20 Best Dark Rum For Pina Colada (2023 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

There are many types of rum that can be used for a pina colada, but dark rum is usually the best choice. Dark rum has a richer flavor that can add a lot of depth to the drink. It also tends to be a bit sweeter than other types of rum, which can help to offset the sweetness of the pineapple and coconut.

20 Best Dark Rum For Pina Colada

Product Image Product Name Features Price

Captain Morgan Rum, Caribbean, Coconut – 750 ml

  • 750 ml

Bacardi Black Rum – 1.75 L bottle

  • Mellowed in heavily charred oak barrels, lightly filtered, and shaped through a secret blend of charcoals
  • Light rum offers tropical fruit and molasses flavors that’s easy to mix and simple to enjoy

Cruzan Black Cherry Rum – 750 ml

  • Alcohol Percentage: 21
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic

Selva Rey Rum, Coconut – 750 ml

  • Alcohol Percentage: 30
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic

Papa's Pilar Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle

  • Nose: Complex notes of vanilla, cinnamon, coffee beans and honey with hints of Sherry and Port.
  • Taste: Intricately flavored: sweet, mixed with earthy, vegetal tones. Mouth-coating with a touch of spice, Bourbon, almond and apricot.

Plantation Original Dark Double Aged Dark Rum

  • Rich and intense style of Jamaica and Barbados with their notes of plum, banana and vanilla
  • Enhanced by meticulous blending and further maturation, in France

Koloa Kaua`i Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle

  • Distilled, blended and bottled by Kōloa Rum Company Kalaheo, Kauaʻi, Hawaiʻi, 40% ABV/80 Proof.
  • The rum is distilled 2 times at 160 180 ABV.

Plantation Original Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle

  • 750 ml

Dead Man's Fingers Coconut Rum

  • Coconut

Malibu Caribbean Rhum, Original – 750 ml

  • Sold in over 80 countries malibu rum is a leading global brand among rum products.
  • Smooth, fresh coconut flavour with a sweet finish.

Myers's Rum Rum, Original Dark – 1 lt

  • 1 L

Cruzan Rum, Aged – 750 ml

  • 750 ml

Captain Morgan's Parrot Bay Puerto Rican Rum, Coconut – 1 lt

  • View.
  • Crystal Color. Nose.
  • Smell True Scent Of Coconut. Boca.

Koloa Coconut Rum (750 mL)

  • Distilled, blended and bottled by Kōloa Rum Company Kalaheo, Kauaʻi, Hawaii, 40% ABV/80 Proof.
  • Intense coconut aromatics with light hints of roasted coconut and piña colada undertones.
Captain Morgan Rum, Caribbean, Coconut – 750 ml
  • 750 ml
Bacardi Black Rum – 1.75 L bottle
  • Mellowed in heavily charred oak barrels, lightly filtered, and shaped through a secret blend of charcoals
  • Light rum offers tropical fruit and molasses flavors that’s easy to mix and simple to enjoy
Cruzan Black Cherry Rum – 750 ml
  • Alcohol Percentage: 21
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
Selva Rey Rum, Coconut – 750 ml
  • Alcohol Percentage: 30
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
Papa's Pilar Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle
  • Nose: Complex notes of vanilla, cinnamon, coffee beans and honey with hints of Sherry and Port.
  • Taste: Intricately flavored: sweet, mixed with earthy, vegetal tones. Mouth-coating with a touch of spice, Bourbon, almond and apricot.
Plantation Original Dark Double Aged Dark Rum
  • Rich and intense style of Jamaica and Barbados with their notes of plum, banana and vanilla
  • Enhanced by meticulous blending and further maturation, in France
Koloa Kaua`i Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle
  • Distilled, blended and bottled by Kōloa Rum Company Kalaheo, Kauaʻi, Hawaiʻi, 40% ABV/80 Proof.
  • The rum is distilled 2 times at 160 180 ABV.
Plantation Original Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle
  • 750 ml
Dead Man's Fingers Coconut Rum
  • Coconut
Malibu Caribbean Rhum, Original – 750 ml
  • Sold in over 80 countries malibu rum is a leading global brand among rum products.
  • Smooth, fresh coconut flavour with a sweet finish.
Myers's Rum Rum, Original Dark – 1 lt
  • 1 L
Cruzan Rum, Aged – 750 ml
  • 750 ml
Captain Morgan's Parrot Bay Puerto Rican Rum, Coconut – 1 lt
  • View.
  • Crystal Color. Nose.
  • Smell True Scent Of Coconut. Boca.
Koloa Coconut Rum (750 mL)
  • Distilled, blended and bottled by Kōloa Rum Company Kalaheo, Kauaʻi, Hawaii, 40% ABV/80 Proof.
  • Intense coconut aromatics with light hints of roasted coconut and piña colada undertones.

1. Captain Morgan Rum, Caribbean, Coconut – 750 ml

Captain Morgan Rum, Caribbean, Coconut - 750 ml

  • 750 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Total Wine & More
Drizly
Bottle Republic

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Directions Drink responsibly.
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.

Reviews From Real Customers

susan.c
William A.
lynnette .d

2. Bacardi Black Rum – 1.75 L bottle

Bacardi Black Rum - 1.75 L bottle

  • Mellowed in heavily charred oak barrels, lightly filtered, and shaped through a secret blend of charcoals
  • Light rum offers tropical fruit and molasses flavors that’s easy to mix and simple to enjoy
  • BACARDI Black Rum imparts toasted and nutty aromatic notes with a smoky finish that’s as crisp as it is exciting
  • Use this gluten free BACARDI dark rum as a drink mixer in classic cocktail like a Rum and Cola, Tormenta Negra or Rum Punch
  • Bacardi Black Rum is 40% alcohol by volume

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Walmart
Drizly
Total Wine & More
All Star Wine & Spirits

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 1.75 lt

Reviews From Real Customers

elizabete.a
felicity.h
JonSolo

3. Cruzan Black Cherry Rum – 750 ml

Cruzan Black Cherry Rum - 750 ml

  • Alcohol Percentage: 21
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
  • Proof: 42
  • Net weight: 1.72 mL

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Total Wine & More
InternetWines.com
njwinegallery.com
Limetree liquors

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Alcohol Percentage 21
Package Quantity 1
Alcohol content Alcoholic
Proof 42
Net weight 1.72 mL

Reviews From Real Customers

Lady Source
CherryMojito
thicks

4. Selva Rey Rum, Coconut – 750 ml

Selva Rey Rum, Coconut - 750 ml

  • Alcohol Percentage: 30
  • Package Quantity: 1
  • Alcohol content: Alcoholic
  • Proof: 60
  • Net weight: 750 mL

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Total Wine & More
Liquor World Sharon
The Wine Rack NJ

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.

Reviews From Real Customers

MrGoodVibes
Pineapple Coconut Girl
rumgirl27

5. Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle

Papa's Pilar Dark Rum - 750 ml bottle

  • Nose: Complex notes of vanilla, cinnamon, coffee beans and honey with hints of Sherry and Port.
  • Taste: Intricately flavored: sweet, mixed with earthy, vegetal tones. Mouth-coating with a touch of spice, Bourbon, almond and apricot.
  • Finish: Robust with a long finish.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Total Wine & More
Bevy’s Liquor World
Oak Liquor Cabinet

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Unit Size 750 ml
Units in Package 1

Reviews From Real Customers

Muddy Mudskipper
LaRock43
Mike NYC

6. Plantation Original Dark Double Aged Dark Rum

Plantation Original Dark Double Aged Dark Rum

  • Rich and intense style of Jamaica and Barbados with their notes of plum, banana and vanilla
  • Enhanced by meticulous blending and further maturation, in France
  • Profound structure spiced with notes of cinnamon and clove, whose smoky quality adds texture
  • Perfect for sharing with friends and families
  • An ideal companion for cocktails

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
The Whisky Exchange
Hard To Find Whisky

Product Details

Reviews From Real Customers

Tetonlafy
Therealgbo
James Z.

7. Don Q Coco Rum – 750 ml bottle

Don Q Coco Rum - 750 ml bottle

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Total Wine & More
InternetWines.com
Wine Chateau

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Unit Size 750 ml
Units in Package 1
Alcohol By Volume 42 %

Reviews From Real Customers

Irishkat
Keila
Lawrence H.

8. Cruzan Rum, Black Cherry – 750 ml

Cruzan Rum, Black Cherry - 750 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Chilly’s Liquors
Big Red Liquors
thelakesideliquor.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Directions Enjoy Cruzan responsibly. Refrigerate after opening.
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.
Alcohol by Volume 21.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

ginger.s
caitlyn.w
carina.f

9. Koloa Kaua`i Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle

Koloa Kaua`i Dark Rum - 750 ml bottle

  • Distilled, blended and bottled by Kōloa Rum Company Kalaheo, Kauaʻi, Hawaiʻi, 40% ABV/80 Proof.
  • The rum is distilled 2 times at 160 180 ABV.
  • Taste and Finish.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Target
Drizly
Total Wine & More
Wine Chateau

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Alcohol by Volume 40.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

Rankenphile
YARNMOM
GJeni

10. Cruzan Rum, Coconut – 1.75 lt

Cruzan Rum, Coconut - 1.75 lt

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Bottle Republic
odarbysliquorbarn.com
Liquor King 4

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 1.75 lt
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.

Reviews From Real Customers

Dragon11711
brittany.c
jovan.d

11. Plantation Original Dark Rum – 750 ml bottle

Plantation Original Dark Rum - 750 ml bottle

  • 750 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Total Wine & More
Drizly
Astor Wines & Spirits
Bitters & Bottles

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Alcohol by Volume 40.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

Neo Magnus
JBn951

12. Dead Man’s Fingers Coconut Rum

Dead Man's Fingers Coconut Rum

  • Coconut

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
The Whisky Exchange
Hard To Find Whisky
Whisky Kingdom

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Distillery/Brand Dead Man’s Fingers
Region England
ABV 37.5%

Reviews From Real Customers

FoxieLAlexi
Kazza
Ozwestie

13. Malibu Caribbean Rhum, Original – 750 ml

Malibu Caribbean Rhum, Original - 750 ml

  • Sold in over 80 countries malibu rum is a leading global brand among rum products.
  • Smooth, fresh coconut flavour with a sweet finish.
  • Distinctive and delicious.
  • Perfect for bringing the sun-kissed island to anytime.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Julio’s Liquors
Tulsa Hills Wine Cellar
Rapid Liquors
InternetWines.com

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.
Alcohol by Volume 21.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

Ellie

14. Myers’s Rum Rum, Original Dark – 1 lt

Myers's Rum Rum, Original Dark - 1 lt

  • 1 L

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Total Wine & More
10th St Liquors
Coasters
Liquor World of Syracuse

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 1 lt
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.
Alcohol by Volume 48.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

Craig Mance
Bob B
WannaBeJamaican

15. Kingston Coconut Rum – 1 L

Kingston Coconut Rum - 1 L

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Sip Sip Hooray Wines & Liquors
10th St Liquors
Total Wine & More
A&B Liquor

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Country Jamaica
Region Kingston

Reviews From Real Customers

Martin69
CJ2021
BoozyGurl

16. Cruzan Rum, Aged – 750 ml

Cruzan Rum, Aged - 750 ml

  • 750 ml

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Ocean Wine & Spirits
Mission Wine & Spirits
Bay Ridge Wine & Spirits

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 750 ml
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery, and may cause health problems.

Reviews From Real Customers

DB2
AlbertoJ
Yuh

17. Cruzan Rum Coconut 1.0L

Cruzan Rum Coconut 1.0L

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
myliquorexpress.com
Destination Wine & Liquor

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Alcohol Level 27.5%
Bottle size 1lt bottle Single

Reviews From Real Customers

sharon.k
DLW12

18. Captain Morgan’s Parrot Bay Puerto Rican Rum, Coconut – 1 lt

Captain Morgan's Parrot Bay Puerto Rican Rum, Coconut - 1 lt

  • View.
  • Crystal Color. Nose.
  • Smell True Scent Of Coconut. Boca.
  • Sabor Input Coconut With A Hint Of Rum, Rich Mid-Palate, Creamy, Sweet.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
All Star Wine & Spirits
The Wine Rack NJ
Siliato Liquors

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Units in Package 1
Unit Size 1 lt
Directions Enjoy our quality responsibly.
Warnings Government Warning: (1) According to the Surgeon General, women should not drink alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects. (2) Consumption of alcoholic beverages impairs your ability to drive a car or operate machinery and may cause health problems.
Alcohol by Volume 21.0 %

Reviews From Real Customers

wendy.w
michellekport
alisha.o

19. Koloa Coconut Rum (750 mL)

Koloa Coconut Rum (750 mL)

  • Distilled, blended and bottled by Kōloa Rum Company Kalaheo, Kauaʻi, Hawaii, 40% ABV/80 Proof.
  • Intense coconut aromatics with light hints of roasted coconut and piña colada undertones.
  • Taste and Finish.

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
Total Wine & More
Mission Wine & Spirits
Bay Ridge Wine & Spirits

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Order Now
to Ship Today
Bottle Size 2

Reviews From Real Customers

BritishNavalTradition
P2nDaBoyzpsu
Mezcalera

20. Cruzan Coconut Rum (1 L)

Cruzan Coconut Rum (1 L)

Check Latest Price

Sold By Price
Drizly
odarbysliquorbarn.com
Liquor World of Syracuse
Tahli’s Discount Liquors

Product Details

Specifications

Details
Countries Us Virgin Islands
Regions St. Croix
Types Spirit
Alcohol by Volume (%) 42

Conclusion

After trying different types of rum in my pina colada, I’ve come to the conclusion that dark rum is the best type of rum to use. It has a richer flavor that really comes through in the drink, and it also gives the drink a nice color.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment