Best Cherries For An Old Fashioned (2024 Updated)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

If you're a fan of the classic cocktail, the Old Fashioned, then you know that the right cherry can make all the difference in the world. While any cherry will do, a good cherry can elevate your drink to the next level. So, what should you look for when searching for the best cherries for an Old Fashioned?

Firstly, you should consider the type of cherry. Maraschino cherries are the most popular choice, but there are other options such as Luxardo cherries or Amarena cherries.

Secondly, you should look for cherries that are preserved in a natural syrup, rather than artificial ingredients. This will ensure a better taste and texture.

Thirdly, the size of the cherry matters. A smaller cherry will fit better in your drink and won't overpower the other flavors.

Fourthly, consider the brand. Some of the most popular brands include Luxardo, Woodford Reserve, and Tillen Farms.

Finally, think about the price. While you don't want to skimp on quality, you also don't want to break the bank. Look for a brand that offers a good balance of quality and affordability.

By considering these key points, you'll be able to find the perfect cherry for your Old Fashioned cocktail. Whether you prefer a classic Maraschino or a more exotic option, a good cherry will take your drink to the next level.

10 Best Cherries For An Old Fashioned

1. Award-Winning Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries With Deep Burgundy-Red Color, Silky Smooth Rich Syrup, And Gourmet Sweet-Tart Flavor. Made In America, 10.5 Oz.

Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries are an award-winning gourmet product that offers a luxurious and rich flavor. These cherries have been recognized for their exceptional quality and flavor, earning Double Gold honors in the prestigious 2019 SIP Awards, an internationally recognized consumer judged competition.

The real fruit flavor of Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries has all the nuance of seasonal cherries, natural color and flavors. These deep, dark burgundy-red colored cherries are enrobed in a silky smooth and rich syrup that delivers a nutty, fruit-forward sweet-tart luxe taste with faint earthy undertones that is nothing short of extraordinary.

Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries are 100% American-grown and made. The cherries are sourced from the northwest coast of Michigan’s Lower Peninsula region, where rolling hills, sandy soil, and a temperate climate moderated by Lake Michigan are hailed as the ideal conditions for cherry cultivation. This ensures that the cherries are of the highest quality, and that the production process is environmentally conscious and sustainable.

These cocktail cherries are gluten-free, preservative-free, and certified kosher, making them a healthy and safe option for those with dietary restrictions. Moreover, they contain no artificial coloring or flavoring, ensuring that the natural flavor and color of the cherries are preserved.

Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries are highly versatile and can be used in a variety of cocktails and desserts. Expert mixologists agree that the intensity and clarity of these cherries are an essential component in Old Fashioneds, Manhattans, and Whiskey Sours, and provide a unique flair to Citrus Sours, Mocktails or Tiki punches. They are also the perfect complement drizzled over ice cream or gelato, or your favorite cakes or desserts.

The 10.5 oz jar size contains about 30 cherries per jar, and the 20 oz jar size has about 60, making them perfect for any occasion or gathering. Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries are an excellent choice for those who seek to elevate their cocktails or desserts with a touch of luxury and exceptional flavor.

2. Woodford Old Fashioned Bundle Of Orange Bitters, Cherries And Old Fashioned Syrup

Introducing the Woodford Old Fashioned Bundle, which includes three essential ingredients to create the perfect old fashioned cocktail. This bundle offers a convenient and cost-effective way to elevate your cocktail game and impress your guests.

The first component of this bundle is the Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries, which come in an 11 oz jar. These cherries are soaked in premium Woodford Reserve Bourbon, which imparts a rich and complex flavor profile. These cherries are perfect for garnishing your old fashioned cocktail, adding a sweet and boozy element to the drink. They can also be used in other cocktails, desserts, or as a snack.

The second component of this bundle is the Woodford Reserve Orange Bitters, which come in a 2 oz bottle. These bitters are made with bitter orange peels, gentian root, and other botanicals, which give them a bright and citrusy flavor. They are an essential ingredient in an old fashioned cocktail, as they add depth and complexity to the drink. They can also be used in other cocktails, such as a classic martini or a negroni.

The third and final component of this bundle is the Woodford Old Fashioned Syrup, which comes in a 16 oz bottle. This syrup is a pre-made mixture of sugar, water, and bitters, which makes it easy to create an old fashioned cocktail. Simply add the syrup to your favorite bourbon or whiskey, garnish with the Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries, and enjoy! This syrup is made with the same high-quality ingredients as the Woodford Reserve Orange Bitters, ensuring a consistent and delicious flavor.

In conclusion, the Woodford Old Fashioned Bundle is a must-have for any cocktail enthusiast or home bartender. It includes three essential ingredients that make it easy to create a delicious and impressive old fashioned cocktail. The Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries, Woodford Reserve Orange Bitters, and Woodford Old Fashioned Syrup are all made with premium ingredients and offer a unique and complex flavor profile. This bundle is a great value and will elevate your cocktail game to new heights.

3. Luxardo And Woodford Old Fashioned Combo

The Luxardo and Woodford Old Fashioned Combo is the perfect addition to any cocktail enthusiast's bar. This combo features the original maraschino cherry made from Italian marasca cherries and Woodford Reserve's Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup.

Luxardo, a family-owned Italian company with over 200 years of experience, produces the original maraschino cherries. These cherries are made from marasca cherries that are carefully harvested and then preserved in a sweet syrup. They are then steeped in Luxardo's own Maraschino Liqueur, resulting in a unique flavor that is both sweet and tart. The Luxardo maraschino cherries are an ideal garnish for cocktails such as the classic Old Fashioned or Manhattan, and can also be used as a topping for ice cream sundaes.

The Woodford Reserve Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup is a pre-made syrup that makes preparing a classic Old Fashioned cocktail incredibly easy. Made with natural ingredients, this syrup combines the flavors of sugar, bitters, and orange zest to create a perfectly balanced cocktail. Simply add the syrup to your favorite bourbon or rye whiskey and enjoy a delicious cocktail in seconds.

Combining these two products creates the ultimate Old Fashioned experience. Simply add a Luxardo maraschino cherry and a splash of Woodford Reserve Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup to your preferred whiskey, stir, and enjoy a perfectly balanced and flavorful cocktail.

Overall, the Luxardo and Woodford Old Fashioned Combo is a must-have for any cocktail enthusiast. The Luxardo maraschino cherries add a unique flavor to cocktails and desserts, while the Woodford Reserve Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup makes preparing a classic Old Fashioned cocktail incredibly easy. Combine these two products to create the ultimate Old Fashioned experience.

4. Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries – 13.5 Oz (383g)

Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries are a delightful addition to any cocktail. These cherries are made using natural ingredients, and they bring a bright and refreshing flavor to your favorite recipes. The cherries are infused with Kentucky's finest bourbon, adding a hint of sweetness and depth to your drinks.

These cherries are perfect for muddling, garnishing, and topping off your favorite cocktails. They add a touch of sophistication to your drinks, making them perfect for special occasions or just a night in with friends.

The Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries come in a 13.5 oz (383g) jar, making them perfect for sharing. The jar measures 2.8" l x 2.8" w x 4.5" h and can be easily stored in your refrigerator after opening.

These cherries are made using the highest quality ingredients, ensuring that you get the best possible flavor with every sip. They are a must-have for anyone who loves bourbon and wants to add a touch of elegance to their cocktails.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a way to elevate your cocktail game, look no further than Woodford Reserve Bourbon Cherries. These cherries are the perfect addition to any drink, and they are sure to impress your guests. So why not add a jar to your bar today and start creating your own signature cocktails?

5. Handcrafted 13.5oz Bourbon Barrel Aged Cherries By Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Essential For Classic Cocktails Like Old Fashioned, Manhattan, And Whiskey. Made With Tart Oregon Cherries. Gourmet Quality.

The Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. has brought to market a unique and essential cocktail ingredient with their Bourbon Barrel Aged Cherries. These cherries are handcrafted in small batches and are made with tart Oregon cherries that have been preserved in Kentucky Bourbon for the perfect blend of flavors.

The Bourbon Barrel Aged Cherries have a bold and distinctive taste that makes them an ideal garnish for classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned or Manhattan. However, they can also be used to add a sweet and tart touch to other drinks or even desserts like ice cream sundaes or cheese plates.

Crafted in the United States with raw ingredients including cherries, water, cane sugar, fruit and vegetable concentrates, bourbon, citric acid, and natural flavors, the Bourbon Barrel Aged Cherries are carefully distributed across the world to bottle shops, bars, restaurants, and general fans of a delicious drink.

One of the unique features of these cherries is that they can be eaten straight out of the jar. Their bold and distinctive flavor makes them a great snack on their own or a perfect addition to any charcuterie board.

The Bourbon Barrel Aged Cherries are a must-have for any home bartender or mixologist looking to elevate their cocktail game. They add depth and complexity to any drink and are sure to impress guests with their unique flavor and presentation.

In summary, the Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Bourbon Barrel Aged Cherries are a handcrafted, essential cocktail ingredient made with tart Oregon cherries preserved in Kentucky Bourbon. They are perfect for classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned or Manhattan but can also be used to add a sweet and tart touch to other drinks or desserts. Crafted in the United States with raw ingredients, these cherries are distributed worldwide to bottle shops, bars, restaurants, and general fans of a delicious drink. With their unique flavor and versatility, the Bourbon Barrel Aged Cherries are a must-have for any home bartender or mixologist.

6. Collins Bordeaux Stemmed Cocktail Cherries: Premium Garnish For Cocktails, Manhattan, And Old Fashioned Mix, 10oz.

Collins Bordeaux Stemmed Cocktail Cherries are a premium garnish for cocktails, specifically Old Fashioned and Manhattan mixes. These cherries are deep purple in color and juicy, making them the perfect accompaniment to any sophisticated cocktail. The stem adds a touch of elegance to the presentation, making them ideal for dinner parties or special events.

These gourmet cherries are not only great for garnishing cocktails, but they can also be used to top off your favorite dessert. The rich bing flavor adds a layer of complexity to any dish or beverage. Additionally, these cherries are a tasty snack on their own, especially for those with a sweet tooth.

The Collins Bordeaux Stemmed Cocktail Cherries are an authentic cocktail garnish that will impress guests. They are perfect for adding a touch of class to any cocktail and are a must-have for any home bar. The deep purple hue provides an aesthetically pleasing addition to the drink, while the taste adds a pleasant sweetness.

These cherries are a great gift for cocktail lovers. They are ideal for housewarming, weddings, birthdays, or any occasion where a thoughtful and unique gift is required. Cocktail connoisseurs will appreciate the authenticity and quality of these stemmed cocktail cherries.

In summary, the Collins Bordeaux Stemmed Cocktail Cherries are a premium garnish for cocktails, perfect for Old Fashioned and Manhattan mixes. They are deep purple in color, juicy, and have a rich bing flavor that adds a touch of sophistication to any drink or dessert. These cherries are also a tasty snack and an ideal gift for cocktail lovers.

7. Strongwater Cocktail Bitters Collection – 5 Bottles, 3 Fl Oz Each – Cherry, Orange, Aromatic, Walnut & Lavender Bitters – Perfect Gift Set For Old Fashioned Cocktails.

The Strongwater Cocktail Bitters Collection is a premium set of five full-sized bottles, each containing 3 fl oz of expertly crafted bitters. This gift set includes the Cherry, Orange, Aromatic, Walnut, and Lavender bitters, each with its unique flavor profile that is perfect for adding a twist to classic and creative cocktails.

Handcrafted in the Colorado Rocky Mountains, these small-batch bitters are made with real fruit, herbs, and botanicals, giving them a diverse botanical flavor profile that is sure to spruce up any cocktail. The Strongwater team takes pride in creating award-winning bitters that are not only delicious but also healing to the soul.

To enjoy these bitters, simply place ice in a cocktail shaker, add the alcohol of your choice, and then add a few dashes of your preferred flavored bitters, along with any other desired ingredients. Stir it up, and you have the perfect cocktail in no time.

Each herbal bitters is non-GMO and gluten-free and made with no added sugar, making them a healthy addition to your cocktail. The Cherry, Orange, Golden, and Floral bitters contain 45% ABV, while the Virtue bitters contain 40% ABV.

The Cherry bitters feature tart cherry bourbon, which adds a sweet and sour note to any cocktail. The Orange bitters are citrusy, with a slightly bitter taste that complements the sweetness of the alcohol. The Aromatic bitters are golden and old-fashioned, with a complex blend of herbs and spices that adds depth to any cocktail.

The Walnut bitters are classic black walnut bitters, with a nutty taste that pairs well with whiskey and other dark spirits. Finally, the Lavender bitters are floral mountain wildflower bitters, with a delicate flavor that adds a touch of elegance to any cocktail.

In conclusion, the Strongwater Cocktail Bitters Collection is a must-have for any cocktail enthusiast. With five unique flavors to choose from, each handcrafted with real ingredients, this gift set is sure to elevate any cocktail to the next level.

8. Old Fashioned Cast Iron Hand Operated Cast Iron Clamp On Cherry Pitter

The Old Fashioned Cast Iron Hand Operated Clamp On Cherry Pitter is a versatile kitchen tool that allows you to pit cherries quickly and efficiently. This modern take on an antique cherry pitter is perfect for those who want restaurant-style high speed and volume without compromising on the taste or quality of their cherries.

The cherry pitter is designed to work great on sour cherries, but it may not be as effective on smaller seeded cherries. It can also pit larger, sweet cherries, although the results may not be as neat or pretty. The crank wheel of the cherry pitter forces the fruit through a narrow channel, squeezing out the stone with minimal effort.

One of the key features of this cherry pitter is its durable Xylon coated cast body, which is easy to clean and maintain. The cherry pitter stands 7-1/2" tall and clamps to surfaces up to 1-3/4" thick, making it a versatile and convenient addition to any kitchen.

Whether you're a professional chef or a home cook, the Old Fashioned Cast Iron Hand Operated Clamp On Cherry Pitter is an essential tool for preparing cherries for pies, jams, or any other recipe that calls for pitted cherries. With its sturdy construction and easy-to-use design, this cherry pitter is sure to become a staple in your kitchen for years to come.

9. Traverse City Whiskey Co. Premium Cocktail Cherries – All-American, Stemless, Slow-Cooked Garnish For Cocktails & Desserts, Certified Kosher (2 Pack, 21 Oz)

Traverse City Whiskey Co. has launched a new product that is sure to delight cocktail lovers and dessert aficionados alike. The Premium Cocktail Cherries are made with all-American, natural, certified kosher ingredients, and slow-cooked to perfection, making them the perfect garnish for any occasion. Sold in a convenient two-pack of 21 oz jars, these cherries are sure to elevate any cocktail or dessert to the next level.

One of the standout features of the Traverse City Whiskey Co. Premium Cocktail Cherries is their delicious taste. The company uses only top-quality, gluten-free ingredients, with no artificial fillers, thickening agents, colors, or additives. The cherries are also preservative-free, making them a healthier option for those who are conscious about what they eat. Moreover, these cherries are certified kosher, making them suitable for a wider range of consumers.

The cherries are sourced from Northern Michigan, also known as the Cherry Capital of the World. Here, Traverse City Whiskey Co. uses premium Balaton cherries, which are slow-cooked in copper pots to bring out their best flavors. The company's rich American history and experience in the industry help to make their cherries incomparable in taste.

These premium cherries are also incredibly versatile. They can be used as a garnish in an Old Fashioned, stirred into a whiskey or other sour, and even used to garnish ice creams and sundaes. They can also be used as a topping for cheesecakes or other delicious dessert treats. No matter how they are used, these cherries are sure to add a decadently rich flavor to any dish.

In terms of appearance, the Traverse City Whiskey Co. Premium Cocktail Cherries are 20% larger than other brands, with a deep, dark plum red color. They are also dipped in a flavorful natural syrup, which delivers a satisfyingly sweet and savory taste with faint earthy hints. This makes them not only delicious but also visually appealing.

Traverse City Whiskey Co. is so confident in the quality of their product that they offer a full refund to any customer who is not 100% satisfied with their purchase. This is a testament to the company's commitment to delivering the highest quality product possible.

