20 Best Eye Pencil For Sensitive Eyes (2023 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

An eye pencil for sensitive eyes is a pencil that has been specifically designed for people with sensitive eyes. The pencil is usually made from hypoallergenic materials and is designed to be gentle on the eyes.

The pencil may also have a thicker lead to help prevent the lead from breaking and entering the eye.

20 Best Eye Pencil For Sensitive Eyes

Product Image Product Name Features Price

Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Brown) – Long Lasting, Waterproof, Pigmented and Smooth

  • Water and smudge resistant: specially formulated to stay put for all-day wear, it’s the perfect addition to your eye makeup set

Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil – Onyx

  • Sheer, creamy formula that effortlessly glides on
  • Precisely shapes your eyes with smooth, stay-true color
  • Long wearing up to 12 hours

Mac Eye Pencil – Coffee

  • For all eyes on you
  • Pencil eyeliner
  • Rich colour

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Eye Pencil-Mildew

  • Infused with vitamin E helps keep your eyes moisturized
  • This waterproof eye pencil helps keep the color intact for long hours

Wander Beauty Skyliner Automatic Gel Eyeliner – Brown

  • ‘Plum’ is a deep berry
  • Free from BPA, gluten, parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrances and mineral oil
  • Net a Porter

Jordana Easyliner Retractable Pencil, for Eyes, Jet Black – 0.01 oz

  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this clutz-proof eyeliner
  • Retractable design protects the tip of the pencil for precise application

Yves Saint Laurent dessin du Regard Long Lasting Eye Pencil – NO. 4 (smoky Purple …

  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this smudge-proof eyeliner pencil
  • The waterproof formula gives a long-lasting finish
  • The built-in blending tip offers a neat and precise application

L'Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner 24H, Blackest Black, 0.08 Ounces

  • Enhance your eyes’ natural beauty with this dense, lacquered finish eyeliner
  • Its unique fade-free formula provides long-lasting results

Jordana 12 HR Made to Last Liquid Eyeliner Pencil, Purple Fix – ME04

  • Intense color payoff
  • Lines, defines, accentuates
  • Long-lasting—up to 12 HR wear

L'Oreal Paris Color Riche Le Smoky Eyeliner 204 Brown Fusion

  • Softly glides over the eyelid for a long-lasting and intense result
  • Intensity, comfort and precision
  • New innovative formula combining oil and wax to achieve a long-lasting and intense colour result

Pacifica Eye Pencil, Natural, Jet – 0.1 oz

  • Helps keep skin around the eyes moisturized Shea Butter
  • Helps protects and moisturizes skin Vitamin E
  • Provides anti-aging benefits in addition to helping reduce the appearance of fine lines Vitamin C Antioxidant

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On Waterproof Eye Pencil, Empire – 0.04 oz stick

  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this creamy pencil
  • The metallic finish gives a fashionable look
  • Enriched with jojoba oil and vitamin E to hydrate your eyelids

Charlotte Tilbury The Classic Eye Powder Pencil – Black

  • Give your eyes an attractive makeover with this eye-powder pencil
  • The pencil form glides easily for an even and precise application

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil – Walk of Shame

  • New without box
  • Product Color: Walk of Shame (Nude)
  • Full Size: .04 oz / 1.2 g

Lancome Drama Liqui-Pencil Eyeliner – 03 Green Metropolitan

  • 24-hour wear- Waterproof- Tested under ophthalmological control- Suitable for sensitive eyes- Suitable for contact lens wearersFree Of. . .

Milk Makeup Infinity Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil – Limitless – 0.012 oz

  • Avocado oil and ceramides allow for a smooth glide and tug-free application.
  • Aloe vera extract helps soothe and nourish your lash line.

