Best Ice Cream Nags Head (2024 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

If you’re looking for the best ice cream in Nags Head, you’ve come to the right place! Nothing beats a scoop or two of delicious, creamy ice cream on a hot summer day. But with so many options available, it can be challenging to decide where to go for the best ice cream experience.

When choosing where to indulge in your sweet treat, there are several factors to consider. First, think about the quality of the ice cream. Is it made with fresh, high-quality ingredients? Next, consider the variety of flavors available. Do they have classic favorites as well as unique, seasonal flavors? Lastly, think about the overall experience. Is the atmosphere inviting and pleasant, making it an enjoyable place to relax and enjoy your ice cream?

Some questions to consider when searching for the best ice cream in Nags Head include: What are the most popular flavors? Are there any signature creations unique to the shop? Do they offer gluten-free or dairy-free options for those with dietary restrictions? And, of course, what are the prices like compared to other ice cream shops in the area?

Whether you’re a local or just visiting, make sure to satisfy your sweet tooth by finding the best ice cream in Nags Head – your taste buds will thank you!

10 Best Ice Cream Nags Head

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
Ideal for making, storing, and serving homemade ice pops in a convenient and disposable way.
2
The product is ideal for DIY making of ice cream supplies as it comes with clear plastic bags and wooden sticks.
3
The product is ideal for holding party favors for girls at an ice cream theme birthday or baby shower.
4
This product is ideal for party favors and gift bags for girls' birthday parties, baby showers, and summer events.
5
The product is ideal for scooping ice cream with ease and comfort thanks to its ergonomic handle design.
6
The product is ideal for making homemade ice cream, frozen yogurt, and freeze pops using disposable plastic molds.
7
The product is ideal for making homemade popsicles, ice cream, yogurt tubes, and healthy snacks for kids or parties.
8
Product is ideal for making homemade ice pops, yogurt, and freeze pops with easy-to-use disposable plastic bags and silicone funnel.
9
The product is ideal for wrapping and sealing food-grade frozen treats, such as ice pops and candy.
10
The product is ideal for making and storing homemade ice pops, yogurt, and freeze pops with the included funnel.
Ideal for making, storing, and serving homemade ice pops in a convenient and disposable way.
The product is ideal for DIY making of ice cream supplies as it comes with clear plastic bags and wooden sticks.
The product is ideal for holding party favors for girls at an ice cream theme birthday or baby shower.
This product is ideal for party favors and gift bags for girls' birthday parties, baby showers, and summer events.
The product is ideal for scooping ice cream with ease and comfort thanks to its ergonomic handle design.
The product is ideal for making homemade ice cream, frozen yogurt, and freeze pops using disposable plastic molds.
The product is ideal for making homemade popsicles, ice cream, yogurt tubes, and healthy snacks for kids or parties.
Product is ideal for making homemade ice pops, yogurt, and freeze pops with easy-to-use disposable plastic bags and silicone funnel.
The product is ideal for wrapping and sealing food-grade frozen treats, such as ice pops and candy.
The product is ideal for making and storing homemade ice pops, yogurt, and freeze pops with the included funnel.

1. Mexican-Style Ice Pop Bags – 200 Pack

This super value pack of popsicle bags comes with 200 flat bags, each measuring 3 inches wide by 12 inches long. These bags allow for the creation of various sizes of popsicles, with a maximum capacity of 12 oz when filled and tied with a simple knot at the top.

Making delicious and healthy homemade popsicles is now easier than ever with these high-quality plastic bags. The bags meet FDA requirements for use in food applications and are made of 100% virgin low density polyethylene. The bottom of each bag is sealed for extra strength, with no slits or side seals to ensure that the contents remain securely inside.

These popsicle bags are ideal for creating snacks with yogurt, fruit, smoothies, and other ingredients that the whole family will love. The bags are easy to use and can be conveniently stored in the freezer until it's time to enjoy the finished product.

As a manufacturer committed to producing premium products, the seller offers a warranty to back up their products. Customers can purchase these popsicle bags risk-free, knowing that if for any reason they are unsatisfied with the product, they can simply contact the seller to return the product for a full refund or replacement.

2. Icy Treat Diy Kit – Plastic Bags & Sticks

The 100-piece ice cream plastic bags and wooden ice lolly sticks set is an excellent choice for those who love making ice cream or experimenting with various flavors and shapes. The set includes 100 pieces of each item, providing you with a large quantity that you can share with your friends and family.

Made from safe materials, the ice cream bags are constructed with plastic, while the ice lolly sticks are made from wood. Both materials are non-toxic and tasteless, ensuring that you can make your delicious treats with ease.