Overall, the Traverse City Whiskey Co. Premium Cocktail Cherries are a must-have for anyone who loves cocktails or desserts. They are made with top-quality, all-American, natural, certified kosher ingredients, slow-cooked to perfection, and incredibly versatile. With their decadently rich flavor and visually appealing appearance, these cherries are sure to become a staple in any kitchen or bar.

Best Cherries For An Old Fashioned FAQs

Are there any specific brands of cherries that are particularly good for old fashioned cocktails?

Luxardo and Amarena are two popular brands of cherries used in old fashioned cocktails. Luxardo cherries are made from Marasca cherries in syrup and have a sweet and sour taste, while Amarena cherries are sour with a deep burgundy color. Both of these brands offer high-quality cherries that can enhance the taste and appearance of your cocktail.

It's essential to choose cherries that are firm and plump, with a bright red color without any bruising. Avoid using canned or jarred cherries that contain artificial colors and flavors, as they can affect the taste of your cocktail.

In summary, Luxardo and Amarena are two popular brands of cherries used in old fashioned cocktails. It's crucial to choose fresh, high-quality cherries to ensure the best taste and appearance of your cocktail.

Can I use cherry juice or syrup instead of whole cherries in my old fashioned?

Yes, you can use cherry juice or syrup instead of whole cherries in your old fashioned. However, the flavor profile and overall experience of the cocktail will differ slightly. Using cherry juice or syrup will add a sweeter and more concentrated cherry flavor, which may alter the balance of the cocktail. It is important to adjust the other ingredients, such as the sugar and bitters, to compensate for the added sweetness. Additionally, if using cherry syrup, it is recommended to decrease the amount of sugar in the recipe to prevent the cocktail from becoming overly sweet. Ultimately, the choice between using whole cherries or cherry juice/syrup comes down to personal preference and the desired flavor profile of the cocktail.

How many cherries should I use in an old fashioned cocktail?

When making an old fashioned cocktail, the use of cherries is a matter of personal preference. Traditionally, one or two cherries are used as a garnish to add a touch of sweetness and color to the drink. However, some people may prefer to add more cherries or even muddle them in the cocktail for a stronger cherry flavor.

If you choose to use cherries as a garnish, it is recommended to use high-quality maraschino cherries that are not artificially colored or flavored. These cherries should be placed on a cocktail pick or skewer and placed on top of the drink.

If you prefer to muddle cherries in your old fashioned, start with one or two cherries and adjust the amount to your taste. Keep in mind that muddling too many cherries may overpower the other flavors in the cocktail.

Ultimately, the amount of cherries used in an old fashioned cocktail is a matter of personal preference and experimentation.

Should I use fresh or preserved cherries for my old fashioned?

For an Old Fashioned cocktail, it is recommended to use preserved cherries rather than fresh cherries. Preserved cherries, also known as cocktail cherries, are typically maraschino cherries that have been soaked in sugar syrup and liqueur. These cherries have a sweeter and more concentrated flavor that complements the flavor of the whiskey in an Old Fashioned.

On the other hand, fresh cherries may not have the same level of sweetness and can water down the drink, affecting its overall taste. However, if fresh cherries are your preference, it is recommended to muddle them in the glass with sugar and bitters before adding the whiskey to bring out their flavor. Ultimately, the choice between fresh and preserved cherries comes down to personal preference, but most bartenders and mixologists would recommend using preserved cherries for an Old Fashioned cocktail.

Which cherry variety is best for an old fashioned cocktail?

The best cherry variety for an old fashioned cocktail is the Luxardo Maraschino cherry. These cherries are sourced from Italy and have a sweet, almond-like flavor that complements the whiskey and bitters in the classic cocktail. They also have a firm texture that holds up well in the drink and adds a pop of color to the finished product.

Another option is the Amarena cherry, which is also from Italy and has a similar sweet flavor. However, these cherries are slightly smaller and have a softer texture than Luxardo cherries.

In general, it's best to avoid using artificially colored and flavored maraschino cherries, as they can overpower the other flavors in the cocktail and give it an artificial taste. Stick with high-quality, natural cherry varieties like Luxardo or Amarena for the best results.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment