If you're looking for a reliable first base mitt, you're in the right place. A great first base mitt is essential for any committed baseball player. But before making a purchase, there are a few factors to take into account to ensure that you're getting the best first base mitt for your needs.
First and foremost, you'll want to consider the quality of the mitt. Is it made from high-quality materials? Will it last through multiple seasons? You'll also want to think about the size and fit of the mitt, as well as any additional features, such as padding or webbing.
It's also crucial to take into account the level of play. A beginner player may not need the same level of quality as a seasoned player. Additionally, players may have different preferences in terms of size and fit, so it's essential to choose a mitt that meets your individual needs.
If you're unsure about what to look for in a first base mitt, consider asking yourself these questions: What is my skill level? How often do I play? What are my individual preferences in terms of size and features?
By taking these factors into account, you can find the best first base mitt for your needs and take your game to the next level.
10 Best First Base Mitt
# | Product Image | Product Name | Product Notes | Check Price |
---|---|---|---|---|
1
|
The product is ideal for baseball players looking for a high-quality and durable glove series in various styles.
|
|
||
2
|
Ideal for fastpitch softball players playing first base who throw left-handed and want a high-quality, durable mitt.
|
|
||
3
|
Ideal for advanced baseball players and those seeking a custom, broken-in feel.
|
|
||
4
|
Ideal for first basemen in baseball due to its 12.75-inch size and design specifically for that position.
|
|
||
5
|
The product is ideal for baseball players who want a durable and comfortable glove for fielding.
|
|
||
6
|
Ideal for baseball players looking for a high-quality and durable glove with excellent grip and comfortable fit.
|
|
||
7
|
The product is ideal for softball players and provides a high-quality, durable glove for improved performance on the field.
|
|
||
8
|
The product is ideal for baseball players playing the position of first baseman.
|
|
||
9
|
The product is ideal for adults who play first base and require a 12 inch glove.
|
|
||
10
|
This product is ideal for people who want a high-quality first base mitt for their baseball games.
|
|
1. Rawlings | R9 Baseball Glove Series | Multiple Styles | Black/gold, 12.5 Inch

This baseball glove is specifically designed for young players aged 8-14 who are looking to enhance their game on the field. The glove is made of soft, durable all-leather material that is ready to use right out of the box.
The glove also features reinforced palm padding and a padded thumb loop that provides excellent coverage and comfort to the player's hand. This impact protection feature is essential for preventing injuries and ensuring the player's full focus on the game.
The glove requires a break-in period of 80% factory and 20% player. This process helps the glove to mold to the player's hand shape and size, offering a custom fit that is comfortable and secure.
This particular glove is designed for right-hand throwers and is to be worn on the left hand. This design ensures maximum efficiency and accuracy during gameplay.
2. Mizuno Fastpitch First Base Mitt – Mvp Prime

The Bio Soft Leather glove is a must-have for serious fastpitch players who demand quality and performance. Made with professional style smooth leather, this glove has the perfect balance of oil and softness which provides an exceptional feel and firm control during gameplay. The glove's durable material ensures longevity and efficient gameplay.
The glove's embroidered logo adds a touch of class and richness to its overall appearance. The logo is outlined and designed with precision to enhance the premium look of the glove. The embroidery is of high quality, making it resistant to wear and tear.
The Bio Soft Leather glove is designed for the fastpitch player and features professional level lace. The same durable lace that is used in professional-level gloves is utilized in this glove, ensuring it lasts through tough gameplay and practices. The glove's lace is strong and sturdy, making it able to withstand the rigors of the game.
One of the key features of the Bio Soft Leather glove is its center pocket designed patterns. The pocket's design is created to naturally center the pocket under the index finger, which allows for the most versatile break-in possible. This feature gives players a customized and comfortable fit that is tailored to their specific needs.
3. Hoh Baseball Glove: R2g & Contour Fit.

The Heart of the Hide from Rawlings is an iconic baseball glove that has stood the test of time. It is the flagship product from Rawlings, a brand that is synonymous with baseball gloves. The glove is made with high-quality steer-hide leather and premium lacing that are engineered to last and impress.
The Heart of the Hide glove is designed to be easy to break-in, with an estimated 25% break-in period. The glove is ready to play right out of the box, with a shock-absorbing palm and a best-in-class wrist lining that provides a comfortable and secure fit. The design is versatile and timeless, making it an ideal choice for players of all ages and levels.
Rawlings is a leader in baseball gear and has been trusted by professionals for many years. By choosing Rawlings gear, players can be confident that they are investing in the best quality and innovation available in the market. The Heart of the Hide glove is a testament to Rawlings' commitment to excellence and is a must-have for any serious baseball player.
4. Marucci Oxbow M Type 38s1 First Base Baseball Mitt – 12.75"

Looking for a reliable and high-performing baseball glove? Look no further than the 12.75" Double Post Web glove! This glove is designed with the first baseman in mind, featuring a deep pocket and a double post web that makes it easy to snag those tough throws.
Crafted from full-grain cowhide leather, this glove is built to last. The supple leather palm lining is soft to the touch and offers added cushioning, making it comfortable to wear for extended periods of time. The smooth microfiber wrist lining is lined with high-density memory foam, which helps to prevent discomfort and fatigue.
One of the standout features of this glove is its professional-grade rawhide laces. These laces are incredibly durable and will hold up to even the toughest games and practices. Whether you're playing in the heat of summer or the cool of fall, this glove will perform at the highest level.
The 12.75" Double Post Web glove is available in both right-hand throw and left-hand throw models, so you can choose the one that best fits your needs. No matter which model you choose, you can rest assured that you're getting a top-quality glove that will help you perform your best on the field.
So why wait? Order your 12.75" Double Post Web glove today and experience the ultimate in comfort, durability, and performance!
5. Shoeless Joe Pro Select Series Fb 13.00" – Ps1300fbtt

The Pro Select PS1300FBTTL baseball glove offers exceptional protection and durability for the serious ballplayer. The glove is lined with top-quality cowhide leather for maximum comfort and long-lasting performance. It features XRD foam padding and an index finger pad to provide extreme impact protection from hard-hit balls.
The dual-color dyed design of the glove adds a touch of style to its functionality. The glove is equipped with durable Pro Select laces that ensure a secure fit and long-lasting performance. The PS1300FBTTL model is specifically designed to fit a size 13" hand.
This high-quality baseball glove is made in Mexico, ensuring superior craftsmanship and attention to detail. Its parameters and specifications make it an ideal choice for players who demand the best from their equipment. Whether you're a seasoned pro or a young athlete just starting out, the Pro Select PS1300FBTTL baseball glove is an excellent choice that will help you perform at your best on the field.
6. Wilson A2000 Baseball Glove Series

Introducing the SuperSkin 12.5" First Base Glove, a game-changer for baseball players who prioritize comfort, control, and durability on the field. This glove boasts a range of features that make it stand out from traditional leather gloves.
One of the most noteworthy features of this glove is its SuperSkin material. Made from microfiber, this material is half the weight of Pro Stock Leather but twice as durable. It's also moisture-resistant, which extends the life of the glove and makes it easier to clean than traditional leather. This means players can focus on the game without worrying about the wear and tear of their equipment.
Another game-changing feature is the Flat Finger Binding. This feature caters to players who prefer to play with a finger outside the glove. It reduces the space between the finger and the back of the glove, providing greater comfort and control in the field. This helps players experience less pain and discomfort during long games.
The Pro Stock Leather used in this glove is known for its rugged durability and unmatched feel. This leather is preferred by professional players for its quality and longevity. With this glove, players can be confident that they have a high-quality product that will last them through multiple seasons.
The Thin Heel Pad design of this glove allows for quicker break-in and better closure. This means players can get comfortable with their glove faster and more efficiently, making it easier for them to focus on their performance on the field.
The DriLex Wrist Lining feature keeps hands dry and comfortable during games. This is especially important for players who sweat during games or who play in hot and humid conditions. With this feature, players can keep their hands dry and comfortable, giving them a competitive edge on the field.
Finally, this glove features bold logos that make it stand out on the field. These logos are not only stylish, but they also help players feel confident and ready to perform at their best.
7. Wilson A2000 Fastpitch Glove Series

The Wilson 2021 A2000 SP1BSS 12.5" Fastpitch Glove – Right Hand Throw, First Base, Grey/White is a top-of-the-line piece of equipment designed to enhance your performance on the field. It boasts a range of features that make it a standout option for any serious player.
One of the standout features of this glove is its Pro Stock Leather construction. This high-quality leather is known for its durability and unique feel, making it the preferred choice of many professional players. With this glove, you can be confident that you're getting a product that's built to last.
In addition to its rugged leather construction, the Wilson A2000 SP1BSS also features SuperSkin technology. This innovative microfiber material is half the weight of traditional leather, yet twice as durable. It's also moisture-resistant, which helps extend the life of the glove and makes it easier to clean.
Another unique feature of this glove is its Flat Finger Binding. This design allows players who prefer to keep a finger outside the glove greater comfort and control in the field. It's a small but important detail that can make a big difference in your performance.
The Wilson A2000 SP1BSS also boasts a thin heel pad design, which allows for quicker break-in and better closure. This feature is especially important for players who want to get the most out of their glove right away.
Finally, the DriLex Wrist Lining is a thoughtful addition that helps keep your hand dry and comfortable during long games or practices. It's a small touch that can make a big difference in your overall comfort and performance.
8. Macgregor Pro 100 1st Base Mitt

The MacGregor 12.5" 1st Base Mitt is a top-quality piece of equipment suitable for use by youth through high school players. It is designed to fit the left hand and is pre-oiled to ensure a short break-in period.
Crafted with precision, this mitt offers a comfortable and secure fit for players at all levels. Its 12.5" size is perfect for first base and provides ample space for catching and securing the ball. The mitt is made with top-quality materials that ensure durability and longevity.
The pre-oiling process makes it easier for players to break in the mitt and start using it right away. It also ensures that the mitt retains its shape and structure over time. The MacGregor 12.5" 1st Base Mitt is a reliable and high-performing tool that will help players improve their skills and excel on the field.
So whether you're a youth player just starting out or a high school athlete looking to take your game to the next level, this mitt is an excellent choice. With its top-quality construction and pre-oiled design, it is sure to become an essential part of any player's gear.
9. Shoeless Joe Adult 12" First Base Glove

Introducing the First Base Traditional youth model, perfect for budding baseball players between the ages of 10-14. This glove is crafted from high-quality soft antique tobacco leather, which gives it a unique vintage feel. The classic open back design and traditional first base webbing make this glove a timeless piece of equipment on the field.
Designed to undergo a professional break-in process, the First Base Traditional glove is individually hand-cut and sewn to ensure it maintains its shape and structure for many seasons. The glove is available in both left-hand throw (item goes on the right hand) and right-hand throw (item goes on the left hand) options, making it suitable for a wide range of players.
With a 12-inch size, this glove is perfectly suited for pre-teen first basemen. Its special aged leather and classic design make it an ideal choice for young players who want to look and feel like pros on the field.
10. Guerrero Rl-35 First Base Mitt 14"

Introducing the exceptional 14" Pattern Modified T-web Baseball Glove, designed to provide superior performance and comfort on the field. This glove is suitable for players of all skill levels who seek outstanding quality and durability.
The Modified T-web design of the glove ensures that it can be used for multiple positions, making it extremely versatile. The closed back of the glove with the added finger slot provides a secure and comfortable fit for the hand, allowing the player to focus on the game without worrying about glove slippage.
The glove also features an adjustable wrist strap, which ensures that the glove is snugly secured to the hand and wrist, preventing any unwanted movement during play. This glove is available in both left and right-hand throw options, with the left-hand throw glove worn on the right hand and the right-hand throw glove worn on the left hand.
With its 14" pattern, this glove is ideal for players who want a larger glove that can accommodate larger balls, making it perfect for outfielders. The glove is made from high-quality materials, which ensures its durability and ability to withstand heavy use.
Best First Base Mitt FAQs
Are there any special features I should look for in a first base mitt?
Yes, there are a few special features that you should look for in a first base mitt.
Firstly, it's important to choose a mitt with a deep pocket, as this will help you secure the ball. A good first base mitt should also have a wide and sturdy webbing to make catching and scooping easier.
Secondly, a mitt with a closed back can provide additional support and protection for your hand, which is important for a position that involves a lot of catching and fielding.
Thirdly, the size of the mitt is also an important factor to consider. A larger mitt can help you catch balls more easily, but it may also be heavier and more difficult to maneuver.
Lastly, it's important to choose a high-quality leather mitt that is durable and will last for multiple seasons. Look for mitts made from high-quality leather that is both flexible and sturdy.
Overall, choosing a first base mitt with these features can help you perform better on the field and make your first base position more comfortable.
Can left-handed players use the same first base mitts as right-handed players?
Yes, left-handed players can use the same first base mitts as right-handed players. However, they need to purchase a first base mitt that is specifically designed for left-handed players. These mitts are designed with a different shape and pocket placement to accommodate the needs of left-handed players. They are also labeled as "left-handed" or "LH" to differentiate them from the traditional right-handed mitts. It is important for left-handed players to use a left-handed mitt to ensure proper fit and functionality. Using a right-handed mitt could result in difficulty catching and fielding the ball, as well as potential injury. Additionally, some leagues may have rules in place requiring players to use the appropriate mitt for their handedness. Therefore, left-handed players should invest in a left-handed first base mitt to ensure optimal performance and compliance with league rules.
How much should I expect to spend on a high-quality first base mitt?
The cost of a high-quality first base mitt can vary depending on the brand, materials used, and level of craftsmanship. Generally, you can expect to spend anywhere from $100 to $300 on a quality first base mitt. Some of the top brands in the market, such as Rawlings, Wilson, and Mizuno, offer a range of options at different price points to fit your budget and needs. It's important to remember that investing in a good quality mitt can make a significant difference in your game, as it can provide better protection, durability, and improved performance. So, it's worth spending a little extra to get a mitt that will last you for years and help you improve your skills.
How often should I replace my first base mitt?
The frequency with which you should replace your first base mitt will depend on a variety of factors, including the quality of the mitt, how often you use it, and how well you take care of it. If you have a high-quality first base mitt and you take good care of it, it could last for several years before needing to be replaced. However, if you play frequently and don't take proper care of your mitt (i.e. not oiling it or storing it properly), it may wear out more quickly and need to be replaced sooner.
As a general rule, it's a good idea to inspect your mitt regularly for signs of wear and tear. If you notice any holes or significant wear in the leather, it's likely time to replace it. Additionally, if you find that the mitt is no longer providing the level of support and protection that you need, it may be time to upgrade to a new one. Ultimately, the best way to determine when to replace your first base mitt is to pay attention to how it feels and performs during games and practices.
What are some common mistakes to avoid when buying a first base mitt?
Buying a first base mitt can be a daunting task, especially if you are a first-time buyer. There are several common mistakes that people make when purchasing a first base mitt that you should avoid.
First, do not buy a mitt that is too big or too small for your hand. A mitt that is too big will be difficult to control and may result in errors, while a mitt that is too small will be uncomfortable to wear and may not provide adequate protection.
Second, avoid buying a mitt that is too stiff. A stiff mitt will take longer to break in and may not provide the flexibility needed to make quick, accurate plays.
Third, do not overlook the importance of the webbing. The webbing should be strong and durable, but also flexible enough to allow you to make quick, accurate catches.
Finally, do not overlook the importance of quality materials and construction. Look for a mitt that is made from high-quality leather or synthetic materials and has solid construction.
In summary, when buying a first base mitt, avoid buying a mitt that is too big or too small, too stiff, has weak webbing, or is made from poor quality materials.
What are the most important factors to consider when choosing a first base mitt?
When choosing a first base mitt, there are several important factors to consider. Firstly, the size of the mitt is crucial. The mitt should be big enough to catch the ball but not so big that it becomes cumbersome. Generally, a first base mitt should be between 12.5 and 13 inches long. Secondly, the webbing on the mitt should be strong and flexible to ensure that it can hold the ball securely. The type of webbing used can vary, but the H-web and the single-post web are both popular choices. Thirdly, the material of the mitt should be considered. Leather is the most common material used for first base mitts as it is durable and can be molded to fit the player's hand. Finally, the brand and price of the mitt should also be considered. While a higher price may indicate better quality, it is important to find a mitt that fits within your budget and meets your specific needs.
What brands make the best first base mitts?
When it comes to selecting a first base mitt, there are several brands that stand out for their quality and durability. Wilson, Rawlings, Easton, and Mizuno are some of the most popular brands that make excellent first base mitts.
Wilson is known for their A2000 and A2K series gloves, which are made from high-quality leather and offer excellent comfort and performance. Rawlings is another popular brand that makes top-notch first base mitts, including the Heart of the Hide and Pro Preferred series.
Easton is a newer brand in the world of baseball gloves, but they have quickly established themselves as a reliable option for players. Their first base mitts are made from premium leather and offer great flexibility and durability.
Finally, Mizuno is another brand that has been around for a long time and is known for producing high-quality baseball gloves. Their Pro Select and Pro Limited series first base mitts are particularly popular among players.
Ultimately, the best first base mitt for you will depend on your personal preferences and playing style. It is worth trying on several different brands and styles to find the one that feels the most comfortable and provides the best performance.
What kind of padding and support should a good first base mitt have?
A good first base mitt should have adequate padding and support to protect the player's hand and wrist from injury. The padding should be thick enough to absorb impact from hard throws and catches, but not so thick that it interferes with the player's ability to grip the ball. The mitt should also have a sturdy webbing that provides support for the fingers and helps to maintain the mitt's shape.
Some first base mitts also feature additional padding on the thumb and pinky finger, as these areas are particularly vulnerable to injury. The wrist strap should be adjustable and secure, allowing the player to adjust the fit of the mitt to their hand for maximum comfort and protection.
When selecting a first base mitt, it's important to try on several different models to find one that fits comfortably and provides the necessary padding and support. It's also a good idea to consider the materials used in the construction of the mitt, as high-quality leather or synthetic materials can provide better durability and performance over time.
What size and shape should a good first base mitt be?
A good first base mitt should be relatively large and have a deep pocket to allow for catching and securing the ball. The size of the mitt can vary slightly depending on personal preference, but typically ranges from 12 to 13 inches in length. The shape of the mitt should be specifically designed to scoop the ball off the ground and make it easier for the first baseman to catch and control the ball. Some mitts also have extra padding to provide additional protection against hard throws. It is important to choose a mitt that fits well and feels comfortable to the player, as they will need to wear it for extended periods of time during games and practices. Ultimately, the best first base mitt is one that allows the player to make consistent and confident plays on the field.
Which materials are best for a first base mitt?
When it comes to selecting the best material for a first base mitt, there are a few options to consider. Generally, first base mitts are made with either leather or synthetic materials. Leather mitts are considered to be the most popular choice due to their durability, comfort, and flexibility. They also tend to last longer than synthetic options. However, synthetic mitts are often more affordable and can still be a good choice for beginners or those on a budget.
When selecting a leather mitt, it's important to consider what type of leather is being used. Full-grain leather is considered to be the highest quality, while top-grain leather and split leather are also options. Full-grain leather is the most expensive but is also the most durable and comfortable. Top-grain leather is a bit less expensive and still provides good quality, while split leather is the least expensive but may not last as long.
Ultimately, the best material for a first base mitt will depend on personal preference, budget, and the level of play. It's always a good idea to try on different mitts and feel the materials before making a decision.