The wooden ice lolly sticks are lightweight and measure approximately 114 x 10 x 2 mm/ 4.49 x 0.39 x 0.08 inches, while the ice cream plastic bags are approximately 21 x 8 cm/ 8.27 x 3.15 inches. The proper size of both items makes it easy for you to use and create your desired treat.

This set is perfect for those who enjoy DIY projects and want to create different flavors and shapes of ice cream, yogurt sticks, fruit and vegetable pops, and candy treats. It’s also great for creating unique and fun party favors that your guests will love.

Surprise your friends and family with this incredible set during the hot summer months. It makes an excellent and interesting gift that will add more fun and cool feeling to their daily lives. With this ice cream plastic bags and wooden ice lolly sticks set, you can enjoy delicious and refreshing treats all summer long.

3. Sweet Treat Party Tote Bags By Wernnsai

Introducing the perfect gift bag for kids’ parties and birthday celebrations, the Ice Cream Bag! This rectangular gift bag features a delicious ice cream design that is sure to leave a lasting impression on the little ones.

Designed and printed by the manufacturer with manual techniques and natural products, these gift bags are perfect for any occasion, including birthdays, baby showers, or any other celebration. The Ice Cream Bag is the perfect finishing touch to your gift.

Crafted from high-quality cardboard, these gift bags are lightweight, sturdy, and completely odor-free. The bags feature a sturdy bottom that is strong enough to hold small gifts, making them the perfect choice for party favor gift bags.

The Ice Cream Bag comes in a convenient size of 4.9” x 3” x 7.9” / 12.36 x 7.64 x 20cm, which is perfect for holding candies, snacks, or any other little objects that you wish to gift.

The manufacturer is committed to providing excellent customer service. If you encounter any unpleasant experiences with the product, please feel free to get in touch with them. They will respond promptly and resolve the issue within 24 hours.

4. Sweet Treat Goodie Bags – 12 Pack

Introducing the Sweet and Delicious Ice Cream Party Bag, a perfect addition to any girl's birthday party! These bags not only look amazing, but they are also environmentally friendly. Made with sturdy Oxford cloth, these bags are thicker and more durable than nylon bags, ensuring that they can be used again and again.

Measuring 10 inches wide by 12 inches high (25 x 30cm), these bags are spacious enough to fit up to three books. They are also incredibly versatile, allowing you to personalize them with your own designs. You can use heat transfer vinyl to add graphics or simply use markers to draw and color on them.

In addition to being cute and customizable, these bags are also washable and reusable. Say goodbye to single-use plastic bags and hello to a more sustainable option! Your guests can take the bags home and use them for their own shopping or storage needs.

5. Spring Chef Ice Cream Scoop With Comfortable Handle, Black

Introducing the last ice cream scoop you'll ever need. This is a genuine heavy-duty tool that is built to last. Unlike other scoops with mechanical gimmicks or moving parts that can break, this scoop is sturdy and reliable. Plus, it's dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

This scoop is not just for ice cream. It's great for other creative kitchen uses such as scooping out seeds from melons or filling peppers with stuffing. It even works amazingly well for gelato and custard. And, it comes with a lifetime warranty to guarantee its quality.

Thanks to its innovative design, this scoop creates perfect spheres of ice cream that curl onto themselves, resulting in beautiful and well-proportioned scoops. It effortlessly cuts through even the hardest frozen desserts, making it the best combination of a scoop and spade. The curved area of the scoop creates brilliant curls, while the thin edges help dig out ice cream from the corners of the container.

Say goodbye to struggling with a bad scoop. This scoop plows through ice cream like it's butter, gliding smoothly and easily through hard-packed frozen sweets. It will seem like ice cream flows right into the scoop and drops into your bowl or cone with little to no effort.

The handle is comfortable to hold and easy to grip, with a notch to lift container lids that will keep your hands happy. Unlike scoops with a metal handle that can freeze your hand, this scoop has a simple yet ergonomic design that is easy to clean.

Life is too short to struggle with a bad scoop. With its pleasant weight, ability to reach hard-to-reach parts of a carton, and excellent handling of hard ice cream, this is the one for you. It will make you known for your perfect scooping abilities and elevate your dessert game.

6. Freeze Fun: Disposable Ice Lolly Bags

This set of 280 ice popsicle bags provides ample quantity for daily use and sharing with family and friends. Enjoy the fun of DIY snacks with these convenient and practical bags. The completely sealed bottom allows for easy filling with juice, and a simple knot seals the bag for freezing. These disposable ice pop mold bags are versatile and suitable for making a variety of treats, including handmade popsicles, candy, sugar, yogurt, fruit juice, fruit smoothies, and vegetable popsicles.

