10 Best Bait For Old Fashioned Mouse Trap (2024 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Are you tired of having mice running around your house and want to get rid of them? An old fashioned mouse trap is a great solution, but what kind of bait should you use? Here are 5 key points to consider when looking for bait for an old fashioned mouse trap.

1. Sweet and savory: Mice have a sweet tooth and love foods like peanut butter, chocolate, and dried fruit. However, they also love savory foods like cheese and meats.

2. Freshness: Make sure to use fresh bait. Mice have a keen sense of smell and can detect stale or old bait.

3. Placement: Place the bait in the center of the mouse trap. This will ensure that the mouse has to step onto the trigger to get to the bait.

4. Quantity: Use a small amount of bait, about the size of a pea. This will prevent the mouse from being able to grab the bait and run away without triggering the trap.

5. Experiment: Try different types of bait to see what works best in your home. Some mice may prefer sweet foods over savory, or vice versa.

In conclusion, when looking for bait for an old fashioned mouse trap, consider using sweet and savory fresh bait, placing it in the center of the trap, using a small amount, and experimenting with different types of bait. With these tips, you'll be able to effectively trap and remove mice from your home.

10 Best Bait For Old Fashioned Mouse Trap

1. 6 Pack Of Quick And Safe Mouse Traps For Indoor Use, Effective And Sanitary Mousetrap Catchers For Household And Pet Safety.

Introducing the Mouse Traps, Mice Traps for House, Small Mice Trap Indoor Quick Effective Sanitary Safe Mousetrap Catcher for Family and Pet – 6 Pack. This innovative product offers a safe and effective solution for catching mice without the use of poison or glue. With its no-touch design, users can rest assured that their fingers will never be at risk of snapping.

These mouse traps are incredibly easy to use and set up. Simply place a bait in the cup and put it back into the trap, keeping the clamp open. Perfect for both indoor and outdoor use, the traps are suitable for catching small mice with their high sensitivity and powerful stainless steel spring.

Unlike traditional wood or metal traps, these mouse traps are more efficient and safe. With only 0.025 lbs of weight needed to trigger the trap, mice are easily caught and eliminated. This ensures that users can completely eliminate the problem without the worrying of mice returning again.

Using electronic ultrasonic equipment may temporarily scare the mouse away, but they will eventually return after a period of time. With our best mouse trap, users can catch the mouse effectively to avoid future infestations.

The Mouse Traps, Mice Traps for House, Small Mice Trap Indoor Quick Effective Sanitary Safe Mousetrap Catcher for Family and Pet – 6 Pack is not only efficient and effective, but also easy to clean. Users can easily clean any odors and blood with ease.

We understand that customer satisfaction is essential, and we take pride in offering friendly customer support. If you are not satisfied with our product, we will try our best to help you.

In conclusion, the Mouse Traps, Mice Traps for House, Small Mice Trap Indoor Quick Effective Sanitary Safe Mousetrap Catcher for Family and Pet – 6 Pack is a must-have for any household experiencing a mouse problem. With its safe and efficient design, users can eliminate their mouse problem with ease and confidence.

2. Seepis Indoor Mouse Traps – Quick, Effective, And Safe For Family And Pets – 12 Pack, Black.

The SEEPIS Mouse Trap is a highly efficient tool for getting rid of mice in your house. It is designed to be quick, effective, and safe for both your family and pets. With a sensitive trigger and powerful spring, this mouse trap can kill mice faster and more effectively than other traps on the market. It only takes 15 grams of pressure to trigger the trap, ensuring a quick and humane kill.

Made from durable plastic and stainless steel, this mouse trap is both reusable and easy to clean. Unlike traditional wood rat traps that absorb odors and stains, the SEEPIS Mouse Trap can be washed and reused multiple times. It is also designed to be easy to set up, eliminating the need to use your fingers and avoiding the possibility of injury.

One of the standout features of the SEEPIS Mouse Trap is that it allows you to remove mice without actually touching them. Simply hold the tail of the trap and open it over a trash can to dispose of the mouse. This makes the process of getting rid of mice much more hygienic and less unpleasant.

The SEEPIS Mouse Trap can be used both indoors and outdoors, making it a versatile tool for dealing with mice infestations in all directions. Place it in warehouses, gardens, kitchens, corridors, and other places where rats frequently appear, and you will be able to stay free of mouse troubles.

Overall, the SEEPIS Mouse Trap is an excellent choice for anyone looking to get rid of mice in their home. It is quick, efficient, and safe for both humans and pets. Its reusable design and easy cleaning make it a cost-effective solution to mouse infestations, while its hygienic removal process makes it a more pleasant option than traditional traps.

3. Catchmaster Pest Glue Trap – 36 Pre-Baited Boards For Indoor Use. Non-Toxic And Made In The Usa.

The Pest Glue Trap by Catchmaster is a highly effective solution for catching rodents, mice, rats, and insects in your home or business. This product comes with 36 boards that are pre-baited and ready to use indoors, making it a simple and easy solution for pest control.

The glue traps are pre-scented, so there is no need for additional bait. For best results, leave the trap with the paper on so that pests can acclimate to the trap, then place the glue boards along known or suspected rodent pathways. The peanut scent is non-allergenic, making it safe for use around people and pets.

Catchmaster glue traps are safe, non-toxic, and no-mess, making them an effective alternative to standalone glue boards that may not hold up as well in damp or humid areas like basements or bathrooms. When placed in an area with normal conditions, glue traps can last up to one full year. Our products are tested under the harshest field conditions to ensure maximum reliability for any level of pest control expert.

Designed to help keep your family protected and safe from unwanted pests in your home, Catchmaster's glue traps are intuitive, secure, and effective. The pest glue traps are easy to place, simply put the trap against walls and along pathways to catch unwanted pests and insects. If using in an area with dust or other debris, fold the trap into a tunnel to protect the glue.

These glue boards can be used indoors in residential, commercial, or industrial buildings, and sensitive areas where rodenticides or snap traps are undesirable or prohibited. Our glue boards are proudly made in the USA, fast-acting, and non-toxic, keeping your family and home safe from pests.

At the core of Catchmaster's philosophy is intelligent pest management. Utilizing a science-based approach to integrated pest management, we leave no stones unturned when it comes to pests. We have unwavering conviction in our products and are dedicated to providing effective solutions for pest control.

In conclusion, the Pest Glue Trap by Catchmaster is a highly effective solution for catching rodents, mice, rats, and insects in your home or business. With pre-baited and ready-to-use boards, it is a simple and easy solution for pest control. Safe, non-toxic, and no-mess, it is an effective alternative to standalone glue boards that may not hold up as well in damp or humid areas. Catchmaster's glue traps are intuitive, secure, and effective, making them an ideal choice for pest control in any setting.

4. Tomcat Press 'n Set Mouse Trap, 2 Traps/pack (7-Pack)

The Tomcat Press 'N Set Mouse Trap is an effective and easy-to-use solution for eliminating pesky mice from your home or business. This product comes in a convenient pack of two traps and is available in a 7-pack, providing ample supply for multiple uses.

Setting this mouse trap is a breeze, as it requires only one touch to activate. Once set, the trap is ready to catch any unsuspecting mice that wander into your space. The trap's design includes a built-in grab-tab, making disposal quick and easy. No more touching the dead mouse or struggling to remove it from the trap.

Tomcat Press 'N Set Mouse Trap is a guaranteed solution to get rid of mice. If you are not satisfied with the product or its performance, the company offers a satisfaction guarantee and will refund your money.

For even better results, the Tomcat Attractant Gel may be used with the Press 'N Set Mouse Trap. This gel is specifically formulated to attract mice and increase the chances of trapping them.

Not only is this mouse trap effective, but it is also safe and humane. The Press 'N Set Mouse Trap utilizes a powerful spring to kill mice instantly, ensuring a quick and painless death. Additionally, the trap is designed to prevent harm to pets or children, with a secure locking mechanism that keeps the trap closed until it is manually opened for disposal.

Overall, the Tomcat Press 'N Set Mouse Trap is a reliable and effective solution for eliminating mice from your space. Its ease of use, built-in grab-tab, and guaranteed results make it a top choice for homeowners and business owners alike.

5. D-Con Refillable Corner Fit Mouse Bait Station, 1 Trap + 18 Bait Refills

The d-CON Refillable Corner Fit Mouse Bait Station is a reliable solution to help reduce mice problems. This product comes with one trap and 18 bait refills, making it an ideal choice for homeowners looking for a long-lasting solution to tackle the issue of mice infestation.

One of the standout features of this product is that it contains no neurotoxins or anti-coagulants, making it a safe option for use in homes with children and pets. The neurotoxins and anti-coagulants commonly found in other mouse traps can pose a significant health risk to humans and animals, making it essential to opt for a safer alternative.

The d-CON Refillable Corner Fit Mouse Bait Station is also designed to be tamper-resistant, ensuring that curious children and pets do not come in contact with the bait. The compact and weather-resistant station can be used both indoors and outdoors, making it a versatile option for homeowners.

The product is ideal for use in various areas of the home, including the attic, kitchen/pantry, basement, bedrooms, bathrooms, living room, laundry room, garage, and shed. This makes it a comprehensive solution to tackle mice infestations irrespective of the location in the house.

The bait station is easy to use and refill, making it a convenient option for homeowners. The station can be refilled multiple times, ensuring long-lasting protection against mice infestations.

In summary, the d-CON Refillable Corner Fit Mouse Bait Station is a safe, effective, and long-lasting solution to help reduce mice problems in homes. With its tamper-resistant design, weather-resistant materials, and versatile use, it is an excellent investment for homeowners looking for a reliable solution to tackle mice infestations.

6. D-Con No View, No Touch Covered Mouse Trap, 6 Pack (2 Traps Each) (Packaging May Vary)

The D-Con No View, No Touch Covered Mouse Trap is a highly effective and safer alternative to traditional mouse traps. This product comes in a convenient 6-pack, with 2 traps in each pack. It is designed with a unique covered design that ensures there is no need to touch the trapped mouse, making it safer than other options on the market.

One of the key benefits of the D-Con No View, No Touch Covered Mouse Trap is its ease of use. Simply insert the bait into the bait compartment, twist, and set the trap. This process takes only a few seconds and eliminates the need for complicated setup and handling. The bait compartment is located in the back of the trap, ensuring that the bait is easily accessible to the mouse but not to children or pets.

The D-Con No View, No Touch Covered Mouse Trap is also safe around children and pets. The covered design ensures that the trap is not accessible to curious children or pets. Additionally, the trap is designed to be tamper-resistant, ensuring that the mouse is the only one that can access the bait and trigger the trap.

In terms of effectiveness, the D-Con No View, No Touch Covered Mouse Trap is highly efficient in catching mice. The unique design of the trap ensures that there is no view of the trapped mouse, which helps to reduce stress for both the mouse and the user. The covered design also helps to keep the trap clean and hygienic, reducing the risk of contamination from trapped mice.

The D-Con No View, No Touch Covered Mouse Trap is an ideal solution for those looking for a safe and effective way to catch mice. Its ease of use, safety, and effectiveness make it a top choice for homeowners and businesses alike. The product comes in a convenient 6-pack, ensuring that users have enough traps to cover a larger area or multiple rooms. With this product, users can rest assured that they are taking the necessary steps to keep their home or business pest-free.

7. 4 Pack Humane Mouse Traps – Reusable, Safe & Effective For Indoor/outdoor Use

The lllteri Humane Mouse Traps are a set of four catch and release traps that are designed to be safe for both family and pets. These traps are reusable and easy to clean, providing an environmentally friendly solution to rodent problems.

Made from new PC material, these traps are highly durable and can be used both indoors and outdoors. They are designed to catch small rodents, voles, hamsters, and moles without causing any harm or killing them. The traps also feature multiple breathing holes to prevent suffocation.

Setting the traps is easy and effective. Simply load the bait into the bait compartment, press the bottom to open it, and keep the spring door open. The traps will quickly catch any rodents that enter.

The lllteri Humane Mouse Traps are safe to use around both family and pets, as they do not require electricity, glue, chemicals, or poison. They are a non-lethal solution to rodent problems that will not harm the environment.

To ensure the traps are effective, it is recommended to place the bait food that the small rodent likes and put it in the area where the mouse primarily travels. Additionally, when releasing and cleaning the traps, it is important to wear gloves to avoid contact with bacteria.

In summary, the lllteri Humane Mouse Traps are an effective and safe solution to rodent problems. They are easy to use, reusable, and environmentally friendly, making them a great choice for anyone looking for a humane way to deal with rodents.

8. Tomcat 373312 Wooden Mouse Trap (1 Case Of 48 Traps)

The Tomcat 373312 Wooden Mouse Trap is an affordable and reliable way to get rid of mice in your home or business. With a case of 48 traps, you can efficiently tackle any rodent problem you may encounter.

This wooden trap is easy to use and requires no special skills or knowledge. Simply place the bait on the trap, set the trigger, and wait for the mouse to take the bait. Once the mouse is caught, you can dispose of it safely and easily.

For even better results, you may use Tomcat attractant gel with this trap. The gel contains a powerful attractant that lures mice to the trap, increasing the chance of catching them. Plus, the gel is easy to apply and won't create a mess or attract other pests.

The Tomcat 373312 Wooden Mouse Trap is a reliable way to kill mice. The trap is designed to be strong and durable, ensuring that it won't break or malfunction during use. Plus, the trap is reusable, allowing you to catch multiple mice with just one trap.

Overall, the Tomcat 373312 Wooden Mouse Trap is an excellent choice for anyone looking for an economical and effective way to get rid of mice. With its ease of use, reliability, and compatibility with Tomcat attractant gel, this trap is a must-have for anyone dealing with a rodent infestation.

9. Reusable Indoor/outdoor Mouse Traps – 12 Pack. Quick And Effective For Small Mice.

The Mouse Traps 12-Pack is a highly effective and reusable solution for catching small mice both indoors and outdoors. Made from high-quality ABS plastic, these traps are easy to wash and do not absorb any odors or stains like traditional wood mouse traps.

Featuring powerful springs and large open mouths, these traps are designed to catch and kill rats instantly. With a sensitivity that can be triggered by only 0.03lbs of weight, mice are killed quickly and without any pain.

In addition to their effectiveness, these mouse traps are also incredibly easy to set up. Simply remove the bait cup, add food to it, and place it back onto the trap. Then, keep the clamp open and place the trap in an area where mice are likely to be found. Peanut butter is suggested as an ideal bait for these traps.

One of the key benefits of these mouse traps is their safe and hygienic design. With a no-touch feature, users can set and dispose of the traps without worrying about injury or cross-contamination. When it's time to dispose of a caught mouse, simply press the trap to release it without ever having to touch the rodent.

Suitable for both indoor and outdoor use, these mouse traps are ideal for a variety of settings including kitchens, living rooms, bathrooms, warehouses, gardens, and garages. However, it's important to keep them away from pets, children, and other small animals when used outdoors.

Overall, the Mouse Traps 12-Pack is a quick, efficient, and cost-effective solution for dealing with small mice in and around the home. With their reusable design and innovative features, these traps are a must-have for anyone looking to effectively control pests in their living space.

10. Victor Easy Set Mouse Traps (Pack Of 12)

The Victor Easy Set Mouse Traps (Pack of 12) is a classic wood-based wire snap trap with a large scented plastic trip pedal. Designed to provide clean and quick trapping, it can be used safely around food, water, children, and pets. This makes it an ideal solution for runaway trapping and pest control.

One of the key features of this mouse trap is its Swiss cheese pedal, which requires no baiting. This means that you can simply set the trap and wait for it to do its job. The scent of the plastic pedal is enough to attract mice to the trap, making it a hassle-free and efficient way to get rid of pests in your home or business.

Another advantage of the Victor Easy Set Mouse Traps is their ease of use. The trap can be easily set by hand, without the need for any special tools or equipment. Plus, the large pedal makes it easy to catch even the smallest and most agile mice.

In addition to its effectiveness and ease of use, the Victor Easy Set Mouse Traps are also designed to be safe and humane. The trap is made from non-toxic materials and does not use any harmful chemicals or poisons. This means that you can use it confidently around your family, pets, and food without worrying about any side effects.

Overall, the Victor Easy Set Mouse Traps (Pack of 12) is an excellent option for anyone looking for an efficient and safe way to get rid of mice in their home or business. With its clean and quick trapping, easy-to-use design, and safe and humane materials, it is a reliable and effective solution for pest control.

Best Bait For Old Fashioned Mouse Trap FAQs

Can I use peanut butter as bait for an old fashioned mouse trap?

Yes, you can use peanut butter as bait for an old fashioned mouse trap. In fact, peanut butter is often a preferred choice for mouse traps as it is highly attractive to mice due to its strong smell and sweet taste. When using peanut butter as bait, it is important to place a small amount on the trigger of the trap, making sure not to overload it, as this can cause the mouse to eat the bait without triggering the trap. It is also important to check the trap regularly to ensure it is still effective and to dispose of any trapped mice humanely. Overall, using peanut butter as bait for an old fashioned mouse trap is a cost-effective and efficient way to control mice infestations in your home or workplace.

How do I choose the right bait for my old fashioned mouse trap?

Choosing the right bait for an old fashioned mouse trap is crucial in ensuring that the trap is effective in catching mice. The type of bait that works best may vary depending on the region, season, and availability of food. Common bait options include peanut butter, cheese, nuts, and dried fruit. These options are all appealing to mice due to their strong scent and high fat content.

It is important to note that the amount of bait used should be small enough to fit on the trap trigger but large enough to attract the mouse. Additionally, placing the trap in an area where mice frequently travel, such as along walls or near food sources, can increase the chances of catching a mouse.

To determine the most effective bait option, it may be helpful to experiment with different options and observe which bait the mice are most attracted to. By choosing the right bait, you can increase the likelihood of catching mice and effectively controlling the infestation.

How often should I replace the bait in my old fashioned mouse trap?

As a professional, I would recommend replacing the bait in an old fashioned mouse trap every time you check it. This is because the scent of the bait can wear off quickly, and mice may not be attracted to it if it is not fresh. Additionally, if the bait has been sitting in the trap for too long, it may start to spoil or attract other pests, such as ants.

It is also important to note that the frequency of bait replacement may vary depending on the type of bait you are using, the environment in which the trap is placed, and the level of mouse activity in the area. If you notice that the bait is consistently being taken without catching any mice, it may be time to try a different type of bait or adjust the placement of the trap.

Overall, regularly replacing the bait in your old fashioned mouse trap can increase the likelihood of catching mice and help control rodent populations in your home or business.

What is the best type of bait to use for an old fashioned mouse trap?

The best type of bait to use for an old fashioned mouse trap is a substance that is highly attractive to mice and can be easily placed on the bait holder. Some of the most effective bait options include peanut butter, cheese, chocolate, or even small bits of bacon. These baits have a strong odor that can easily lure the mouse to the trap. When using a mouse trap, it is essential to place the bait in a way that the mouse has to touch the trigger to access it. This ensures that the trap will be activated, and the mouse will be caught. It is important to note that the bait should be checked and replaced regularly to maintain its freshness and effectiveness. Additionally, it is advisable to use gloves when handling the bait to avoid leaving human scent on it, which may deter the mouse from approaching the trap.

Will cheese work as bait for an old fashioned mouse trap?

Yes, cheese can work as bait for an old fashioned mouse trap. Cheese is a popular choice for mouse traps because of its strong odor and high protein content, which is attractive to mice. However, it is not the only option for bait. Other foods such as peanut butter, chocolate, and bacon can also be effective as bait. The key is to choose a bait that is highly attractive to mice and can stick to the trap trigger without falling off easily. It is important to note that the type of mouse trap used can also affect the effectiveness of the bait. For example, snap traps are more likely to be successful with solid baits that can be easily picked up, while sticky traps are better suited for liquid baits. Overall, cheese can be a good option for a mouse trap bait, but it is important to consider other factors such as the type of trap and the preferences of the mice in the area.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!