Best Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches (2024 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Who doesn't love a delicious ice cream sandwich on a hot summer day? But have you ever stopped to think about the importance of the cookie part of the sandwich? After all, it's what holds the ice cream together and adds that extra crunch and flavor. So, if you're looking for the best cookies for ice cream sandwiches, here are 5 key points to keep in mind.

First and foremost, the cookie needs to be sturdy enough to hold the ice cream without falling apart. This means it should be slightly crispy on the outside but not too hard that it crumbles easily.

Secondly, the cookie should have a neutral flavor that complements the ice cream without overpowering it. This means avoiding overly sweet or heavily spiced cookies.

Thirdly, the texture of the cookie should be just right. Too soft and it will become soggy when the ice cream melts, but too hard and it will be difficult to bite into.

Fourthly, consider the size and shape of the cookie. You want something that is easy to hold and eat without making a mess.

Finally, don't forget to think about any dietary restrictions or preferences. There are plenty of delicious gluten-free, vegan, and low-sugar cookie options available that will still make for a great ice cream sandwich.

By keeping these key points in mind, you're sure to find the perfect cookies for your next ice cream sandwich creation.

10 Best Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches

1. Ice Cream Sandwich Gift Cookie Recipe Premium T-Shirt

The Ice Cream Sandwich Gift Cookie Recipe Premium T-Shirt is the perfect present for ice cream makers or cookie lovers who enjoy experimenting with new sandwich recipes. Whether you prefer classic vanilla or mint chocolate chip, this shirt celebrates the joy of creating and savoring delicious ice cream sandwiches.

For those who love gluten-free options, this shirt is also a great way to show off your passion for a healthier lifestyle. The design features the humorous phrase, "I might look like I'm listening but in my head I'm eating an Ice Cream Sandwich," making it a fun gift idea for men, women, and kids who have a sweet tooth.

Made with lightweight, fine jersey fabric, this premium t-shirt is comfortable to wear and easy to care for. It is available in a men's fit that runs small, so it is recommended to size up for a looser fit. The women's fit is true to size, so you can simply order your usual size.

This shirt is an excellent choice for a birthday or Christmas gift, or for any occasion when you want to surprise someone with a unique and thoughtful present. It is also a great way to express your love for ice cream sandwiches and share your passion with others.

Whether you're a professional baker, a home cook, or simply a fan of delicious desserts, the Ice Cream Sandwich Gift Cookie Recipe Premium T-Shirt is a must-have item for your wardrobe. So why wait? Order yours today and enjoy the sweet and creamy taste of your favorite ice cream sandwich recipe, all day long!

2. Chef'n Sweetspot Mini Ice Cream Sandwich Maker (Fudge/coconut), Standard, Small

Introducing the Chef'n SweetSpot Mini Ice Cream Sandwich Maker – the perfect tool for creating sweet treats at home! With this innovative kitchen gadget, you can make up to 10 mini ice cream sandwiches in a matter of minutes, bringing the joy of childhood nostalgia to your kitchen.

This mini ice cream sandwich maker is a wonderful gift for any occasion, allowing you to revisit childhood experiences with your loved ones. Whether you're baking with your kids or treating yourself to a sweet treat, this gadget promises to be a hit with everyone.

Making mini ice cream sandwiches has never been easier! The Chef'n SweetSpot Mini Ice Cream Sandwich Maker comes with an easy-to-follow recipe and a spatula tool, allowing you to create perfect sandwiches every time. Simply choose your favorite flavor combinations, and you're ready to start creating!

The silicone casing of this mini ice cream sandwich maker makes it easy to clean up after use. Simply rinse with soapy water and let dry, and you're ready to use it again. The compact size of this gadget also makes it easy to store in a kitchen drawer or cabinet.

Overall, the Chef'n SweetSpot Mini Ice Cream Sandwich Maker is a fun and creative way to enjoy ice cream at home. Whether you're looking for a fun way to spend time with your family or want to indulge in some delicious treats, this gadget promises to deliver. So why not treat yourself or a loved one today?

3. Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Recipe T-Shirt

The Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Recipe T-Shirt is the perfect addition to any ice cream lover or cookie enthusiast's wardrobe. This unique design is created for those who enjoy experimenting with new sandwich recipes, whether it's a classic vanilla or a refreshing mint chocolate chip flavor. For those who prefer gluten-free options, this t-shirt is sure to be a hit.

The Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Recipe T-Shirt is perfect for those who consider themselves experts in the world of ice cream sandwiches. The lightweight and classic fit of the shirt makes it comfortable to wear all day, while the double-needle sleeve and bottom hem ensures its durability.

This t-shirt is not only fashionable, but it also serves as a conversation starter among friends and family who share a love for ice cream sandwiches. It can be worn to a casual gathering, a day out with friends, or even to a dessert-themed party.

The design on the t-shirt features a mouth-watering ice cream sandwich, with the recipe printed in bold letters underneath. This makes it a great gift for anyone who loves to bake or cook. It is also an excellent way to promote your ice cream shop, bakery, or food blog.

The Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Recipe T-Shirt is made from high-quality material, ensuring it is both comfortable and long-lasting. It comes in a variety of sizes, making it easy to find the perfect fit for anyone. The design is printed using advanced printing technology, ensuring that it stays bright and vibrant even after multiple washes.

In conclusion, the Ice Cream Sandwich Cookie Recipe T-Shirt is a must-have for anyone who loves ice cream sandwiches or baking. It is fashionable, comfortable, and durable, making it a great addition to any wardrobe. With its unique design, it is sure to be a conversation starter and make you stand out from the crowd. Get your hands on this t-shirt today and show off your love for ice cream sandwiches!

4. Chameleon Colors Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Mix (4-Pack, 9.1 Oz) With Chocolate Sandwich Cookies.

Chameleon Colors Ice Cream Innovations has introduced their latest product, the Cookies & Cream Homemade Ice Cream Mix. This product comes in a pack of four 9.1-ounce bags, each containing a mix of vanilla ice cream with a rich and creamy texture, and four packs of 2.8 ounces of chocolate sandwich cookies. This product is perfect for those who crave homemade ice cream with a unique twist.

Unlike other ice cream mixes in the market, Chameleon Colors Ice Cream Innovations has created a mix that has a smooth and creamy texture. The manufacturers have carefully formulated the mix to ensure that it is free from any gritty texture or flavorless taste. This homemade ice cream mix offers a rich and creamy flavor profile that is sure to satisfy even the most discerning of taste buds.

Making ice cream with the Cookies & Cream Homemade Ice Cream Mix is easy and straightforward. Simply blend the ice cream mix with cream and whole milk, mix it well and pour it into an ice cream maker to churn. The result is a delicious and creamy ice cream that is perfect for any occasion. The product also comes with easy-to-follow instructions, making it an ideal choice for parties and reunions.

This unique ice cream mix is perfect for those who love to experiment with different flavors and textures. The inclusion of chocolate sandwich cookies adds a unique twist to the classic vanilla ice cream flavor. The cookies give the ice cream a crunchy texture and a rich chocolatey taste that complements the creaminess of the vanilla ice cream.

The product is made in the U.S.A, ensuring that it is of the highest quality. The manufacturers have taken care to use only the best ingredients in the mix, ensuring that every scoop of ice cream is delicious and satisfying. The Cookies & Cream Homemade Ice Cream Mix also makes for a thoughtful gift for ice cream lovers and fanatics.

In conclusion, Chameleon Colors Ice Cream Innovations Cookies & Cream Homemade Ice Cream Mix is an excellent choice for anyone who loves homemade ice cream with a unique twist. This product offers a rich and creamy texture, a delicious flavor profile, and easy-to-follow instructions, making it perfect for any occasion. The inclusion of chocolate sandwich cookies adds a unique twist to the classic vanilla ice cream flavor, making it a must-try for ice cream lovers.

5. Pusheen Pastel Sweet And Squishy Dessert Collection: 4-Inch Bundle Of 2 (Pink Macaron Cookie And Mint Green Ice Cream Sandwich)

The DHE Pusheen Pastel Sweet and Squishy Dessert Collection 4 Inch Bundle of 2 is a must-have for any Pusheen or cat lover. This bundle includes two Sweet Tooth themed Pusheen 4 inch plushes, the Macaron Cookie and the Ice Cream Sandwich.

In this collection, Pusheen has been reimagined as her favorite sweet treats. The Ice Cream Sandwich plush is a delightful mint green color and is rolled in rainbow sprinkles. The Macaron Cookie plush is a playful shade of pink and is bursting with yummy cream in the middle.

Both plushes are made with soft, slow rise material that is satisfying to squeeze. The plushes are also surface-washable, making them easy to keep clean.

These plushes make for the perfect gift for any occasion. Whether it's a birthday, baby shower, baptism, Easter, Valentine's Day, or just because, Gund's stuffed animals are sure to bring a smile to anyone's face.

The DHE Pusheen Pastel Sweet and Squishy Dessert Collection 4 Inch Bundle of 2 is a playful and delightful addition to any collection. These plushes are not only cute and cuddly, but they also bring a touch of sweetness and fun to any room.

6. Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Chocolate Wafer, 5 Lb)

Jellybean Foods presents their latest product, the Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies in a 5 lb pack. As a brand that is synonymous with quality and authenticity, Jellybean Foods assures customers that this product is genuine and only available from their brand.

It is important to note that this product does not include ice cream, as the title clearly states that it is a wafer and cookie combination. The wafer is perfect for making ice cream sandwiches at home or for use in other dessert recipes.

Jellybean Foods takes pride in ensuring that their products are suitable for a wide range of dietary needs. The Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies are certified Kosher, making it a great option for those adhering to a Kosher diet.

The Chocolate Wafer variant is perfect for those who are chocolate lovers. The crisp and crunchy texture of the wafer combined with the rich chocolate flavor is a match made in heaven. It is perfect for use in making homemade ice cream sandwiches or as a fun addition to other dessert recipes.

The 5 lb pack size ensures that there is enough product to cater to large gatherings or for use in commercial settings. The product is packaged in a way that ensures freshness and quality, making it a great option for those who value the taste and texture of their desserts.

In conclusion, the Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies from Jellybean Foods are a versatile and delicious addition to any dessert recipe. With its Kosher certification and genuine quality, it is a product that can be enjoyed by a wide range of customers.

7. Ruby Jewel – Ice Cream Sandwich Variety Pack 5.25 Oz. (10 Count)

Introducing the Ruby Jewel Ice Cream Sandwich Variety Pack, a new offering that is sure to delight your taste buds. This pack contains a wide selection of our favorite cookie and ice cream combos, including classic flavors like Chocolate Chip with Vanilla Bean and Brown Sugar with Strawberry, as well as new, unique flavors like Lemon with Honey Lavender and Dark Chocolate with Fresh Mint.

At Ruby Jewel, we believe in sourcing high-quality, all-natural, locally produced ingredients for our ice cream sandwiches. This ensures that you get the best possible taste experience, without any artificial flavors or preservatives. We take pride in consciously choosing ingredients that are good for you and the environment.

Our ice cream sandwiches are perfect for any occasion, whether it's a birthday, celebration, or just an everyday dessert. Each package contains 10 individually wrapped ice cream sandwiches, handmade with care in Portland, Oregon. We use only the freshest ingredients to create a delicious, creamy ice cream that is sandwiched between two soft, chewy cookies.

Our Chocolate Chip with Vanilla Bean ice cream sandwich is a timeless classic that is sure to please. The rich, creamy vanilla ice cream is paired with our soft, chewy chocolate chip cookie, creating a perfect balance of flavors and textures. If you're in the mood for something fruity, our Brown Sugar with Strawberry ice cream sandwich is a great choice. The sweet, tangy strawberry ice cream is sandwiched between our soft, chewy brown sugar cookie, creating a deliciously unique flavor combination.

For those who want to try something new, our Lemon with Honey Lavender ice cream sandwich is a must-try. The tangy lemon ice cream is paired with our soft, chewy honey lavender cookie, creating a refreshing and unique flavor experience. And if you're a fan of dark chocolate, you'll love our Dark Chocolate with Fresh Mint ice cream sandwich. The rich, decadent dark chocolate ice cream is sandwiched between our soft, chewy chocolate cookie, and is infused with fresh mint for a cool, refreshing finish.

In summary, the Ruby Jewel Ice Cream Sandwich Variety Pack is a delicious, all-natural treat that is perfect for any occasion. With a wide variety of flavors to choose from, you're sure to find something that suits your taste buds. And with our commitment to using only the freshest, locally sourced ingredients, you can feel good about indulging in this sweet treat.

Best Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches FAQs

Can I make ice cream sandwiches with store-bought cookies or do I need to make them from scratch?

Yes, you can definitely make ice cream sandwiches with store-bought cookies. In fact, it's a great and easy way to make delicious treats without having to bake your own cookies. Simply choose your favorite cookies, such as chocolate chip or oatmeal raisin, and sandwich a scoop of ice cream between two cookies. You can even get creative and use different flavored cookies or ice cream to mix and match flavors.

However, if you prefer a more homemade touch, making your own cookies can add a personal touch to your ice cream sandwiches. This allows you to control the texture, flavor, and size of the cookies to perfectly complement your chosen ice cream. Additionally, homemade cookies can make for a more impressive presentation when serving to guests.

Ultimately, the choice is yours and both options can result in delicious ice cream sandwiches.

How do I ensure that my cookies are soft enough for ice cream sandwiches?

To ensure that your cookies are soft enough for ice cream sandwiches, there are a few things you can do. First, make sure that you use a recipe that results in soft, chewy cookies. This might mean using a recipe that includes extra moisture, such as brown sugar or honey. You can also add a little bit of cornstarch to your cookie dough, which will help to keep the cookies soft and tender.

Once your cookies are baked, let them cool completely before assembling your ice cream sandwiches. If you assemble them while the cookies are still warm, the ice cream will melt and the cookies will become soggy. You can also try freezing your cookies for a few minutes before assembling your sandwiches, which will help to firm them up and prevent them from becoming too soft.

Finally, consider the type of ice cream you use. If you use a very hard ice cream, it may be difficult to bite through the sandwich without breaking the cookies. Opt for a softer ice cream, or let your ice cream soften slightly before assembling your sandwiches.

Should I freeze my cookies before making ice cream sandwiches or assemble them fresh and then freeze them?

There are different schools of thought on whether to freeze cookies before making ice cream sandwiches or assemble them fresh and then freeze. Both methods have their advantages and disadvantages.

Freezing cookies before assembling the ice cream sandwiches can help prevent the cookies from becoming soggy. This is because freezing the cookies makes them firmer, which helps them hold up better when they come into contact with the ice cream. Freezing the cookies also makes them easier to handle and assemble. However, frozen cookies can be difficult to bite through, and the ice cream may not adhere to them as well as it would to freshly baked cookies.

Assembling the ice cream sandwiches fresh and then freezing them can result in a softer, more chewy texture. The ice cream will also be more likely to adhere to the cookies, creating a more cohesive sandwich. However, the cookies may become slightly softer and more prone to becoming soggy when they come into contact with the ice cream.

Ultimately, the decision whether to freeze cookies before making ice cream sandwiches or assemble them fresh and then freeze them depends on personal preference and the desired texture of the finished product.

What flavors of cookies pair best with which flavors of ice cream for ice cream sandwiches?

When it comes to ice cream sandwiches, the cookie and ice cream pairing is crucial for a delicious treat. Here are some flavor combinations that work well together:

1. Chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream: A classic flavor combination that never disappoints. The sweetness of the chocolate chips complements the creamy vanilla ice cream.

2. Oatmeal cookies with salted caramel ice cream: The nutty flavor of oatmeal cookies pairs well with the sweet and slightly salty taste of salted caramel ice cream.

3. Peanut butter cookies with chocolate ice cream: The rich and nutty flavor of the peanut butter cookies complements the creamy chocolate ice cream.

4. Sugar cookies with strawberry ice cream: The subtle sweetness of the sugar cookies pairs well with the fruity flavor of the strawberry ice cream.

5. Gingerbread cookies with pumpkin ice cream: The warm and spicy flavor of gingerbread cookies pairs well with the creamy pumpkin ice cream.

Overall, when pairing cookies and ice cream, it's important to consider the flavors and textures of both components to ensure a harmonious and delicious combination.

What type of cookie is best for making ice cream sandwiches?

The best type of cookie for making ice cream sandwiches is a cookie that is soft and chewy, yet sturdy enough to hold up to the weight and coldness of the ice cream. Cookies like chocolate chip, sugar, oatmeal, and snickerdoodle are popular choices for ice cream sandwiches. It is important to choose a cookie that has a flat surface, as it will be easier to spread the ice cream evenly. Additionally, it is important to choose a cookie that complements the flavor of the ice cream. For example, chocolate chip cookies pair well with vanilla ice cream, while oatmeal cookies pair well with cinnamon or maple flavored ice cream. Ultimately, the best type of cookie for making ice cream sandwiches is a matter of personal preference, and experimentation is encouraged to find the perfect combination of cookie and ice cream flavors.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment