10 barbless hook. This makes it the perfect size and weight for any fishing trip, and the barbless hook ensures easy and safe removal from any fish caught.

Whether you're a seasoned fisherman or just starting, this fishing lure is a must-have in your fishing gear. It's perfect for boating and can be used in various fishing conditions, providing you with an enjoyable and successful fishing experience.

Best Lure For Cutthroat Trout FAQs

Are there specific brands of lures that work better for catching cutthroat trout?

There are several brands of lures that are known to work well for catching cutthroat trout. One of the most popular and effective brands is Panther Martin. Their classic spinners are particularly effective for cutthroat trout, as they mimic the natural prey that these fish feed on. Other popular brands for catching cutthroat trout include Mepps, Rooster Tail, and Blue Fox.

When choosing lures for cutthroat trout, it's important to consider the color and size of the lure, as well as the type of water you'll be fishing in. For instance, in clear water, natural colors like brown, green, and silver tend to work well, while in murky water, brighter colors like chartreuse or orange may be more effective.

Ultimately, the best way to determine which brands and types of lures work best for catching cutthroat trout is to experiment and try different options until you find what works best in your specific fishing conditions.

How can I choose the best lure for cutthroat trout based on the time of day or season?

Choosing the best lure for cutthroat trout can depend on several factors, including the time of day and season. During the early morning and late afternoon, when the light is low, it's best to use lures that make noise or create vibrations to attract the fish. Spinnerbaits, crankbaits, and surface lures are all great options during these times.

During the middle of the day when the sun is high and bright, it's best to use lures that mimic the natural prey of the cutthroat trout. These can include small jigs, soft plastics, and live bait such as worms or minnows.

In terms of season, during the spring and fall, when the water is cooler, it's best to use lures that imitate baitfish such as spoons or minnow imitators. During the summer when the water is warmer, it's best to use lures that create a commotion such as topwater lures or poppers.

Ultimately, the best way to choose the right lure for cutthroat trout is to experiment with different types and see what works best for the specific body of water and conditions you are fishing in.

How can I modify a lure to make it more effective for catching cutthroat trout?

Cutthroat trout are known to be selective feeders, and they can be quite challenging to catch at times. However, there are a few modifications that you can make to your lure to increase its effectiveness for catching cutthroat trout.

Firstly, you can adjust the size and color of your lure. Cutthroat trout tend to prefer smaller lures that match the color of the insects they are feeding on. So, you might want to use a smaller size lure in natural colors like brown, black, or green.

Secondly, you can add scent to your lure. Cutthroat trout rely heavily on their sense of smell to locate food, so adding scent to your lure can make it more attractive to them. You can use natural scents like garlic, anise, or shrimp oil.

Thirdly, you can modify the action of your lure. Cutthroat trout are known to be attracted to lures that mimic the movements of their natural prey. So, you can experiment with different retrieves and twitches to see what works best.

Lastly, you can try using a different type of lure altogether. Cutthroat trout are known to be partial to dry flies and nymphs, so you might want to try using those instead of traditional lures.

Overall, modifying your lure to suit the preferences of cutthroat trout can take some trial and error, but with a little experimentation, you can increase your chances of catching these elusive fish.

Should I use a floating or sinking lure for cutthroat trout?

When it comes to fishing for cutthroat trout, the choice between using a floating or sinking lure depends on various factors. The first factor to consider is the water depth you are fishing in. If you are fishing in shallow waters, a floating lure will work well as it will stay on the surface and lure the trout to the bait. On the other hand, if you are fishing in deep waters, a sinking lure is an ideal choice as it will reach the depths where the cutthroat trout are likely to be found.

Furthermore, the type of prey the cutthroat trout feed on is another factor to consider. If the trout feed on insects, a floating lure that resembles the insect they feed on will work well. However, if they feed on smaller fish, a sinking lure that resembles a small fish will be more effective.

In conclusion, the choice between using a floating or sinking lure for cutthroat trout depends on the water depth, type of prey, and other factors. It is essential to experiment with both types of lures to determine which one works best for the particular fishing conditions you are facing.

Should I use a spinning or fly fishing lure for cutthroat trout?

When it comes to fishing for cutthroat trout, both spinning and fly fishing lures can be effective. The choice between the two ultimately comes down to personal preference and the specific conditions of the fishing location.

Spinning lures, such as spoons or spinners, are typically easier to use and are a great option for beginners or those fishing in areas with obstacles such as trees or rocks. They are also effective in fast-moving water where the current can carry the lure naturally.

On the other hand, fly fishing lures, such as dry flies or nymphs, require more skill and technique to use effectively. They are often preferred by experienced anglers who enjoy the challenge of matching the hatch and presenting a more natural-looking bait to the fish.

Ultimately, the decision between spinning and fly fishing lures for cutthroat trout should be based on your fishing experience, personal preference, and the specific conditions of the fishing location. It is always a good idea to consult with local fishing experts or guides for advice on what type of lure to use.

What color of lure works best for cutthroat trout in different water conditions?

When it comes to cutthroat trout, choosing the right color of lure can make a significant difference in your fishing success. The best color of lure for cutthroat trout varies depending on the water conditions you are fishing in. In clear water conditions, natural colors such as brown, green, or gray are most effective, as they mimic the natural prey of the fish. In murky or stained water conditions, brighter colors such as chartreuse, orange, or pink tend to work better, as they create more contrast and are easier for the fish to see. Additionally, using lures with a reflective or holographic finish can also be effective in both clear and murky water conditions, as they create a flash that can attract the attention of the fish. Ultimately, the key is to experiment with different colors and finishes until you find what works best in the specific water conditions you are fishing in.

What is the best depth to fish a lure for cutthroat trout?

When it comes to fishing for cutthroat trout, the best depth to fish a lure can vary depending on a few different factors. Firstly, it is important to understand the habits and preferences of the fish in the specific body of water you are fishing in. In general, cutthroat trout tend to feed in the upper water column, so fishing a lure at a shallower depth can often be effective.

However, if the water is particularly warm or the fish are not actively feeding, it may be necessary to fish deeper to reach the trout. A good rule of thumb is to start by fishing the lure at a shallower depth and gradually working your way deeper until you find success.

It is also important to consider the type of lure you are using, as different lures will perform better at different depths. For example, a floating fly may work well at shallower depths, while a sinking lure or bait may be necessary to reach deeper water.

Ultimately, the best depth to fish a lure for cutthroat trout will depend on the specific conditions of the body of water you are fishing in and the preferences of the fish at that time.

What is the best technique to use when fishing with a lure for cutthroat trout?

The best technique to use when fishing with a lure for cutthroat trout is to imitate the prey they feed on, such as small minnows or insects. One effective approach is to cast the lure upstream and allow it to drift naturally downstream, mimicking the motion of real prey in the water. Additionally, using a slow and steady retrieve with occasional pauses can also entice cutthroat trout to strike. It's important to vary the speed and depth of the retrieve to find what works best for the particular fishing spot and conditions. Another useful technique is to add a subtle twitch or jerk to the lure to create a more realistic action. It's also crucial to choose the right size and color of lure to match the natural prey in the area. By experimenting with different techniques and lures, anglers can increase their chances of catching cutthroat trout while enjoying the thrill of the sport.

What is the most effective type of lure for catching cutthroat trout?

When it comes to catching cutthroat trout, the most effective type of lure can vary depending on a few different factors. However, one type of lure that is often successful is a small spinner. Cutthroat trout are known to be attracted to shiny objects, and a spinner can mimic the movement of a small fish or insect in the water. Additionally, using a spinner with a bright or contrasting color can help it stand out and catch the attention of the fish.

Another effective type of lure for cutthroat trout is a fly. This is especially true if you're fishing in a river or stream where fly fishing is popular. Different types of flies can imitate different insects or small fish that cutthroat trout feed on, so it's important to choose a fly that matches the natural food sources in the area.

Ultimately, the most effective type of lure for catching cutthroat trout will depend on the specific conditions of the body of water you're fishing in, as well as the preferences of the fish in that area. It's always a good idea to do some research and talk to local anglers to get a better idea of what lures tend to work best in the area you'll be fishing.

What size of lure should I use when fishing for cutthroat trout?

When selecting the size of lure for cutthroat trout, it's important to consider the water conditions and the type of prey they feed on. In general, smaller sized lures work best for cutthroat trout as they tend to feed on smaller baitfish and insects. A good starting point would be using lures in the 1/8 to 1/4 ounce range. However, if the water is murky or fast-moving, larger lures may be necessary to catch the attention of the fish. It's also important to match the color of the lure to the natural prey in the area. For example, using a brown or green lure that mimics the color of a crayfish can be effective. Ultimately, it's important to experiment with different sizes and colors to see what works best in the particular fishing location.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!