L'Oreal Paris Superliner Le Khol Eyeliner 120 Snow

  • Creamy texture
  • Formula contains oil and wax to create ultra-creamy feel
  • Delivers long-lasting and intense colour result
Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Brown) – Long Lasting, Waterproof, Pigmented and Smooth
  • Water and smudge resistant: specially formulated to stay put for all-day wear, it’s the perfect addition to your eye makeup set
Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil – Onyx
  • Sheer, creamy formula that effortlessly glides on
  • Precisely shapes your eyes with smooth, stay-true color
  • Long wearing up to 12 hours
Mac Eye Pencil – Coffee
  • For all eyes on you
  • Pencil eyeliner
  • Rich colour
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Eye Pencil-Mildew
  • Infused with vitamin E helps keep your eyes moisturized
  • This waterproof eye pencil helps keep the color intact for long hours
Wander Beauty Skyliner Automatic Gel Eyeliner – Brown
  • ‘Plum’ is a deep berry
  • Free from BPA, gluten, parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrances and mineral oil
  • Net a Porter
Jordana Easyliner Retractable Pencil, for Eyes, Jet Black – 0.01 oz
  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this clutz-proof eyeliner
  • Retractable design protects the tip of the pencil for precise application
Yves Saint Laurent dessin du Regard Long Lasting Eye Pencil – NO. 4 (smoky Purple …
  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this smudge-proof eyeliner pencil
  • The waterproof formula gives a long-lasting finish
  • The built-in blending tip offers a neat and precise application
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner 24H, Blackest Black, 0.08 Ounces
  • Enhance your eyes’ natural beauty with this dense, lacquered finish eyeliner
  • Its unique fade-free formula provides long-lasting results
Jordana 12 HR Made to Last Liquid Eyeliner Pencil, Purple Fix – ME04
  • Intense color payoff
  • Lines, defines, accentuates
  • Long-lasting—up to 12 HR wear
L'Oreal Paris Color Riche Le Smoky Eyeliner 204 Brown Fusion
  • Softly glides over the eyelid for a long-lasting and intense result
  • Intensity, comfort and precision
  • New innovative formula combining oil and wax to achieve a long-lasting and intense colour result
Pacifica Eye Pencil, Natural, Jet – 0.1 oz
  • Helps keep skin around the eyes moisturized Shea Butter
  • Helps protects and moisturizes skin Vitamin E
  • Provides anti-aging benefits in addition to helping reduce the appearance of fine lines Vitamin C Antioxidant
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On Waterproof Eye Pencil, Empire – 0.04 oz stick
  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this creamy pencil
  • The metallic finish gives a fashionable look
  • Enriched with jojoba oil and vitamin E to hydrate your eyelids
Charlotte Tilbury The Classic Eye Powder Pencil – Black
  • Give your eyes an attractive makeover with this eye-powder pencil
  • The pencil form glides easily for an even and precise application
Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil – Walk of Shame
  • New without box
  • Product Color: Walk of Shame (Nude)
  • Full Size: .04 oz / 1.2 g
Lancome Drama Liqui-Pencil Eyeliner – 03 Green Metropolitan
  • 24-hour wear- Waterproof- Tested under ophthalmological control- Suitable for sensitive eyes- Suitable for contact lens wearersFree Of. . .
Milk Makeup Infinity Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil – Limitless – 0.012 oz
  • Avocado oil and ceramides allow for a smooth glide and tug-free application.
  • Aloe vera extract helps soothe and nourish your lash line.
L'Oreal Paris Superliner Le Khol Eyeliner 120 Snow
  • Creamy texture
  • Formula contains oil and wax to create ultra-creamy feel
  • Delivers long-lasting and intense colour result

1. Beauty for Real I-Line 24/7 Eyeliner (Whiskey)

Beauty for Real I-Line 24/7 Eyeliner (Whiskey)

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
Walmart
Beauty Bridge
Oneway Beauty

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 5.25 x 0.62 x 0.62 inches; 0.3 Ounces

Reviews From Real Customers

Elyse

2. Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Brown) – Long Lasting, Waterproof, Pigmented and Smooth

Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Brown) - Long Lasting, Waterproof, Pigmented and Smooth

  • Water and smudge resistant: specially formulated to stay put for all-day wear, it’s the perfect addition to your eye makeup set
  • Highly pigmented, ultra-smooth glide: our easy pencil applicator lets you apply smooth, even lines with an intense color payoff every time
  • Safe and gentle formula: our gel eyeliners are never tested on animals and are 5-free with no formaldehyde and parabens
  • Apply on inner lid to seamlessly blend in with your false lashes
  • Apply and blend before it sets for a smokey effect

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer No
Product Dimensions 6 x 0.75 x 0.75 inches; 1 Ounces

Reviews From Real Customers

Stephanie C.
Lorraine R.
judy t.

3. Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil – Onyx

Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil - Onyx

  • Sheer, creamy formula that effortlessly glides on
  • Precisely shapes your eyes with smooth, stay-true color
  • Long wearing up to 12 hours

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay – austramericacosmeticsoutlet
Walmart – ARTS LLC
Perfume Emporium

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Makeup Form Pencils
Assembled Product Weight 0.03 Pounds
Assembled Product Dimensions (L x W x H) 0.70 x 0.60 x 6.80 Inches

Reviews From Real Customers

Rachael71
Tina

4. Mac Eye Pencil – Coffee

Mac Eye Pencil - Coffee

  • For all eyes on you
  • Pencil eyeliner
  • Rich colour
  • Comfortable application
  • Shade: Coffee

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
eBay
Walmart
Loja Glamourosa

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Design House Make-Up Artist Cosmetics
Year Introduced 2002

Reviews From Real Customers

Kanchan

5. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Eye Pencil-Mildew

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Eye Pencil-Mildew

  • Infused with vitamin E helps keep your eyes moisturized
  • This waterproof eye pencil helps keep the color intact for long hours
  • The creamy formula of this pencil glides smoothly for precise application

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon.com – Seller
Walmart – Rolisales LLC
Sephora
Nordstrom

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Cruelty-Free Yes
Product Form Pencil
Waterproof Yes
Vegan Yes
Weight 0.04 oz

Reviews From Real Customers

jillbrooks
Mrs0rtega
Cilla86

6. Wander Beauty Skyliner Automatic Gel Eyeliner – Brown

Wander Beauty Skyliner Automatic Gel Eyeliner - Brown

  • ‘Plum’ is a deep berry
  • Free from BPA, gluten, parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrances and mineral oil
  • Net a Porter

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Wander Beauty
Dermstore.com
Verishop

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Application Area Eyes
Eye Makeup Eyeliner
Eyeliner Gel, Pencil
Ingredient Jojoba, Olive Oil
Makeup Eye Makeup
Volume 0.5g

7. Estee Lauder Double Wear – Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil – Smoke

Estee Lauder Double Wear - Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil - Smoke

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Fragrance11.com
iBeautyCity.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Eyeliner Brand Estee Lauder
Formulation Pencil
Effect Matte
Shade Smoke

Reviews From Real Customers

Janna5
Riss14

8. Jordana Easyliner Retractable Pencil, for Eyes, Jet Black – 0.01 oz

Jordana Easyliner Retractable Pencil, for Eyes, Jet Black - 0.01 oz

  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this clutz-proof eyeliner
  • Retractable design protects the tip of the pencil for precise application
  • Smudge-proof formula offers you a long-lasting wear

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Adam’s Knick Knack Emporium
Bonanza – Banyer

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Cruelty-Free Yes
Recommended Age Group Adult
Weight 0.01 oz
Retractable Yes
Smudge-Proof Yes

Reviews From Real Customers

im2daffy
beanny_66
tesla103160

9. Yves Saint Laurent dessin du Regard Long Lasting Eye Pencil – NO. 4 (smoky Purple …

Yves Saint Laurent dessin du Regard Long Lasting Eye Pencil - NO. 4 (smoky Purple ...

  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this smudge-proof eyeliner pencil
  • The waterproof formula gives a long-lasting finish
  • The built-in blending tip offers a neat and precise application

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
BeautyLIV.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Waterproof Yes
Container Type Pencil
Weight 0.04 oz
Gender Women
Recommended Age Group Adult

10. L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner 24H, Blackest Black, 0.08 Ounces

L'Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner 24H, Blackest Black, 0.08 Ounces

  • Enhance your eyes’ natural beauty with this dense, lacquered finish eyeliner
  • Its unique fade-free formula provides long-lasting results
  • The smooth-gliding blush steadily guides you to create perfect lines

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Walmart
Ulta Beauty
Target

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Style Lacquered finish

Reviews From Real Customers

Atiq
Anna W
ShortyLee

11. Jordana 12 HR Made to Last Liquid Eyeliner Pencil, Purple Fix – ME04

Jordana 12 HR Made to Last Liquid Eyeliner Pencil, Purple Fix - ME04

  • Intense color payoff
  • Lines, defines, accentuates
  • Long-lasting—up to 12 HR wear
  • Water-resistant and transfer-resistant

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – great_buy
Bonanza – HappyForeverFinds’ booth
Oneway Beauty

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Item traits 0.04 oz
Period After Opening 24M
Scent Unscented
Shade #04 – Purple Fix
Formulation Gel Pencil
Effect Eyeliner/Matte
Volume 0.04 oz

Reviews From Real Customers

crisieh

12. L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Le Smoky Eyeliner 204 Brown Fusion

L'Oreal Paris Color Riche Le Smoky Eyeliner 204 Brown Fusion

  • Softly glides over the eyelid for a long-lasting and intense result
  • Intensity, comfort and precision
  • New innovative formula combining oil and wax to achieve a long-lasting and intense colour result
  • Can use on the inside or outside of the eyelid to draw attention
  • Available in brown fusion colour

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay – jaygee2469
fruugo.com

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

Ioana
missusaitch2011
Josephluant

13. Pacifica Eye Pencil, Natural, Jet – 0.1 oz

Pacifica Eye Pencil, Natural, Jet - 0.1 oz

  • Helps keep skin around the eyes moisturized Shea Butter
  • Helps protects and moisturizes skin Vitamin E
  • Provides anti-aging benefits in addition to helping reduce the appearance of fine lines Vitamin C Antioxidant

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Poshmark

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Derived Nutrition Claim Salt Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Soy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Paraben Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrite Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegan
Derived Nutrition Claim Dairy Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Nitrate Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Vegetarian
Derived Nutrition Claim Caffeine Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Wheat Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Lactose Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Peanut Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Gluten Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Egg Free
Derived Nutrition Claim Shell Fish Free
Rich Ingredients TITANIUM DIOXIDE CI 77891, HYDROGENATED SIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OIL, SIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OIL, CAPRYLIC / CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDES, HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL, MICA, BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTER, CANOLA OIL, SCLEROCARYA BIRREA SEED OIL, IRON OXIDE CI 77492, EUPHORBIA CERIFERA CERA, GLYCERYL CAPRYLATE, COPERNICIA CERIFERA CERA, IRON OXIDE CI 77491, IRON OXIDE CI 77499, TOCOPHEROL, ASCORBYL PALMITATE.
Ingredients TITANIUM DIOXIDE CI 77891, HYDROGENATED SIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OIL, SIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OIL, CAPRYLIC / CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDES, HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL, MICA, BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTER, CANOLA OIL, SCLEROCARYA BIRREA SEED OIL, IRON OXIDE CI 77492, EUPHORBIA CERIFERA CERA, GLYCERYL CAPRYLATE, COPERNICIA CERIFERA CERA, IRON OXIDE CI 77491, IRON OXIDE CI 77499, TOCOPHEROL, ASCORBYL PALMITATE.
Nutrition Claim Paraben Free
Nutrition Claim Sustainable
Nutrition Claim Cruelty Free
Nutrition Claim Natural
Nutrition Claim Vegan
Nutrition Claim Humane

Reviews From Real Customers

Molly G
Slim

14. Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner – Espresso

Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner - Espresso

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
eBay
Walmart
CHANEL

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Eyeliner Brand Chanel
Country/Region of Manufacture Italy
Volume .01 oz
Formulation Kohl
Shade Brown, 20 ESPRESSO

Reviews From Real Customers

Harley4156
DR
Starrdust07

15. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On Waterproof Eye Pencil, Empire – 0.04 oz stick

