10 Best Italian Bakery New Jersey (2024 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

If you are a fan of Italian baked goods and happen to be in New Jersey, you are in luck! The state is home to several authentic Italian bakeries that serve up some of the best pastries, bread, and cakes you will ever taste. However, with so many options to choose from, it can be overwhelming to decide which bakery to visit. To make things easier for you, here are five key points to consider when looking for an Italian bakery in New Jersey:

1. Authenticity: Look for a bakery that sources its ingredients from Italy and uses traditional Italian baking techniques. This will ensure that you get the same taste and quality as you would in Italy.

2. Variety: A good Italian bakery should offer a wide variety of baked goods, including bread, pastries, cakes, and cookies. This will give you more options to choose from and allow you to try something new every time you visit.

3. Reputation: Check online reviews and ask for recommendations from friends or family to find out which Italian bakeries in New Jersey are highly regarded and have a good reputation.

4. Freshness: Make sure the bakery you choose bakes its goods daily and uses fresh ingredients. This will ensure that you get the best quality and taste.

5. Location: Consider the location of the bakery and whether it is convenient for you to visit. Some Italian bakeries in New Jersey have multiple locations, so you may want to choose one that is closer to you.

By considering these key points, you can find the perfect Italian bakery in New Jersey that will satisfy your craving for delicious, authentic baked goods.

10 Best Italian Bakery New Jersey

1. Large Gourmet Birthday Gift Basket With Chocolate Covered Cookies And Chocolate Gift Box.

If you want to give the ultimate gift of giving, look no further than the Birthday Gift Basket – Happy Birthday Cookies – Chocolate Covered Cookies – Chocolate Gift Box – Gourmet Food Gifts (Large Box). This eye-catching cookie gift box is filled with Hazel and Creme chocolate covered cookies that have a delicious combination of flavors and textures. Each cookie is double creamed and generously dipped into dark chocolate, then topped with mouth-watering flavorful toppings. Indulge yourself and savor every bite into pure chocolate bliss. The unique blends and flavors will surely satisfy all your chocolate cravings.

Hazel and Creme’s chocolates are handcrafted and tested to ensure you get the best distinctive chocolate flavor. Only the freshest premium quality ingredients are used to ensure your ultimate satisfaction. The cookies are tried and true, ensuring every piece is pure bliss. You can buy with ultimate confidence, knowing you are getting a product that has been crafted with care and attention to detail.

Nothing says “Happy Birthday” like a box of heavenly chocolates. Make your special someone’s birthday one to remember with this box of deliciousness. There’s nothing more thoughtful and exciting than a rich, luscious box of chocolate. These chocolate cookie boxes are perfect, thoughtful gifts for any birthday occasion.

Every box is shrink-wrapped for ultimate freshness, then professionally packaged in an enticing modern box that is guaranteed to arrive in perfect condition and sure to impress any recipient. The box itself may be black or gold, but it's what's inside that counts. The care and attention given to the packaging and presentation of this product is just as important as the delicious treats inside.

These chocolate gift boxes are truly one of a kind. Kosher and dairy-free, they are loved and appreciated by all. Enjoy guilt-free chocolate that’s just a click away! Hazel and Creme are so confident in their product that they offer a satisfaction guarantee. From beautiful packaging to delicious flavors, this product is sure to impress. So go ahead, treat yourself or your loved ones to a Birthday Gift Basket – Happy Birthday Cookies – Chocolate Covered Cookies – Chocolate Gift Box – Gourmet Food Gifts (Large Box), and indulge in pure chocolate bliss.

2. Gomacro Variety Pack, 1 Bar Each (Pack Of 12) – 12 Flavors Including 3 New Flavors

The GoMacro Variety Pack is the perfect choice for anyone who loves to try different flavors. This pack consists of 12 bars, each of which features a unique and delicious flavor. The pack includes three new flavors – Mocha choco chip, Dark choco Almond, and Blueberry + Cashew. The other flavors included in the pack are Cherries + Berries, Banana + Almond Butter, Cashew Butter, Granola + Coconut, Sunflower Butter + Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Cashew Caramel, and Almond Butter + Carob. In case any of these flavors are out of stock, the pack will include the Apple + Walnut flavor, and the customers are guaranteed to receive three new flavors.

All the bars in the GoMacro Variety Pack are made with InfantSafe Brown Rice Syrup, which is a natural sweetener that is safe for infants. These bars are gluten-free, USDA organic, vegan, GMO-free, and macrobiotic. The bars are made with high-quality ingredients, and they are perfect for people who are health-conscious and want to maintain a healthy lifestyle.

The GoMacro Variety Pack is an excellent choice for people who are always on the go and need a quick and healthy snack. These bars are perfect for people who are looking for a quick energy boost or want to satisfy their hunger pangs. The bars are also great for people who have specific dietary requirements, such as vegans or people who are gluten intolerant.

The GoMacro Variety Pack is not a manufacturer-created variety pack, and it will not be sent in the original manufacturer's packaging. However, customers can rest assured that they will receive a high-quality product that is packed with flavor and nutrition. The bars are perfect for people of all ages and can be enjoyed anytime, anywhere.

In conclusion, the GoMacro Variety Pack is a fantastic product that offers a wide range of flavors and is made with high-quality ingredients. The pack includes three new flavors, and customers are guaranteed to receive them even if they are out of stock. The bars are perfect for people who are health-conscious and want to maintain a healthy lifestyle. The bars are also great for people who are always on the go and need a quick and healthy snack. Overall, the GoMacro Variety Pack is a must-try product that is packed with flavor, nutrition, and convenience.

3. Wyler's Authentic Italian Ice Fat Free Freezer Bars Original Flavors 2oz Bars, 96 Count

Wyler's Authentic Italian Ice Fat Free Freezer Bars Original Flavors 2oz bars, 96 count is a delicious and guilt-free frozen treat that is perfect for any occasion. These freezer bars are made with real fruit juice and come in four original flavors: Kiwi Watermelon, Orange Crème, Raspberry, and Lemon. Simply place the Wyler's Italian Ice in the freezer, wait for the liquid to freeze, snip off the top, and enjoy!

Wyler's Italian Ice freezer bars are always fat-free, making them a healthier alternative to traditional frozen treats. These freezer bars are perfect for those who are looking to indulge in a sweet treat without the added guilt. Each bar is only 2oz, making it the perfect snack size.

The Kiwi Watermelon flavor is a refreshing and tangy combination of kiwi and watermelon that is sure to quench your thirst on a hot summer day. The Orange Crème flavor is a creamy and smooth blend of orange and vanilla that is reminiscent of an orange creamsicle. The Raspberry flavor is a burst of sweet and tart raspberry flavor that is perfect for those who love fruity flavors. Lastly, the Lemon flavor is a classic, tangy lemon flavor that is perfect for those who love sour treats.

Wyler's Authentic Italian Ice Fat Free Freezer Bars Original Flavors 2oz bars, 96 count is perfect for any occasion. Whether you are looking for a sweet treat to enjoy on a hot summer day or a guilt-free snack to satisfy your sweet tooth, these freezer bars are the perfect choice. With 96 bars in each box, you will have plenty to share with your friends and family. So why wait? Try Wyler's Authentic Italian Ice Fat Free Freezer Bars Original Flavors 2oz bars, 96 count today and experience the delicious and guilt-free frozen treat that everyone is talking about!

4. Chef Works Unisex Adult Chef Hat Apparel Accessories, Black, One Size Us

The Chef Works unisex adult Chef Hat apparel accessory is a must-have for any professional chef or home cook. Made with a blend of polyester and cotton, this hat is not only durable but also comfortable to wear for long periods. The hat is available in black and white, making it easy to match with any uniform or outfit.

One of the standout features of the Chef Works Chef Hat is its Velcro closure. This closure ensures a secure fit and allows for easy adjustment to accommodate different head sizes. The hat is designed to fit most adults, making it a versatile accessory that can be used by a variety of people.

The Chef Works Chef Hat is also machine washable, making it easy to clean and maintain. It is recommended to wash the hat with like colors and tumble dry on low heat to prevent any damage to the fabric.

In addition to its practical features, the Chef Works Chef Hat also adds a touch of professionalism to any kitchen. The classic design and color options make it a timeless accessory that will never go out of style. Whether you're a seasoned chef or just starting out, this hat will help you feel confident and ready to tackle any culinary challenge.

Overall, the Chef Works unisex adult Chef Hat apparel accessory is a high-quality product that any chef or home cook would be proud to wear. With its durable construction, adjustable fit, and classic design, this hat is sure to become a staple in your kitchen wardrobe.

5. Carlo's Bakery – Best Seller's Cake Slice Sampler – 8x Slices

Carlo's Bakery, famously known as the "Cake Boss," is offering a delectable treat for cake lovers with its Best Seller's Cake Slice Sampler. This ultimate cake experience includes eight slices of the bakery's most popular and delicious cakes.

The first cake in the sampler pack is the Rainbow cake, which boasts six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake that are filled with a sweet vanilla icing and covered with rainbow sprinkles. The second cake is the Strawberry Pastel Rainbow, which features six layers of pastel rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled with a sweet strawberry buttercream icing and topped with confetti quins.

The Carrot cake, made with freshly shredded carrots and finely chopped walnuts, is frosted with cream cheese icing, while the Red Velvet cake, a southern classic, has moist cake and cream cheese frosting. This cake is adorned with chocolate shavings and crumbles of red velvet cake.

The Confetti cake is a vanilla cake with a burst of sprinkles layered with sweet vanilla confetti icing and topped with rainbow sprinkles. The Rainbow Chocolate Fudge cake is another colorful treat, with six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled with a rich chocolate fudge frosting and covered with rainbow sprinkles.

The Chocolate Fudge cake is a quintessential chocolate cake, iced with a rich chocolate fudge frosting, topped with chocolate ganache, and adorned with chocolate sprinkles. Lastly, the Cookies & Cream cake is made with chocolate cake layers, iced with cookies & cream Swiss buttercream, and topped with Oreos and chocolate ganache.

To serve the sampler pack, it is recommended to leave it at room temperature for around three hours. If not serving immediately, it can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 72 hours. It is important to note that the cakes are processed on equipment that also processes peanuts and tree nuts.

Overall, Carlo's Bakery's Best Seller's Cake Slice Sampler is the perfect way to indulge in all of the bakery's most popular cakes in one sitting. With each slice offering a unique and delicious flavor, cake lovers will not be disappointed with this ultimate cake experience.

Best Italian Bakery New Jersey FAQs

Are there any Italian bakeries in New Jersey that offer gluten-free options?

Yes, there are several Italian bakeries in New Jersey that offer gluten-free options. One such bakery is Sweet Avenue Bake Shop located in Rutherford, NJ. They offer a wide variety of gluten-free baked goods, including Italian-inspired treats such as cannoli and tiramisu. Another option is Sorella's Homemade Baked Goods in Watchung, NJ, which offers gluten-free versions of their Italian pastries, including biscotti, sfogliatelle, and zeppole. La Bonbonniere Bake Shoppes, with locations in Edison and Woodbridge, NJ, also offer gluten-free options for their Italian cookies, pastries, and cakes. It is important to note that while these bakeries offer gluten-free options, cross-contamination may still occur, so those with severe gluten allergies should exercise caution.

Can you recommend an Italian bakery in New Jersey that specializes in cakes for special occasions?

Absolutely! If you're looking for an Italian bakery in New Jersey that specializes in cakes for special occasions, I would highly recommend checking out Palermo's Bakery. They have several locations throughout the state and offer a wide variety of cakes for all types of events, including weddings, birthdays, and anniversaries. Their cakes are made with high-quality ingredients and can be customized to fit your specific needs and preferences. They also offer tastings and consultations to help you choose the perfect cake for your special occasion. Additionally, Palermo's Bakery has been in business for over 25 years and has won numerous awards for their delicious and beautifully decorated cakes. Overall, I believe Palermo's Bakery would be an excellent choice for anyone looking for an Italian bakery that specializes in cakes for special occasions in New Jersey.

What are some must-try Italian baked goods in New Jersey?

As a culinary hub for Italian cuisine, New Jersey offers an array of delicious baked goods that give a taste of Italy. One must-try baked good is the cannoli, a crispy and flaky pastry filled with sweet ricotta cheese and chocolate chips. Another popular treat is the sfogliatelle, a shell-shaped pastry with a crispy outer layer and a soft, creamy filling made of ricotta cheese and semolina. For a breakfast option, try the brioche, a sweet and buttery roll that pairs perfectly with a cappuccino. Other delectable Italian baked goods to try include the pignoli cookies, almond biscotti, and amaretti cookies. Whether you have a sweet tooth or prefer savory baked goods, New Jersey's Italian bakeries have something for everyone to enjoy.

What are the best Italian bakeries in New Jersey?

New Jersey is home to several Italian bakeries that offer a wide range of delectable treats. Among the best Italian bakeries in the state are Carlo's Bakery, Monteleone's Bakery, and Vaccaro's Bakery. Carlo's Bakery is perhaps the most famous of them all, thanks to its appearance on the hit TV show Cake Boss. The bakery is known for its delicious cannoli, lobster tails, and specialty cakes, among other treats.

Monteleone's Bakery, on the other hand, has been serving the community of Jersey City since 1926. The bakery is known for its fresh bread, pastries, and cakes. Meanwhile, Vaccaro's Bakery in Clark is famous for its traditional Italian pastries, including sfogliatelle, cannoli, and biscotti. The bakery also offers a variety of cakes for special occasions. These Italian bakeries are a must-visit for anyone looking for authentic Italian treats in New Jersey.

Where can I find authentic Italian pastries in New Jersey?

If you're looking for authentic Italian pastries in New Jersey, there are several bakeries you could check out. One of the most popular is Palazzone 1960 in Montclair, which is known for its traditional Italian pastries like cannoli, sfogliatelle, and tiramisu. Another option is Pasticceria Bruno in Staten Island, which offers a wide variety of Italian desserts made with high-quality ingredients. For a taste of old-world Italian pastries, try La Promenade in Tenafly, which has been serving up classic treats like biscotti, pignoli cookies, and ricotta cheesecake for over 30 years. Other noteworthy bakeries for Italian pastries in New Jersey include Antoinette Boulangerie in Red Bank, Calandra's Bakery in Newark, and Ferrara's Bakery in Little Italy, New York (which is just across the Hudson River from New Jersey).

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Sharing is caring!