Made with reliable and safe PE plastic material, these bags have a thickness of 5 filaments, ensuring durability and peace of mind when using for food. Each bag measures approximately 5 x 30 cm/ 1.97 x 11.81 inches (LW), making them lightweight and portable for travel, picnics, and other outdoor activities. With these ice popsicle bags, you can enjoy a cool summer and create many delicious and appetizing snacks.

7. Zip 'n' Sip Popsicle Party Pack

Looking for a way to make healthy homemade popsicles without the mess? Look no further than these popsicle bags! Made from safe materials, these bags can hold thick or liquid form fluids and can be zip sealed for your convenience. With 150 bags per package, you'll have plenty to use for camping, picnics, snacks, kids parties, boating, and trips. The bags measure 2.36 inches wide by 8.66 inches long to the top and come with a green funnel to make pouring a breeze.

To use, simply fill the bags with your desired ingredients, seal them up, and place them in a cup, jar, or something that will hold them upright in the freezer. After a few hours, your cool and refreshing popsicles will be ready to enjoy! Plus, with the ability to customize your popsicles with any ingredients you want, you can create healthy and delicious treats without the added cost of store-bought frozen snacks.

At this company, customer satisfaction is a top priority. If you have any issues with your purchase, please don't hesitate to reach out for assistance. With these popsicle bags, you can enjoy mess-free, healthy homemade popsicles anytime, anywhere.

8. Freeze & Squeeze: 240 Disposable Ice Pop Bags

Looking for a convenient and easy way to make your own ice lollies and snacks? Look no further than this package of 240 ice lolly bags and a silicone funnel!

With an abundant quantity of bags included, you'll have enough to support your long-term needs. And with the included funnel, you can easily pour juice or water into the bags without any mess or fuss.

Once you've filled the bags with your favorite ingredients, simply tie off the opening and freeze for a delicious and refreshing homemade treat. These bags are perfect for making all kinds of snacks, including ice lollies, candy, sugar, yogurt, fruit juice, fruit smoothies, vegetable ice lollies, and more.

Made from high-quality PE plastic material, these ice candy bags are safe for food and won't break or burst easily. And the silicone funnel is non-toxic and durable, so you can use it for multiple batches of snacks.

Be sure to check the dimensions of the bags and funnel before you buy. The plastic mold bag measures approximately 7 x 30 cm/ 3 x 12 inches in length and width, while the funnel is approximately 7.5 x 7.5 cm/ 3 x 3 inches in diameter and height. And because they're lightweight and portable, you can easily take them with you when traveling, going for a picnic, or attending outdoor activities.

In short, this package of ice lolly bags and funnel is the perfect way to enjoy homemade snacks all summer long. With its safe and reliable material, convenient dimensions, and easy-to-use design, you'll be making delicious treats in no time!

9. Hot Seal Ice Pop Bags (200pcs, Clear)

The popsicle storage bags are a must-have for any household that loves to indulge in frozen treats. Made of high quality plastic, these bags are not only durable but also environmentally friendly. The material used is safe for food storage and ensures that your treats remain fresh for longer periods of time.

One of the best features of these bags is their easy sealing mechanism. You can use a hot sealing machine or twist ties to seal the bags. Alternatively, you can also leave them open like in the product photos. The jagged edges on both sides of the bags make it easy to open the bags and access your delicious treats.

These bags are perfect for storing freeze popsicles, candy, cookies, and other treats. They keep your treats fresh for longer, preventing wastage and saving you money. Also, using these bags to store your treats helps keep your fridge clean and organized.

10. Frozen Fun Pack: 150 Disposable Popsicle Bags!

The ice pop season is here! And to help you create the perfect homemade frozen snacks, these popsicle bags have been designed to make the process easier and more convenient. Made from high-quality plastic material, the popsicle bags are sturdy and airtight, ensuring that your homemade popsicles remain fresh and delicious for longer periods.

Each package contains 150 popsicle bags that measure 2.36 inches wide by 10.23 inches long, providing you with the flexibility to create different sizes of popsicles, ranging from 2oz (25% filled) to 6oz (75% filled). The bottom of the bags is sealed, making it easy to pour your preferred filler mixture without worrying about leaks. Once filled, seal the top of the bag with a simple knot, and your popsicles are ready for freezing.

These ice pop bags are versatile, making them perfect for making a variety of frozen treats, including ice candy, yogurt sticks, fruit smoothies, vegetable pops, and more. Whether you're at home, on a picnic, or at a party, you can enjoy your homemade snacks anywhere you go.

The popsicle bags are reusable and easy to clean. Simply clean and dry them after use, and they are ready to use again. Plus, they are transparent, allowing you to see the contents inside, making them perfect for showcasing your creative and colorful popsicle creations.

The manufacturer is committed to providing you with the best quality products and excellent customer service. If you encounter any issues with the product, please don't hesitate to contact the customer support team for assistance.

Get your hands on these popsicle bags today and start creating the most delicious and healthy frozen treats for you and your loved ones!

Best Ice Cream Nags Head FAQs

Are there any local ice cream shops in Nags Head that I should try?

Yes, there are several local ice cream shops in Nags Head that are worth checking out. One popular spot is Booty Treats, which offers a variety of ice cream flavors and toppings, as well as shakes, smoothies, and other treats. Another great option is Surfin' Spoon, which serves up homemade ice cream in unique flavors like salted caramel and blueberry cheesecake. You might also want to stop by Big Buck's Homemade Ice Cream, which has been a Nags Head favorite for over 25 years. They offer over 50 flavors of ice cream, including seasonal options like pumpkin and eggnog. Overall, there are plenty of delicious ice cream shops to choose from in Nags Head, so be sure to visit a few during your stay!

Can I find any vegan or dairy-free ice cream options in Nags Head?

Yes, there are several options for vegan or dairy-free ice cream in Nags Head. One popular option is Kill Devil's Frozen Custard & Beach Fries, which offers a dairy-free sorbet in addition to their regular frozen custard options. Another option is Surfin' Spoon, which offers a coconut milk-based vegan ice cream that is also gluten-free. They have a variety of flavors to choose from, such as chocolate, strawberry, and mint chip. Additionally, Sweet Frog Premium Frozen Yogurt offers a dairy-free sorbet option that is vegan-friendly. They have a variety of flavors to choose from, such as raspberry, mango, and lemon. Overall, there are several options for those looking for vegan or dairy-free ice cream in Nags Head, so you should be able to find something that suits your tastes.

Do any of the Nags Head ice cream shops offer homemade ice cream?

Yes, several Nags Head ice cream shops offer homemade ice cream. One of the most popular is Kill Devil's Frozen Custard & Beach Fries, which is known for its creamy frozen custard made on-site using locally sourced ingredients. Other options for homemade ice cream in Nags Head include Surfin' Spoon and Booty Treats, both of which make their own small-batch ice cream in-house. At these shops, you can find a variety of unique flavors that you won't find anywhere else, such as cinnamon bun, peanut butter cup, and mint chocolate chip with real mint leaves. Whether you're in the mood for a classic vanilla cone or something a little more adventurous, you're sure to find a deliciously homemade treat at one of Nags Head's many ice cream shops.

What are some of the best places to get ice cream on the Nags Head beach?

Nags Head beach is a beautiful destination on the Outer Banks of North Carolina that is known for its scenic beauty and delicious food options. When it comes to finding the best places to get ice cream on Nags Head beach, there are several options to choose from.

One of the top choices for ice cream on the beach is Fatboyz Ice Cream and Grill. They are known for their generous portions and delicious flavors. They offer a range of classic flavors as well as unique options like banana pudding and key lime pie.

Another popular destination for ice cream is The Spot. They offer homemade ice cream in a variety of flavors like mint chocolate chip, butter pecan, and strawberry. The Spot also has a selection of toppings and cones to add to your ice cream.

Scoops Ice Cream is also a great option for anyone looking for a sweet treat on Nags Head beach. They have a variety of flavors including chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, as well as specialty flavors like black cherry and coconut.

Overall, there are many great places to get ice cream on Nags Head beach. Whether you're looking for classic flavors or unique creations, there's something for everyone to enjoy.

What are the most popular ice cream flavors in Nags Head?

Nags Head, being a beach town, has a variety of ice cream shops that offer unique and delicious flavors to cater to the taste buds of locals and tourists alike. However, some of the most popular ice cream flavors in Nags Head include vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, and cookies and cream. These classic flavors remain a favorite among all age groups and are readily available in most ice cream shops in Nags Head. In addition to these, some shops also offer more unique and exotic flavors such as lavender honey, blueberry cheesecake, and salted caramel. These flavors are perfect for those looking for something different or adventurous in their ice cream experience. Overall, the ice cream shops in Nags Head offer a wide variety of flavors to satisfy any craving.

What are the prices like for ice cream in Nags Head?

The prices for ice cream in Nags Head can vary depending on the location and type of ice cream. Generally, a single scoop of ice cream can range from $3 to $5, while a double scoop can range from $5 to $7. Some locations may have higher prices for specialty flavors or toppings. Additionally, prices may be higher during peak tourist season. However, it is important to note that prices can vary from shop to shop, so it is best to check with each individual location for their specific prices. Overall, the prices for ice cream in Nags Head are similar to those in other beach destinations and are reasonable for a sweet treat on a hot day.

What makes the ice cream in Nags Head so special?

Nags Head is a popular tourist destination located in the Outer Banks of North Carolina. One of the things that make the ice cream in Nags Head so special is its quality. Many of the ice cream shops in Nags Head use fresh, locally sourced ingredients to create their delicious frozen treats. This means that the ice cream is often made with milk and cream from local farms, and the flavors are often inspired by the fruits and flavors of the region.

In addition to the quality of the ingredients, the ice cream shops in Nags Head often have unique and creative flavors that you won't find anywhere else. From salted caramel to key lime pie, the ice cream flavors in Nags Head are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.

Finally, the experience of enjoying ice cream in Nags Head is also special. Many of the ice cream shops are located near the beach, so you can enjoy your treat while taking in the beautiful ocean views. Overall, the combination of quality ingredients, unique flavors, and a beautiful setting make the ice cream in Nags Head a must-try for anyone visiting the area.

Where can I find the best ice cream in Nags Head?

Nags Head is a charming town on the Outer Banks of North Carolina, and there are several places where you can enjoy delicious ice cream. One of the most popular spots is the famous Kill Devil's Frozen Custard & Beach Fries, which has been serving homemade custard and fries since 1980. They offer a wide range of flavors, including vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and mint chocolate chip, among others.

Another great option is Surfin' Spoon, which has a unique concept that allows you to create your own ice cream masterpiece. They offer a variety of flavors and toppings, including fresh fruits, candy, and sauces. Plus, they use organic and locally sourced ingredients whenever possible.

If you're looking for a more classic ice cream experience, you might want to check out Full Moon Cafe & Ice Cream, which has been serving homemade ice cream since 1975. They offer classic flavors like butter pecan, chocolate chip, and cookies and cream, as well as more unique options like coconut pineapple and caramel sea salt.

Overall, Nags Head has plenty of great options for ice cream lovers, so you're sure to find something that suits your taste buds!

Which ice cream shops in Nags Head have the most unique flavors?

Nags Head is a hub of ice cream shops that offer a variety of unique flavors. Among them, the most popular ones are the Surfin' Spoon, The Spot, and Booty Treats. Surfin' Spoon is a locally owned ice cream shop that offers homemade ice cream with fresh ingredients. Their unique flavors include sea salt caramel, peanut butter cup, and blueberry cheesecake. The Spot is another popular ice cream shop that has been serving the area for over 20 years. Their most unique flavors include key lime pie, chocolate coconut, and banana pudding. Booty Treats is also a must-visit spot for ice cream lovers. Their ice cream is made with locally sourced ingredients, and their unique flavors include sweet potato pie, black cherry, and butter pecan. All these ice cream shops use high-quality ingredients and offer a wide range of flavors that are sure to satisfy any ice cream lover's taste buds.

Which Nags Head ice cream shops have the best reviews?

Nags Head is home to several ice cream shops that are well-loved by both locals and tourists. According to customer reviews, some of the best ice cream shops in Nags Head include Scoops Homemade Ice Cream, The Spot, and Booty Treats Ice Cream & Shave Ice.

Scoops Homemade Ice Cream is a family-owned and operated business that offers a wide variety of homemade ice cream flavors, all made with fresh and natural ingredients. Customers rave about the creamy texture and delicious taste of their ice cream, with popular flavors like cookie dough and mint chocolate chip.

The Spot is another popular ice cream shop in Nags Head, known for its fun and beachy atmosphere and extensive menu of ice cream flavors and toppings. Customers can choose from classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate, or opt for more unique options like cotton candy and sea salt caramel.

Finally, Booty Treats Ice Cream & Shave Ice is a must-visit for anyone looking for a refreshing and tasty treat on a hot summer day. Customers love their shave ice and ice cream, with flavors like rainbow and strawberry cheesecake receiving especially high praise.

Overall, Nags Head has no shortage of delicious and highly-rated ice cream shops to choose from, so be sure to stop by one (or all!) of these spots on your next visit to the Outer Banks.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!