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On Waterproof Eye Pencil, Empire - 0.04 oz stick

  • Define the beauty of your eyes with this creamy pencil
  • The metallic finish gives a fashionable look
  • Enriched with jojoba oil and vitamin E to hydrate your eyelids

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Amazon
Sephora
Nordstrom
Selfridges

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Cruelty-Free Yes
Vegan Yes
Product Form Pencil
Weight 0.04 oz
Gender Women

16. Charlotte Tilbury The Classic Eye Powder Pencil – Black

Charlotte Tilbury The Classic Eye Powder Pencil - Black

  • Give your eyes an attractive makeover with this eye-powder pencil
  • The pencil form glides easily for an even and precise application
  • Black color enhances the natural appearance of your eyes

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
eBay – banit03
Walmart – eCosmetics
Selfridges
Cult Beauty

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Weight 0.04 oz
Cruelty-Free Yes
Product Form Pencil
Color Black
Area of Application Eyes

Reviews From Real Customers

D Parker
Sarah 1001

17. Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil – Walk of Shame

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil - Walk of Shame

  • New without box
  • Product Color: Walk of Shame (Nude)
  • Full Size: .04 oz / 1.2 g

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
eBay – alteregor

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Makeup Form 24/7 WaterLine

18. Lancome Drama Liqui-Pencil Eyeliner – 03 Green Metropolitan

Lancome Drama Liqui-Pencil Eyeliner - 03 Green Metropolitan

  • 24-hour wear- Waterproof- Tested under ophthalmological control- Suitable for sensitive eyes- Suitable for contact lens wearersFree Of. . .
  • Use the tip of the pencil to fill in any gaps between lashes.
  • For those with green eyes, line the lower lash line with black to offset any redness, and try purple, olive and copper hues.
  • For those with blue eyes, try brown and bronze tones as well as gold or navy blue.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Lancome
Sephora
Ulta Beauty
Macy’s

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Item traits 1.2 g / 0.042 oz
Eyeliner Brand Lancome
Country/Region of Manufacture Germany
Formulation Pencil
Effect Matte
Shade 03 Green Metropolitan, Green
Volume 1.2 g / 0.042 oz

Reviews From Real Customers

Atrain89
jjlawsalot
DearJalen

19. Milk Makeup Infinity Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil – Limitless – 0.012 oz

Milk Makeup Infinity Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Limitless - 0.012 oz

  • Avocado oil and ceramides allow for a smooth glide and tug-free application.
  • Aloe vera extract helps soothe and nourish your lash line.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Sephora
Kohl’s
ModeSens

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Avocado Oil and Ceramides Provide a smooth glide and tug-free application.
Aloe Vera Extract Helps soothe and nourish the lash line.

Reviews From Real Customers

beautywithlaura
Glamamama1
KKiyo

20. L’Oreal Paris Superliner Le Khol Eyeliner 120 Snow

L'Oreal Paris Superliner Le Khol Eyeliner 120 Snow

  • Creamy texture
  • Formula contains oil and wax to create ultra-creamy feel
  • Delivers long-lasting and intense colour result
  • Glides on smoothly and evenly

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Fishpond.com
bigamart.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
dimensions 0.9 x 0.9 x 14.2 cm; 10 Grams

Reviews From Real Customers

Debs
Eleonore
Surr

Conclusion

When it comes to eye pencils for sensitive eyes, there are a few things you need to keep in mind. First, you want to make sure that the eye pencil you choose is hypoallergenic and fragrance-free. Second, you want to choose an eye pencil that is soft and creamy, so it glides on easily and doesn’t tug at the delicate skin around your eyes.

Third, you want to make sure that the eye pencil you choose is safe for use on the waterline, as some eye pencils can cause irritation when used there.

When it comes to choosing the best eye pencil for sensitive eyes, I highly recommend the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. This eye pencil is hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, and safe for use on the waterline.

It’s also soft and creamy, so it glides on easily and doesn’t tug at the delicate skin around your eyes.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment